PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Here it comes: Syria (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/513470-here-comes-syria.html)

dead_pan 10th Sep 2013 16:31

Yes, that prospect was raised by a BBC journo this morning. Its going to be hellishly difficult to supervise the collection and removal of this kit in the middle of a war.

air pig 10th Sep 2013 16:38

Dead pan:


Yes, that prospect was raised by a BBC journo this morning. Its going to be hellishly difficult to supervise the collection and removal of this kit in the middle of a war.
I think that comment is British understatement, hellishly difficult is more like bloody impossible in the middle of an active war zone. If it is removed, how do you verify you have it all, where do you store it, is there a facility to destroy it and who does it and who secures it prior to destruction.

Eclectic 10th Sep 2013 16:42

It is just a red herring. A delaying tactic.
Assad will never allow intrusive enforcement.
And he will insist on lots of conditions.
Perhaps he will request all states stop their aid to the opposition (military or otherwise), and engage the US in confidence building, ie a couple of tons out of Syria every month in exchange for the above mentioned actions. Putin, Iran, and the UN will perceive such actions to be positive and continue supporting a diplomatic solution.
Putin and Assad will twist this into an Assad wins situation. Lots of Sunnis and Kurds will die.
And at the end of the process Assad will still have lots of chemical weapons.

Obama should launch tonight whilst he still has some surprise.

air pig 10th Sep 2013 16:50

Eclectic:


It is just a red herring. A delaying tactic.
Assad will never allow intrusive enforcement.
And he will insist on lots of conditions.
Perhaps he will request all states stop their aid to the opposition (military or otherwise), and engage the US in confidence building, ie a couple of tons out of Syria every month in exchange for the above mentioned actions. Putin, Iran, and the UN will perceive such actions to be positive and continue supporting a diplomatic solution.
Putin and Assad will twist this into an Assad wins situation. Lots of Sunnis and Kurds will die.
And at the end of the process Assad will still have lots of chemical weapons.

Obama should launch tonight whilst he still has some surprise.
You really have an axe to grind here, almost warmongering. Reflect if you fire on Syria, what do you achieve, if anything, what exit strategy do you have and as I have said before dying by a burst of AK 47, artillery barrage or by Sarin, you just as DEAD. This is an internal, inter-religious factional war, of which I want my country to have NO part.

NutLoose 10th Sep 2013 16:53

You could just launch it all into the med :E

That's got to be a nightmare job, recovering that little lot in the middle of a war, no doubt somewhere along the line Hague will be volunteering the Army to go in to get it and the RAF to fly it out.

Lonewolf_50 10th Sep 2013 17:03

Practical problems in re removal of Syrian stockpile of chem weapons, and whatever remains of it as of this writing ...

1. How does one confirm where "it all is?"
2. How does one control shipment of it out of Syria, during a civil war?
3. How does one detect some of it going astray?
4. Who is charged with protecting the movements to container ship in whatever port is chosen. (Do you ship it all to Jordan over land? :eek: )

Answers on a post card.

Eclectic 10th Sep 2013 17:24

Just like I predicted: REUTERS: Putin says Syria chemical weapons handover will only work if US rejects use of force.

Conditions, conditions, conditions.
Putin and Assad have no good intentions, just narrow self interest. They are playing the West.

And the elephant in the room is Iran. With Obama a dead duck the road is clear for the mad mullahs to go nuclear. Which they would be very happy to use.

btw Assad has about 1,000 tons of chemical agents and Sarin has a lethal concentration for 1 minute exposure of 0.1 to 0.07 mg per human. So he can kill everyone on planet earth several times over.

Ronald Reagan 10th Sep 2013 17:31

Hopefully the Russians can get a resolution through the security council which does not have any mention of military action in it, the French one is full of threats. Seems a bad way to go about it. Good job we have Putin the peacemaker on the the case, great man that he is.

NutLoose 10th Sep 2013 17:34

Still got the thumb screw on huh.

Broadsword*** 10th Sep 2013 17:42


The US, UK and France are to table a UN Security Council resolution but Russia has already indicated opposition.

The resolution will call on Syria to publicly declare that it has a chemical weapons programme, place it under international control and dismantle it.

But French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius said he had spoken on Tuesday to Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov, who told him that Moscow was not in favour of a binding UN resolution.
BBC News - Syria conflict: US issues warning on chemicals plan

So it appears Assad will continue to get Russia's unconditional support, no matter what he does (or does not do).

dead_pan 10th Sep 2013 17:43


REUTERS: Putin says Syria chemical weapons handover will only work if US rejects use of force
Well what a surprise. That particular piece of smallprint is going to be a deal-breaker, I fear. Time to start marching back up the hill.

Toadstool 10th Sep 2013 17:58


With Obama a dead duck the road is clear for the mad mullahs to go nuclear. Which they would be very happy to use.
Where did you get this inside knowledge? Have IRAN got the bomb now? Have they stated that they will use it?

Broadsword*** 10th Sep 2013 18:04

UN resolution on Syria to test if Russian chemical weapons plan is 'ruse' | World news | theguardian.com

From 'Putin the peacemaker' to 'Putin the peace faker' in the space of 24 hours. He ain't all that smart.

ShotOne 10th Sep 2013 18:15

This is a no-lose deal from our point of view; whichever side wins there, we don't want them having sarin etc. And it doesn't necessarily stop those who feel that lobbing in a load of missiles will solve things from doing so at some later date if they really want to.

Eclectic 10th Sep 2013 18:17

@Toadstool

Iran nuclear

Iran nuclear - Haaretz | Israel News

Iran's Nuclear Program

Toadstool 10th Sep 2013 18:38

Ah yes of course, my misunderstanding. It is a fact that they have nuclear reactors and would more than likely wish to obtain a nuclear weapon. I wasn't aware that they had a death wish and had stated that they would be more than happy to use such a weapon if they had it.

Eclectic 10th Sep 2013 19:26

C&P:

JUST IN: U.S. House Democrat Chris van Hollen just told me on CNN International that a proposed House resolution on Syria would give the president 30 days to work out a credible plan on chemical weapons before he would be allowed to use military force.

“There are thirty days, and in that thirty days the president can continue to try to work out the solution. If after thirty days the president says that we have either secured that chemical stockpile or that’s there’s a credible plan to do it, then you would not proceed with limited force. But if makes another determination, he would be allowed to go forward.”
CNN

Courtney Mil 10th Sep 2013 19:38


Originally Posted by LoneWolf
(Post 1450) Answers on a post card.

See my post 1489 - a bit tongue in cheek, but an element of truth. http://www.pprune.org/8040658-post1489.html

As for you "I'd rather be lucky than good", it got me through 30 years in the RAF and my fast jet years. :ok:

racedo 10th Sep 2013 20:04


Interesting map:

http://images1.ynet.co.il/PicServer3.../4851307/3.jpg

This is big and detailed so resizing it would reduce its value.
Also I am not hosting it.
FAKE

Date of production of map FEB 2012.

Eclectic 10th Sep 2013 20:16

Why does "Date of production of map FEB 2012" make it fake?

Someone has taken a commercial map and added the data. You can do that sort of stuff these days with computers.


All times are GMT. The time now is 19:39.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.