PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   New Years Honours List 2013 - Names we know! (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/503897-new-years-honours-list-2013-names-we-know.html)

EMU_1 28th Dec 2012 23:08

New Years Honours List 2013 - Names we know!
 
BBC already posted the link, will add the MoD website main link when they eventually publish.

Lots of names we all recognise.

RAF List Here

Alternatively, for Purple entries, Dept list starts at page 8: link here

Yeller_Gait 29th Dec 2012 00:58

That list should just about cover everyone left in the RAF, hands up those who did not get an individual or team award.

The awards list seems to get longer each year, for fewer people each year.

Well done to all :D:D:D

Y_G

Roland Pulfrew 29th Dec 2012 07:57


The awards list seems to get longer each year,
Must be the reverse of wagon wheels, mars bars etc, I was thinking the (RAF) list seems to be ever smaller, despite being on permanent operations since 1990!!

dctyke 29th Dec 2012 08:07

Never seen this one on the list before:

President RAF Cricket Asscn
Chief of the Air Staff Commendation

And no 'team' award.

chinook240 29th Dec 2012 08:08

EMU,
Your cut and paste missed out 2 very important RAF awards:

PROMOTIONS IN AND APPOINTMENTS TO THE MILITARY DIVISION OF THE MOST HONOURABLE ORDER OF THE BATH

As Knight Commander

Air Marshal Timothy Michael ANDERSON CB DSO

Air Marshal Andrew Douglas PULFORD CBE

Tankertrashnav 29th Dec 2012 08:27

I have to admit to being a little out of date on the honours system. What exactly is a team award? Is this something that appears in the London Gazette along with the OBEs, MBEs, etc, or is it something that is entirely in-service?

I've been following these lists since I left in 1977. For many years it was pleasant to see old chums' names from time to time. Now it's chastening to realise that 99% of those on this list probably weren't even in the service when I left (and some not born!) Well done to all anyway.

Spanish Waltzer 29th Dec 2012 08:33

An interesting choice of picture to head the RAF list on EMU's link...:E

.....ah so someone somewhere does glance at pprune occasionally! The RN sea king to which I was referring has quietly been replaced by a mighty RAF Tornado.....well done RAF PR!

HNY SW

c130jbloke 29th Dec 2012 08:41

So of the 26 gongs of MBE and above, all but 9 go to officers and the lowest rank to receive an award was a Sgt.......

So what exactly did all these people do to deserve an award ?

A and C 29th Dec 2012 08:58

Question
 
I know of a guy who has been a civilian instructor on an Air Training Corps squadron for the best part of 40 years, the guy is a leading light of the trainning program and this is reflected in the cadets exam results.

I can't help thinking that voluntary work over such a long period should get some sort of award but I fear that the guy has been in post for so long that the upper management see him as part of the furniture and have not considered putting his name forward.

Would any of the other members of this forum like to comment on if this guy sounds like a suitable candidate for consideration for some sort of award?

Jambo Jet 29th Dec 2012 09:07

He does, but until somebody writes an appropriate citation on the correct form and then gets your OC to endorse the application, nobody will be aware.....

Over to you, I think....

Bigpants 29th Dec 2012 10:10

Telegraph 26 Dec
 
"CBEs and above are problematic. While it is certainly the case that outstanding individuals do receive knighthoods, these deserving men and women are obliged to rub shoulders with a number of others who have carried out some disreputable act. A knighthood is far too often a sign that the recipient may have kept quiet about something he or she should have made public, done some illicit favour for the government of the day, paid a large sum of money into the bank account of a major political party or (in the case of civil servants) is being rewarded for not rocking the boat over an extended period of years. It goes without saying that peerages are even more dubious, as the wholly disreputable conduct of so many peers once they arrive in the House of Lords proves."

"is being rewarded for not rocking the boat over an extended period of years"

"the recipient may have kept quiet about something he or she should have made public"

Take your pick....

Tableview 29th Dec 2012 11:01

Kate Bush, Tracey Emin, ........honoured

Would anyone honour me if I shrieked meaningless lyrics out of tune, or put my dirty bedding into a museum? No, thought not.


What an utter disgrace. Added to which, I may be wrong, but I seem to recall that Emin woman making some very anti-Royal family statements a while ago. And someone that ugly doesn't deserve recognition anyway!

Melchett01 29th Dec 2012 11:50


So what exactly did all these people do to deserve an award?
c130jbloke - Although said in response to a different question, Jambo Jet has also answered your question. These individuals were fortunate enough to have a chain of command that actually thought about their troops, had the good fortune to be able to string a coherent sentence together and then actually been bothered to write the citation in the first place.

It is my opinion that as an organisational whole, the RAF is shockingly bad at putting its people forward for honours and awards compared to the other services. There seems to have been a gradual move over the years to a mindset of you are paid to do your job, so just being good at what you do isn't enough. A couple of years ago, I put one of my FS's name forward for an award precisely for that very reason; he had shown, over many many years, a level of technical ability and personal qualities that lead to an unusual level of respect and trust by his peers, subordinates and seniors. He ended up getting an MBE and was the only RAF name on that list that received such an award for being exceptional at what he did. That he was the only recipient on that basis was also noted by Air Cmd when they put out a report noting a degree of disappointment that Chains of Command weren't recognising individuals for their abilities at a time of high op tempo.

Now there are those who suggest that being good at your job is what you get paid and promoted for. I would have agreed entirely until recently, but as Big Pants notes, the Telegraph seems to have summed things up far more eloquently than I ever could. Furthemore, a quick look at the link to the Cabinet Office honours page suggests that


72% of recipients are people who have undertaken outstanding work in their communities either in a voluntary or paid capacity
So it seems that these days being paid should no longer be seen as a barrier to deserving individuals being nominated.

Some of the wider nominations did also raise an eyebrow at Melchett Towers this morning, including as Tableview notes, that Emin creature. The number of Olympic awards, whilst unsurprising and welcome after one of the few bright spots in an otherwise pretty dismal year, does also highlight the inconsistencies in Govt policy towards double medalling. If the Armed Forces cannot accept and wear NATO or other medals for operations where a UK medal has been awarded, does that mean the Olympic recipients will have to hand their medals back? No? Thought as much, the usual double standards by politicians where it suits.

cuefaye 29th Dec 2012 12:56

I say again - Sir Bradley Wiggins -FFS

brokenlink 29th Dec 2012 14:41

A & C - ATC Civilian Instructors should get a Commandants Commendation after prescribed periods of service, will have to check but I think it starts at 14 years and includes one at 26 years. However it all depends on the system being reminded that it is due. If you need the info please PM me and I'll dig it out for you.

Regards, BL

Aileron Drag 29th Dec 2012 15:32

When I left a Volunteer Gliding Sqn as an A2 CGI after 20 years, I didn't even get a 'thank you' letter.

Not that I was surprised. The CO had put in thirty-odd years, and he didn't get one either!

Mick Jagger got a 'K' though, so that's alright. And Bruce Bleedin' Forsyth. :ugh:

denachtenmai 29th Dec 2012 16:05

Cherie, Mrs BLAIR For services to Women's Issues and to
charity in the UK and Overseas.
Speechless:uhoh:
Regards, Den.

Danny42C 29th Dec 2012 17:37

"Who hath Honour ? Him that died o' Wednesday! (Falstaff: Henry IV Part 1)
 
Apopcryphal Story from a Long Time Ago:

The time is late December 1940; the New Year's Honours List has just been made public.

An M.P. stands up in the Commons * "What about the knights who ride on the wings of Spitfires ?"

* Would the Commons be sitting then ? Don't know - there was a War on !

Nothing changes.

Danny42C.

TheWizard 29th Dec 2012 18:02

HM speaks out
 
Here is the 'official' reasons for the awards*
Queen's New Year honours*Socialvoices on MSN News UK


"Strange how all these raging republicans are quite happy to be associated with Royalty when one is placing ribbons round their necks. Sometimes would rather put something else around their necks but the ceremonial noose is up in the attic somewhere along with hundreds of placemats and Andrew's model helicopter collection."


*(Not actually factual)

OldnDaft 29th Dec 2012 19:55

I was very pleased to see one of my former SAC's get a commendation - I drafted the submission and the individual thoroughly deserved the award.

bobward 29th Dec 2012 19:59

ATC Awards
 
I've been an ATC instructor since 1975. In that time I served 25 years in uniform (ATC WO then commissioned). I was awarded a Cadet Forces Medal, followed by a Bar. Since then, nothing. I'm not complaining. Like many others I do it to help the kids realise their ambitions, be it in the services or the outside. The real reward comes when an ex-cadet comes back and starts off with 'I really enjoyed my time here...;

Maybe I'm old fashioned - I just find that much more rewarding than anything else.....

Happy New Year to all the other hard-working CI's and uniformed staff out there.

Cheers
Bob

PS,
My late father did 25 years as a JP, as well 50 years as a football referee, and then as an assessor. Anyone like to guess what he got for all that???

Aileron Drag 29th Dec 2012 23:23

OldnDaft,

Good for you.

BigGreenGilbert,

I suspect his argument is that the man has been well rewarded for his success, and will now become a multi-millionaire. Quite right too - he deserves it.

But 'honours' should not be about 'success', but 'service'. It should be about years of effort with little or no reward, and for the benefit of our society. Not about winning more gold medals than anyone else, hosting 'Strictly Come Dancing', or having three thousand platinum discs to your accountant's credit.

Service. Service is what should be recognised. And it isn't.

Tankertrashnav 30th Dec 2012 10:07

Sir Bradley? Dont see anything unusual there. There are plenty of precedents from way back, including Sir Stanley Matthews, Sir Don Bradman and Sir Gordon Richards. All good blokes, no doubt, but they were knighted for their sporting achievements and Wiggins is no different. I know nothing about cycling as a sport, seems like a refined form of masochism to me, but good luck to the guy I say.

cuefaye 30th Dec 2012 10:30

Big Green

Oh I did explain, but my post (not rude or abusive) was 'removed'. It was to do with his tweeting immediately after attaining his Gold, and his attitude to a certain Lady at the BBC Awards; I guess someone is litigation-sensitive.

Happy New Year

Heathrow Harry 30th Dec 2012 10:31

Can anyone explain why all the Senior ranks get gongs when we aren't doing very much?

Are they not paid??

ancientaviator62 30th Dec 2012 10:52

Melchett01
several times I have tried to write up people for the awards in question. Despite following the 'crib' sheet as instructed I was only successful once. Now you may argue that I was not up to the job. But when you are told that the station's allocation of a particular 'gong' has already been decided then it is a mite discouraging. However I always mentioned the fact that he/she had been recommended in the individual's ACR . I was once told that it was going to a chap for services to the station Catholic Church and when I suggested in that case the Pope ought to honour him I got a flea in my ear.

RUCAWO 30th Dec 2012 11:50

With the ATC it really is down to the chain of command, a lot of staff with over ten yrs service, including CIs, in my wing have Lord Lieutenants Certificates (even I got one) or have been nominated for them, the previous Wg Cdr had an OBE and there have been numerous commendations for other staff. If you are on a Sqn and you believe someone deserves recognition say to your boss, he may just not thought about it.
Just looked at the list, one of our padres got the MBE :ok:

SaddamsLoveChild 30th Dec 2012 15:17

Oh dear, Oh dear......I can imagine Execs at Odi/Ben being a bit down in the mouth when they see that the self licking JHC u write me up and I'll write u up didnt go as planned this year........cynicism or truth?

Moi/ 30th Dec 2012 17:55

Another year, Another year our section/camp/location not mentioned even with the amount of "bungee cord" work we carry out.....

This will be one of the things raised when i go for my clearing interview.

Rigga 30th Dec 2012 20:27

+Okay, I'm out the RAF now but I have read through the link in interest. I have a question.


I can see what Timo has done (not that I agree with it) but what has Jools done? (And I do not mean to be insulting, just out of curiosity)

MightyGem 30th Dec 2012 20:46

Full Military list here:
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/n...ence-civilians

Whenurhappy 31st Dec 2012 07:47

Heathrow Harry,

What do you mean that we (the RAF) have not been busy? I know that you've been out for a while, but it can't have escaped your notice that the Op tempo remains very, very high indeed.

AR1 31st Dec 2012 08:07


Would anyone honour me if I shrieked meaningless lyrics out of tune,
Now hold on there. As most men brought up in the '70's will tell - You cant beat a bit of Bush.

NutLoose 31st Dec 2012 15:42

And let her wail while you're at it...


I for one loathe awards, why should someone be honoured for simply doing their job is beyond me.. Now if it was Aunty Betty etc down the road who for 40 years has given her time for free to help the local kids, then they deserve an OBE, not some old fart that has simply reached the rank of AVM etc, that's simply collecting badges as you go along, rather like McDonald's staff and their stars... Pointless and worthless.


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:04.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.