PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   F-16s and AH-1Ws failed to sink ship (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/196485-f-16s-ah-1ws-failed-sink-ship.html)

alert5 31st Oct 2005 13:40

F-16s and AH-1Ws failed to sink ship
 
The Republic of China Air Force sent two F-16s and two AH-1W Super Cobra helicopters to sink a South Korean freighter that capsized off its coast last Thursday. Both missions failed to sink the ship, but the Ministry of National Defense still declared the mission a success.

http://www.alert5.com/2005/11/botche...embarrass.html

Data-Lynx 31st Oct 2005 13:44

At least it was not so close to home. Try this UK report from 1967 comprising 62,000lbs of bombs, 5,200 gallons of petrol, 11 rockets and large quantities of napalm onto the ship.

diginagain 31st Oct 2005 13:49


Both missions failed to sink the ship, but the Ministry of National Defense still declared the mission a success.
Now that's the sort of statement you'd never see said by our Min of Def. :}

ORAC 31st Oct 2005 13:54

Admitting that it was "embarassing" that the initial effort by two F-16s to bomb and sink the ship failed, Minister of National Defense Lee Jye yesterday said the ministry would engage in introspection about the mission. Lee made the remarks on the legislative floor yesterday while fielding a question from the lawmakers about the ministry's mission to demolish the ship at the request of the Environmental Protection Administration (EPA).

"Engage in introspection", I wonder if it hurts.......... :}

KENNYR 31st Oct 2005 14:35

I remember thinking at the time "why not pack the 62,000 Lbs of bombs into the Torey Canyon and sink it purely by the extra weight." Still, it was wonderful to watch the live target practice and it made me want to join the Army instead. LOL

Gainesy 31st Oct 2005 15:17

Weeell, the Tirpitz was not sunk as such...

MarkD 31st Oct 2005 17:53

http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/taiw.../29/2003277837
(direct link to story)

SSOT 31st Oct 2005 18:05

Chinese? Air Force
 
Surely the Spams haven't been selling F-16s and Super Cobras to the Chinese! Next they'll be trying to offload Trident to the Iranians.

Wholigan 31st Oct 2005 18:06

Just to put the record straight with reference to the Torrey Canyon incident, the initial briefing was to try to set light to the oil, rather than to try to sink the ship. Consequently, the ship was opened up a bit more (the bombs and rockets that hit), and the "petrol" (actually napalm) was dropped to miss the ship and attempt to set the oil alight (the "bombs" that missed). It failed mainly because the "advisers and taskers" didn't seem to know that the heavy oil actually floats just below the surface of the sea water, so the napalm only caused the sea to steam a lot.

The hardest part of the whole episode was the poor old boss trying to explain why the RAF had those "Vietnam Horror Bombs" and nobody had known. What the "press" didn't realise is that anybody who had fuel, a gelling agent and an ignition method could have the "Vietnam Horror Bomb".

Fox3snapshot 31st Oct 2005 18:35

SSOT
 
That's Taiwan matey, and they have a complete inventory of US equipment...with a whole lot more on order.

:eek:

brickhistory 31st Oct 2005 18:38

Since we are, apparently, the root of all evil
 
and all uneducated, I've nothing to lose by asking why "Spam" as a reference?!

FishHead 31st Oct 2005 18:40

Come come now SSOT...

It was the Air Force of the Republic of China, not the People's Liberation Army Air Force of the People's Republic of China.

(ie, Taipei , not Beijing )

walter kennedy 31st Oct 2005 18:47

Wholigan
“… anybody who had fuel, a gelling agent and an ignition method could have the "Vietnam Horror Bomb".
Come on – I’ll bet it was not as ad hoc as that, was it?
In a part of Africa that was more British than Britain in the 70’s, as I recall something called “FranTan” was carried by the Hunters in “Frangible Tanks”.
It’s not something that the good guys like to admit (to themselves let alone the public!) they have in their arsenal.
I am surprised even at the Americans using it recently in Iraq (Fallujah?) – it doesn’t exactly win hearts and minds on either side.

SSOT 31st Oct 2005 18:50

Chinese??????????
 
Fox3snapshot & FishHead - Come on chaps, I was just having a friendly dig at alert5.

BTW I have no idea where the term "spam" in reference to the Americans comes from - though it is widely used in UK military circles. I hope is isn't un-PC; I would hate to offend.

con-pilot 31st Oct 2005 19:04

No fear SSOT, spam is a reference to an American meat (?) product that was very abundant in World War II.

Another reference to Spam was used during the early days of manned space flight in the US. The Astronauts called themselves “Spam in the Can” because at first they very little control over the space capsule.

SSOT 31st Oct 2005 19:09

The Spams
 
My best guess was that it half rhymed with Ams. Spamericans maybe?

brickhistory 31st Oct 2005 19:52

Ok
 
quote: BTW I have no idea where the term "spam" in reference to the Americans comes from - though it is widely used in UK military circles. I hope is isn't un-PC; I would hate to offend.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

No worries. I just was curious if there was a direct anecdote regarding the connection.

As far as un-PC; that's one of the world's many problems. Too much seriousness over stuff that doesn't mean s***.

IMO, of course.

Spam is a delicacy in Hawaii, oddly enough.....

Roadster280 31st Oct 2005 20:19

I know exactly what "spam" refers to. Actually, it is an acronym. It is highly un-PC, not at all friendly.

Since I am a Brit living in the land of milk and honey, I will keep what it actually means under my hat. If anyone cares to post on ARRSE, they will find out the answer, and probably be mercilessly character assassinated for having the naivety to ask. But I am sure someone will dish the dirt.

It isnt nice and should be forgotten. Believe me.

Data-Lynx 31st Oct 2005 20:24

Agree with Roadster280. Another unpleasant 90s variant was based on rhyming slang for spam fritter.

SSOT 31st Oct 2005 21:18

SPAM
 
I did hear once that spam is so popular amongst certain pacific islands due to the similarity of its taste to "longpig"


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.