PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Military Aircraft Based at Civilian Airports. (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/391182-military-aircraft-based-civilian-airports.html)

hisnamesake 5th Oct 2009 06:31

Military Aircraft Based at Civilian Airports.
 
I see this happening in many places in the world and it is something I am not that keen on seeing.

Surely the civilian airport which hosts military aircraft, is a valid military target, in time of conflict, thereby putting innocent civilians at risk. I am aware we fight a war to win at all costs, so I guess it doesn't really matter does it?

As with all things is probably a question of economics.

Yeller_Gait 5th Oct 2009 07:07

I would also suggest that a majority of civil/mil combined airports started out as military airfields, so it is more a case that civilians now use military airfields rather than the military moving into civilian airports.

As you rightly point out, it is economics, and convenience for passengers with the increase in local airports.

Y_G

Karl Bamforth 5th Oct 2009 07:22

All airports, civil or military are an early target in a time of war.

Just because its not military now doesn't stop it being used as such in a time of conflict.

foldingwings 5th Oct 2009 13:59

Autobahns in Eastern & Western Europe were planned to be used as military runways during the Cold War and such strips of highway still offer that as a planned facility in many places on the Globe today. Does that mean it's time to hand in your driving licence, 'hisnamesake'?!!:ugh:

By the way, does your:


thereby putting innocent civilians at risk
mean to suggest that those in the military are guilty of some ill-thought out charge (of yours)?

Foldie:bored:

PS. Thinks, time somebody woke up and smelt the coffee!!!!

airborne_artist 5th Oct 2009 14:11

Better move all those barracks out of town/city centres, and stop people going shopping in uniform.

Wait for it - we already did that....:ok:

hisnamesake 5th Oct 2009 14:50

Thanks for the replies.

Would any of you be prepared to set up a machine gun to fire from a hospital, or from a group hostages or POW's using them as shelter?

I am intrigued to know where the "line would be drawn".

J.A.F.O. 5th Oct 2009 14:58

Perhaps people should check out the Trolls are still being fed thread.

Gainesy 5th Oct 2009 15:09

I would have no worries about machine-gunning an un-armed Teddy Bear in a Red Cross uniform while his parachute was hung up in a tree.

Now go and do your homework.

airborne_artist 5th Oct 2009 15:17


I am intrigued to know where the "line would be drawn".
In the sand. It's in the rules. "We will fight them on the beaches" - WS Churchill 4th June 1940.

Play with Teddy if you have no homework.

goudie 5th Oct 2009 15:17

Get real. In total war there is no such 'line'


I am intrigued to know where the "line would be drawn
".

The Real Slim Shady 5th Oct 2009 15:19


In the sand. It's in the rules. "We will fight them on the beaches" - W Churchill 4th June 1940.
Pure genius.
10 out of 10 AA
:D

minigundiplomat 5th Oct 2009 15:20

hisnamesake,

This thread, and you also it seems, have no point.

You are the weakest link, goodbye.

foldingwings 5th Oct 2009 15:30


Would any of you be prepared to set up a machine gun to fire from a hospital, or from a group hostages or POW's using them as shelter?
No but I know somebody who would?

Ah, sh*t, no! His own guys hanged him in Baghdad a few years ago, so that won't work.

Hey this is fun. Keep em coming, ferchrisesake!

Foldie

Ivan Rogov 5th Oct 2009 15:34

Be intrigued no more, this is "where the line is drawn"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of...Project_(RULAC)

old developer 5th Oct 2009 15:45

I didn't realise they had Trolls in Bolivia :)

hisnamesake 5th Oct 2009 15:47

So if you're not prepared to do that? Well what the hell is the tax payer paying you for? To win a war or fight it with your hands behind your backs?

I dont have to tell you, our dear enemy the Taliban don't give a rats about the "rules". So are you there to win or loose?! If you are going to stick to the rules you will loose.

No I am not a troll, just an old civilian pilot coming to the end of his career, who has been spared the horrors of war and may that continue. I did ask what I considered a pertinent question. I received a few smart arsed replies so I added another question to feed the know it alls.

foldingwings 5th Oct 2009 15:53

Bored now but unfortunately the Mods won't allow me to tell you where to go!:bored:

goudie 5th Oct 2009 15:55

No one likes a smart arse


I received a few smart arsed replies so I added another question to feed the know it alls.

A2QFI 5th Oct 2009 17:34

Military aircraft, based at jointly operated airfields, could also be at risk from suicide bombers trying to blow up airliners, so it cuts both ways!

jayteeto 5th Oct 2009 17:42

If you can't play by the fair rules then its time to give up. Whats the point of fighting 'them' if you are the same as them??
PS. Military units rarely get targeted, they go for underground stations/buses/market places/civilian airliners/etc. If you use your logic from post 1, the SAFEST place would be an airfield with military aircraft. :ok:


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:50.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.