PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   Medal Awards (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/258554-medal-awards.html)

SPIT 4th Jan 2007 17:22

Medal Awards
 
Hi
Being a bit of an ignorance ?? about this I thought that the VC could only be awarded for VALOUR in a Declared War. If I am wrong (again) would somebody please explain it to me as there is a small wager in the local !!! :confused: :confused:

PPRuNe Pop 4th Jan 2007 17:36

Don't know about an actual declaration of war but it is the UK's highest award for bravery (valour) by a military person in the presence of the enemy.

Simple but true.

cooheed 4th Jan 2007 17:53

War was not declared by either side during the Falklands Conflict, yet 2 were awarded for acts of valour in the face of the enemy. Seems crystal to me.

Farmer 1 4th Jan 2007 18:05


The Victoria Cross (VC) is the highest recognition for valour "in the face of the enemy" that can be awarded to members of the British and Commonwealth armed forces of any rank in any service, and civilians under military command. It is also the highest military award in the British honours system.
(Wikipedia)
No mention of the declared war bit, though. Definitely for valour, though. At least, that's what it says on the medal.

Mystic Greg 4th Jan 2007 19:46

And the award is not restricted to military personnel - VCs can be (and have been) awarded to civilians for valour in the face of the enemy.

airborne_artist 4th Jan 2007 19:58


in a Declared War
I suspect that a declared war went out with gents wearing bowler hats to work in the City etc. A wonderful relic of the days of chivalry, but not quite Noo Liabour PC I feel. These days it's all based around UN resolution XXX

FOMere2eternity 4th Jan 2007 20:15


Originally Posted by airborne_artist (Post 3051074)
These days it's all based around UN resolution XXX

Or spirit of a previous UN resolution if you can't quite get one to go along with your predetermined plan...

fantom 4th Jan 2007 20:24


Originally Posted by SPIT (Post 3050856)
Hi
Being a bit of an ignorance ?? about this I thought that the VC could only be awarded for VALOUR in a Declared War. If I am wrong (again) would somebody please explain it to me as there is a small wager in the local !!! :confused: :confused:

Go and have another beer.

day1-week1 4th Jan 2007 20:28

It doesn't have to be a declared war but it does have to be 'in the face of the enemy'. Recently in afgan a para cpl was awarded the VC (pos) for storming a taliban MG postion. Another guy was killed when he rescued his section from a minefield and was killed in the process. He was awarded the GC (pos). Whilst by all accounts he displayed the utmost bravary worthy of a VC in his actions, as his act was not 'in the face of the enemy' and therefore didn't meet the criteria for the VC. I think there have been a few similar incidents in Iraq in the last few years.

Clockwork Mouse 4th Jan 2007 21:30

A state of war exists when the armed forces of two countries engage intentionally in warlike acts against each other. Doesn't have to be formally declared. Hitler never declared war on anyone, just went in. We Brits, of course, did it properly and officially after giving him an ultimatum. The Japs actually intended to declare war on the US before Pearl Harbour but their embassy cocked up the timing.
There were Brit VCs in the Indonesian confrontation and Aussie ones in Vietnam.

Archimedes 4th Jan 2007 21:52

VCs were awarded during several colonial policing campaigns as well - and if the declared war criteria existed, we'd have had to have (in effect) declared war on ourselves for the VC awards to be permissible.

There was one VC in the Indonesian Confrontation, awarded to Rambahadur Limbu.

SPIT 4th Jan 2007 22:06

Hi
THANK YOU FOR THE REPLY'S GENTS, all is a LOT CLEARER NOW but it cost me some beers but it cost some of the BRAVE HOLDERS a LOT MORE that a few beers:ok: :ok: :ok:
All the BEST
SPIT:

Aynayda Pizaqvick 4th Jan 2007 22:23


Originally Posted by SPIT (Post 3051262)
Hi
THANK YOU FOR THE REPLY'S GENTS, all is a LOT CLEARER NOW but it cost me some beers but it cost some of the BRAVE HOLDERS a LOT MORE that a few beers:ok: :ok: :ok:
All the BEST
SPIT:

And apparently you also helped them drink some as well:ok:


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.