Is Ukraine about to have a war?
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 30,922
Received 1,738 Likes
on
750 Posts
Though, the good thing is, with the big speech party, today, there were no announcements for Nukes-firing. Which, in turn, would rule out the usefulness of the Nukes, IE the threat. Use the threat to accomplish what you want, since you won't get anything meaningful (or better, lose all), when you are the first one to use the Nuke. Of course, walk on eggs, though be aware, eggs can be very strong and difficult to squeeze. Don't put the dog in the microwave, and whatever warnings are needed.
Ecce Homo! Loquitur...
Interesting - from todays Pentagon briefing…
The Pentagon sees anecdotal evidence of numerous Russian military officers in Ukraine disobeying orders from their commanders.
Those Russian officers disobeying are mid-level, up to the level of battalion commander, the senior U.S. defense official said.
Those Russian officers disobeying are mid-level, up to the level of battalion commander, the senior U.S. defense official said.
For some perspective.
That's what I said about two thousand posts ago, that we keep reading Nutty's "scorecard" but it's hard to translate the numbers into actual people and equipment so if someone made models of planes and tanks and lined up plastic soldiers it might give some real world perspective ... like this
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 30,922
Received 1,738 Likes
on
750 Posts
If Putin and some cronies want to rebuild the Soviet Union.....and we know how the people when exposed to Western style freedom and prosperity react....how does that old hardcore communist core of the Russian Government react?
We saw an example when the Berlin Wall went up and they killed many trying to escape.
What do the Russian People want these days....more empty shelves due to Communist Party failures or Western style lifestyle items and some freedom?
How does Putin handle that now with the complications of a failed War in Ukraine and the resultant Sanctions?
Juggling those two Balls is hard enough but what if there is some real move by the Russian People or his Military and Security Service to challenge his Rule?
What then?
We saw an example when the Berlin Wall went up and they killed many trying to escape.
What do the Russian People want these days....more empty shelves due to Communist Party failures or Western style lifestyle items and some freedom?
How does Putin handle that now with the complications of a failed War in Ukraine and the resultant Sanctions?
Juggling those two Balls is hard enough but what if there is some real move by the Russian People or his Military and Security Service to challenge his Rule?
What then?
Last edited by T28B; 10th May 2022 at 14:22. Reason: space clean up
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: OnScreen
Posts: 410
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A massive (NATO ?) counterstrike wasn't something really possible. For that, the resources need to be collected and these weren't there (at that moment, the current situation might be different). Maybe more of a Putin type warning, "don't interfere with our superior actions in Ukraine".
I really think, the Russian Nukes option is already from the table. The $33B Ukraine support option was already known to Putin, when speeching, and in the past, he has mumbled about Nukes for much smaller support options. Let the Polish Migs come, asap. Maybe not via Ramstein, though via London Heathrow or so, clearly visible, etc. This might be the last Bojo action, his last bluff action.
Join Date: Dec 2019
Location: OnScreen
Posts: 410
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If Putin and some cronies want to rebuild the Soviet Union.....and we know how the people when exposed to Western style freedom and prosperity react....how does that old hardcore communist core of the Russian Government react?
We saw an example when the Berlin Wall went up and they killed many trying to escape.
What do the Russian People want these days....more empty shelves due to Communist Party failures or Western style lifestyle items and some freedom?
How does Putin handle that now with the complications of a failed War in Ukraine and the resultant Sanctions?
Juggling those two Balls is hard enough but what if there is some real move by the Russian People or his Military and Security Service to challenge his Rule?
What then?
We saw an example when the Berlin Wall went up and they killed many trying to escape.
What do the Russian People want these days....more empty shelves due to Communist Party failures or Western style lifestyle items and some freedom?
How does Putin handle that now with the complications of a failed War in Ukraine and the resultant Sanctions?
Juggling those two Balls is hard enough but what if there is some real move by the Russian People or his Military and Security Service to challenge his Rule?
What then?
What the Russian people want: Stability, if needed to be enforced the hard way. Forgetting that "the hard way" becomes more and more brutal, the longer such a scheme runs. Breaking up the Federation would make things a significantly smaller scale and as such better manageable.
For now, Putin rules by propaganda, FSB enforcement, social control, zero press freedom and Stalin practices. Though the longer the Ukraine war takes, the more service men are missing or return home dead, fueling the unrest of the population. Difficult to predict what is going to happen, though Chaos is a certainty. Chaos anyway, when Putin dies, since nearly every major decision is tied to him personally and though there are formal institutions, these aren't recognized to be applicable (see the ignored formal transfer of power to the prime-minister position, when Putin gets his planned cancer operation, the power goes -rumored- to his FSB "friend").
Yep, but it would be far more visible without buffer states between NATO states and Russia mainland. Let us not forget, Putin doesn't use Internet .......
These 2 sentences do stretch the Western responsibilities quite a lot. Of course, those countries selecting freedom, etc and having joined the Western party should be supported. Those countries wanting and in the process to join should be helped too. Military attacking Russia to "liberate" the population would be quite a stretch further. The current Western support with fighting in Ukraine is, simply, because the Russian bully is not expected to stop with only Ukraine, trying to reinstate the former USSR. See my earlier post.
These were wise words, not only to put Russia in place, though also for the current US political landscape ......
These 2 sentences do stretch the Western responsibilities quite a lot. Of course, those countries selecting freedom, etc and having joined the Western party should be supported. Those countries wanting and in the process to join should be helped too. Military attacking Russia to "liberate" the population would be quite a stretch further. The current Western support with fighting in Ukraine is, simply, because the Russian bully is not expected to stop with only Ukraine, trying to reinstate the former USSR. See my earlier post.
These were wise words, not only to put Russia in place, though also for the current US political landscape ......
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 30,922
Received 1,738 Likes
on
750 Posts
I do see benefits to the west in the future, Ukraine will need help to rebuild post war and the likes of John Deere will be replacing stolen farm equipment etc to the benefit of American workers and industry.
Also various countries will be restocking donated weapons for their own military use, such as NLAW, Javelin and Stinger, the success of which shown against the likes of Russias finest will open up the sales worldwide and to the home markets, again generating jobs and revenues for those countries.
I would imagine Turkey has a queue at their door for UAV’s
Reparations will play a huge part in all of this as insurance does not normally cover war, however according to Russia it’s not a war, though I bet the insurance industry will disagree. I would like to see all the frozen Russian assets etc used to pay for it all.
…
Also various countries will be restocking donated weapons for their own military use, such as NLAW, Javelin and Stinger, the success of which shown against the likes of Russias finest will open up the sales worldwide and to the home markets, again generating jobs and revenues for those countries.
I would imagine Turkey has a queue at their door for UAV’s
Reparations will play a huge part in all of this as insurance does not normally cover war, however according to Russia it’s not a war, though I bet the insurance industry will disagree. I would like to see all the frozen Russian assets etc used to pay for it all.
…
Last edited by NutLoose; 10th May 2022 at 00:06.
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 30,922
Received 1,738 Likes
on
750 Posts
You think that’s bad sue, have you seen his propaganda?
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 30,922
Received 1,738 Likes
on
750 Posts
If you wondering what it is costing, this I believe is to be a rough idea of the Russia costs so far.
see below
see below
Last edited by NutLoose; 10th May 2022 at 01:07.
Still, the disruption of supply has sent oil and gas prices soaring, so Russia is actually generating record revenues from energy exports, 1.8 trillion rubles in April ( double that of last year) according to Forbes.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/rrapier...h=2319a1e04e34
So there is ample money to continue fighting.
The religious aspects of this ongoing conflict are most interesting. Since Russia gave up on communism it has returned to embrace the Russian orthodox church. And Putin has sought to conflate religion and conflict. Seee
this extraordinary...Religious theme park
Anyone looking for sci-fi plot material might want to ponder on a future conflict between a (mainly) Catholic European Union and those Protestants who seek/have left it....
Ecce Homo! Loquitur...
Those interested in the idea of post-Putin Russia should read this excellent book https://www.whsmith.co.uk/products/w...62748a166d&gcl to see how W Germany managed to absorb and regenerate E Germany after years of Soviet rule.
Anyone looking for sci-fi plot material might want to ponder on a future conflict between a (mainly) Catholic European Union and those Protestants who seek/have left it....
