PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Cause for ALARM? (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/532800-cause-alarm.html)

Lowe Flieger 27th Jan 2014 17:57

Cause for ALARM?
 
RAF retires ALARM missile ? FighterControl ? Home to the Military Aviation Enthusiast

The link relates to a report on another website quoting a Janes article about retirement of the Alarm missile from the RAF inventory. I didn't really know what to think of this: is it another shocking retirement in the pursuit of economies before requirements or is it the timely passing of a system that has had its day?

What do the knowledgeable folks think about this?

(I couldn't find a reference to this already having been raised on PPRuNe, but if I have duplicated a post, apologies.)

LF

cobalt42 27th Jan 2014 18:34

Motors/Warheads Life-ex? :ugh:

Same happened with Sea Eagle...

chopper2004 27th Jan 2014 18:43

Thought ALARM went donkeys ago, for the sake of AGM-65 on the then JFH and for the likes of Brimstone and Storm Shadow?

Not even too sure if HARM is used / carried much nowadays across the pond?

Cheers

Rhino power 27th Jan 2014 23:14


Originally Posted by chopper2004
Not even too sure if HARM is used / carried much nowadays across the pond?

HARM (AGM-88) is still very much in use 'across the pond'... AGM-45 and AGM-78 are long gone however.

Wasn't ALARM supposed to be replaced by the Dual Mode Brimstone or some such?

-RP

Martin the Martian 28th Jan 2014 10:15

I wouldn't be too happy trying to take out a SAM radar site at a range of seven miles with Brimstone.

I believe the SA-6 has a range of 15 miles, while the SA-2 is about 28 miles.

Something else for us to rely on our 'coalition partners' for, no doubt.

GOLF_BRAVO_ZULU 28th Jan 2014 11:53

Wasn't the true value of ALARM it's "loiter" capability?

Dan Winterland 28th Jan 2014 12:37

Just hangin' around.

newt 28th Jan 2014 12:55

If no threat detected then it deployed a parachute!! Very Mickey Mouse!

GOLF_BRAVO_ZULU 28th Jan 2014 13:35

If it kept the "lights" off long enough to press home an attack, surely help from Mickey Mouse was better than getting Donald Ducked?

Navaleye 28th Jan 2014 13:45

By all accounts I heard it was a good piece of kit. Why not refurb them? Must cheaper than buying new.

Clad 28th Jan 2014 14:03

Cause for ALARM?
 
Another capability gap! No replacement!

Just wonder about a 'no fly' zone example like in Iraq - where patrolling RAF carried (alarm) in case of being targeted. By the time someone else came in to take out the SAM they will have moved. No fixed SAM loitering in a war zone!

Mind you fits well with no carriers, MPA aircraft lists goes on really. As much as the falklands example is now a bit overdone.... the UK is really going to struggle if we have to go it alone again.

cokecan 28th Jan 2014 15:41

i hear/read that SPEAR CAP3 is supposed to be the 'replacement' - anyone got any idea as to whether it will be available before the end of the decade?

chopper2004 28th Jan 2014 16:17

ALARM mock up on Lynx HAS.1
 
I recall seeing in Paul Beaver's UK Modern Military Missiles book, on the bit about ALARM, there was a photo of a mock ALARM missile on a RN Lynx.

(from above book)

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g2...ps46906bf8.jpg

I don't recall any trials, but maybe I was wrong, how far did the FAA look into arming the likes of the Lynx with this missile? Or was it a BAe publicity shot?

Cheers

Not_a_boffin 28th Jan 2014 16:30


By all accounts I heard it was a good piece of kit. Why not refurb them? Must cheaper than buying new.
I refer you to this...

http://i1.mirror.co.uk/incoming/arti...te-1990350.jpg

Which is swiftly followed by Defence Planning Assumption 1. "Someone Else" will provide Capability [X].

NURSE 29th Jan 2014 11:01

given current defence thinking not surprised the Taliban don't have Radar guided missiles so we don't need them!


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:31.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.