PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Cat and mouse with guns and stuff. (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/544849-cat-mouse-guns-stuff.html)

West Coast 3rd Aug 2014 04:03

Cat and mouse with guns and stuff.
 
U.S. official: Spy plane evaded Russian tracking - CNN.com

Rhino power 3rd Aug 2014 10:23

There'll be tears before bedtime... possibly.

-RP

Hempy 3rd Aug 2014 10:47

History would suggest that when sabres start getting rattled there are really only two options. Either one side recognises that it doesn't have the wherewithal to run with the big dogs, or it doesn't.

One can only hope that common sense prevails. Sadly, this seems to be one characteristic that is in short supply on both sides of this equation.

The Russians are telling the Americans to mind their own business. I hope they listen...sometimes it's better to simply let sleeping dogs lie. Iraq on a grander scale anyone?

10W 3rd Aug 2014 11:33

Funnily enough, UK ground radars track Russian visitors in International airspace near the UK, and send up fighters to within several hundred feet of the Bears and Blinders. They don't seem to be phased by it.

Courtney Mil 3rd Aug 2014 11:39

...in the clearly defined UKADR.

Just This Once... 3rd Aug 2014 11:44

Funnily enough the UK does not have any medium or long range SAMs to lock-up any approaching Russian aircraft. Surveillance radars are one thing but people get a bit more twitchy with the more aggressive use of radars. Given that this aircraft was an RJ it would have more detailed SA on the intent and coordination behind this action than any other platform.

10W 3rd Aug 2014 12:09

Fair point. Presumably the Russians have an ADIZ, making the RJ fair game for any tracking action, including defensive SAM's, until it is identified and intentions are known. It's not unknown for US warships to do the same in international waters. If it was a real attack threat, you'd probably look a bit silly if you didn't have your defence systems locked on and ready to go, just in case you upset someone who is there to probe your defences.

ShotOne 3rd Aug 2014 12:19

Playing cold-war games in international airspace to probe/challenge/whatever, with or without an ADIZ is one thing. But this RJ flew unannounced right through Swedish territory. How would the US respond if a foreign military reconnaissance aircraft did the same thing over the USA.?

Rhino power 3rd Aug 2014 12:51


Originally Posted by ShotOne
How would the US respond if a foreign military reconnaissance aircraft did the same thing over the USA.?

Assuming it was an ally, who was avoiding a potential threat at short notice (as seems to be the case with the RJ), I would imagine they would be a bit miffed but, would get over it...

-RP

fleigle 3rd Aug 2014 14:10

Do you not think that the Swedes knew exactly what was flying over their border?.
f

West Coast 3rd Aug 2014 14:46


The Russians are telling the Americans to mind their own business. I hope they listen...sometimes it's better to simply let sleeping dogs lie. Iraq on a grander scale anyone?
In other words, kiss Putin's arse a bit more. These are the times that the west must have as much information as possible about what Ivan, err, Vlad is up to.
You must remember this has been going on for decades, they send their spy planes, we the west send up our spy planes, there's no precedent set by a 135 being in the area. Should the US get its hackles up because a bear circled Guam a few months back or the bears that fly up and down the west coast of the US? No, send something pointy up to have a look and be done with it assuming all are playing their roles appropriately.

Business as usual old boy. The only real noteworthy part of this is what spooked the crew to escape into Sweedish airspace.

ShotOne 3rd Aug 2014 15:31

"..be a bit miffed and then get over it?" Mmm, yes well I can recall being spoken to, shouted to, rather by some teenager on a USN warship commanding me to alter course to avoid lethal force. Although he may in fact have been talking to several other airliners all going about their lawful business, hard to tell. And that was in the Indian Ocean which is er, quite a long way from the USA.

West Coast 3rd Aug 2014 15:47

Yawn...nothing to do with the events of a few days ago.

Two's in 3rd Aug 2014 17:01

Surely the whole point of a SIGINT mission is to get "painted" by the equipment you are scrutinizing, while not being shot down by it of course.

brickhistory 3rd Aug 2014 17:08


Presumably the Russians have an ADIZ, making the RJ fair
game for any tracking action, including defensive SAM's, until it is identified
and intentions are known.
https://sp1.yimg.com/ib/th?id=HN.608...3&pid=15.1&P=0

DARK MATTER 3rd Aug 2014 17:55

Just a little more background..
Swedish Media Says U.S. Spyplane Recently Violated Swedish Airspace - Matthew Aid

walter kennedy 4th Aug 2014 12:44

They may think the others are as trigger happy as themselves - the Iranian airliner? :ooh:

melmothtw 4th Aug 2014 13:46

Maybe the US crew knew their history, and were all too aware of the Sov..sorry, Russian propensity to shoot down unarmed surveillance aircraft over international waters in the Baltic region...

Catalina affair - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Cows getting bigger 4th Aug 2014 14:47

When I were a lad we used to look upon this sort of thing as sport. How times have changed. :)

ShotOne 4th Aug 2014 14:50

If so, they appeared to have relied rather heavily on the noted Swedish good nature; there are many parts of the world where such a breach of good manners would end violently.


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:27.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.