PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   US 'Bomb' World heritage Site (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/519582-us-bomb-world-heritage-site.html)

AC3854 24th Jul 2013 05:37

They were aiming at Tasmania though ...

500N 24th Jul 2013 05:47

As long as they hit Greenie Bob and his side kick (I'm being polite),
no one would care.

rjtjrt 24th Jul 2013 05:52


They were aiming at Tasmania though ...
Possibly had the co-ordinates for Austria set.

Eclectic 24th Jul 2013 07:04

I have dived many of the world's coral reefs. Several points.
1) Man has been damaging reefs on an epic scale for centuries. In the Middle East the reefs were mined to produce building blocks that cities were built from. Thousands of ships have wrecked themselves on reefs. Lots of war has happened on reefs. Dynamite fishing of Philippine reefs has done immense amounts of damage. As bad as rainforest depletion.
2) Reefs are living things and thus are amazingly resilient. In fact they can be manufactured. Put some concrete shapes on a sandy bottom in the tropics and pretty soon it is colonised by coral.
3) These practice bombs in the enormity of the Great Barrier Reef are far less than insignificant. Like a grain of sand on a big beach.
4) Recovering the bombs would be relatively simple.
5) The bombs could become a tourist attraction.

Howabout 24th Jul 2013 13:36

As the guys before have said, this is a total non-issue. 2 x BDU and 2 x HE (unidentified, but I suspect MK83s).

They were jettisoned "safe." Hell will freeze over before the things explode.

As usual, with an election coming up, our greenies are trying to get mileage by panicking a dumb public on matters they know squat about - the greenies and the public.

As the old bumper sticker said:

"Fertilise the forest; doze in a greenie."

melmothtw 24th Jul 2013 14:37

A slightly different take on the story...

US steps up war against nature

500N 24th Jul 2013 14:40

The Greenies worry about 4 bombs which might cover
a few feet of coral, if it hits coral and not sand yet no
mention of nutrients, fertilizer and silt that comes down
rivers and blankets the whole reef !!!

melmothtw 24th Jul 2013 15:01


The Greenies worry about 4 bombs which might cover
a few feet of coral, if it hits coral and not sand yet no
mention of nutrients, fertilizer and silt that comes down
rivers and blankets the whole reef !!!
To be fair, I think that if this story was about nutrients and fertilizers spilling into the sea and contaminating the reef then I think the "greenies' probably would have something to say about it.

The only reason they're now banging on about bombs being dropped on the reef is because that's pretty much what happened in this particular case....

rigpiggy 24th Jul 2013 16:44

the iron leaching from the casings will stimulate algae therefore bringing wildlife to feed, the sand inside when they crumble, well it is sand

West Coast 25th Jul 2013 02:26

If a quid pro quo would ease tensions, start with San Fran, Debtroit, errr Detroit or DC. Or all of them.


All times are GMT. The time now is 18:59.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.