PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Why did the RAF give up nuclear weapons... (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/555852-why-did-raf-give-up-nuclear-weapons.html)

MAINJAFAD 4th Jun 2016 08:23

I see Nukemap has been updated to do cratering as well, Nice.

Wander00 4th Jun 2016 15:04

Would it improve Slough as well?

Kitbag 4th Jun 2016 16:58


Would it improve Slough as well?
Only cosmetically

ricardian 2nd Sep 2016 12:55

https://scontent-lhr3-1.xx.fbcdn.net...12&oe=5848F8D9

BEagle 2nd Sep 2016 13:42

But a hand grenade is rather more deadly than that WE177A training round....:rolleyes:

In any case, the 177A was for girls. WE177B (B for big) was the real thermonuclear big boy's toy :ok:!

Heathrow Harry 2nd Sep 2016 14:22

not if it falls on you.............

t7a 2nd Sep 2016 15:16

And that one is a 'B'.

Peter G-W 4th Sep 2016 16:00

The best-before date on the underside is Feb 74 as well.

TEEEJ 4th Sep 2016 16:52

8pm BBC2 Sunday 4th September 2016


A Very British Deterrent
Sunday 8pm

Length 1 hour
News & Documentaries, Features
The story of the remarkable events, power relationships and secret deals done half a century ago to secure Britain's very first submarine-launched nuclear missiles.
BBC Two - A Very British Deterrent

pasta 4th Sep 2016 18:58


The best-before date on the underside is Feb 74 as well.
Just be thankful it has a best-before date, and not a use-by date...

Tankertrashnav 4th Sep 2016 23:58

That was an interesting programme TEEJ

When I was a kid I lived In Carlisle and if the wind was from the east you could hear the Blue Streak engines on test at Spadeadam. Surprised there was no mention of the Thor sites, when I went to do OCTU at Feltwell in 64 the Thors hadn't long gone and some of the installations were still there.

Chugalug2 5th Sep 2016 09:37

Yes, thanks too TEEEJ, great prog. I was at Sleaford Tech 59-62, and remember the Soviet satellite and manned launches then (though little flurry at RAFC amongst we low life ;-). I also remember the subsequent Cuba Crisis (at 5FTS RAF Oakington by then). Again it took second billing as it coincided with my 21st!.

All this accounted for the many arms race US systems mentioned in the programme that allowed Super Mac to cherry-pick from, first Skybolt and then Polaris. This was when the special relationship was special both to the USA as well as to the UK. Less so these days of course, with repeated threats to banish us to "the back of the line" (sorry, queue)!

Oh, yes, I also remember the Thors, clearly visible from the main road and not that far inside the wire. It always seemed to me that a malcontent with an air-rifle could have seriously compromised them!

BEagle 5th Sep 2016 11:23

OK - but rather thin!
 
An interesting programme, but with some glaring omissions.

No real mention of the UK free-fall weapons before 1957, only a scant mention of the H-bomb OP GRAPPLE tests. No mention of Thor IRBM and Blue Steel weapons.... Neither that Skybolt worked correctly on the very day that it was cancelled.

But the Holy Loch episode was very interesting; MacMillan and Kennedy managed to find an equable solution- and without undue interference from Mountbottom.

Heathrow Harry 5th Sep 2016 13:11

It wasn't meant to be a history of the UK detererent - it was purely about the adoption of Polaris

the clue is in the PR puff....

"deals done half a century ago to secure Britain's very first submarine-launched nuclear missiles."

anyway these are TV people - not historians

MAINJAFAD 5th Sep 2016 22:52


No real mention of the UK free-fall weapons before 1957, only a scant mention of the H-bomb OP GRAPPLE tests. No mention of Thor IRBM and Blue Steel weapons.... Neither that Skybolt worked correctly on the very day that it was cancelled.
Yep, they forgot about the Skybolt test that did work, however it was mentioned that after McNamara rubbished it publicly, the option of the UK taking the missile on by themselves was a political non starter.

tartare 6th Sep 2016 00:33

Now come on lads - don't knock Slough.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1mlevv9oFuA

Pontius Navigator 8th Sep 2016 16:06

I have been asked about Valiant targeting. As the Victor and Vulcan force built up the Valiants were assigned to SACEUR as the Tactical Bomber Force. They had US laybown weapons years before WE177 entered Service.

Were they targetted by SACEUR and were those targets in WPC rather than mother Russia?

rlsbutler 12th Sep 2016 01:24

Visiting Thor
 
Thanks Chugalug (post #93). You have reminded me of my entry’s detailed exposure to Thor. I was at Sleaford Tech a year earlier – perhaps they thought better of this little exercise when it might have been your turn.

The day started with a briefing by the Stn Cdr of Hemswell. RAF Police were much in evidence, in white caps, belts and gaiters, which abashed us a bit. The old gentleman remained seated and seemed worn out and perhaps not well. His address was notably dispiriting.

We then made a long visit to RAF Coleby Grange. The squadron of old-timers made us very welcome in their hutted accommodation. We saw one of its three missiles raised, which was pretty impressive.

As a gung-ho young jet-jockey, I found the whole business bizarre. Fortunately I did my bomber Canberra first tour in Singapore, so I did not have QRA to teach me the hard truth of life on the front line in the Cold War. Coleby Grange had given me due warning and for years I more or less put it out of my mind.

Chugalug2 12th Sep 2016 21:36

risbutler:-

Fortunately I did my bomber Canberra first tour in Singapore
Fortune clearly smiled on you as it did on me. First tour at Changi as a Hastings Co-pilot. The boss claimed half the Pacific to the East, the East African coast to the West, Japan to the North, New Zealand to the South, and "all the intervening territories" as his Parish. I was lucky enough to beat the bounds to his four cardinal points before returning tour-ex to the Swinging Sixties UK. Once clear of RAFC I never returned to that land of ORPs until our 25th Reunion, long after my PVR!

BTW, the Snowdrop that you recall could be obtained in effigy form from Messrs Airfix, together with his attendant Alsatian. "Stop, or I shall release my handler!".

MAINJAFAD 13th Sep 2016 00:04


BTW, the Snowdrop that you recall could be obtained in effigy form from Messrs Airfix, together with his attendant Alsatian. "Stop, or I shall release my handler!".
That kit had a couple of Thors in it as well, but they were attached to the other dog in the kit.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:17.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.