2013/14 compensation payments arising out of low flying.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: @exRAF_Al
Posts: 3,297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2013/14 compensation payments arising out of low flying.
Some interesting ones in there. I wonder what bird was worth in excess of £2000? And I wonder how the puppy copped it.
https://www.gov.uk/government/upload...4_LF_Dec14.pdf
Edit: An answer!
https://www.gov.uk/government/upload...4_LF_Dec14.pdf
Edit: An answer!
Last edited by Al R; 13th Feb 2015 at 16:00.
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: UK
Posts: 816
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think where any doubt exists the claims are paid just to make the problem go away. Unfortunately, many of the claims are highly dubious and I'm sure some people make an income stream out of this.
I was once interviewed by the snowdrops regarding a claim that my big green helicopter flying at 50ft at cruising speed kicked up stones that smashed a car windscreen. From a low hover it's not impossible, straight and level, 50ft, ~150kts - no way. Perhaps it's more likely that it was the car in front. I suspect the claimant was paid off anyway.
I was once interviewed by the snowdrops regarding a claim that my big green helicopter flying at 50ft at cruising speed kicked up stones that smashed a car windscreen. From a low hover it's not impossible, straight and level, 50ft, ~150kts - no way. Perhaps it's more likely that it was the car in front. I suspect the claimant was paid off anyway.
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Once, after the Reds departed Coningsby on a non-standard route, I fielded a call from a horse owner about the injuries sustained by her prize show horse.
Eliciting her location I suddenly remembered, "Oh yes, I remember, your husband repaired my wrought iron gates".
She went deep and silent and we heard no more about it. Clearly her husband's disability allowance was worth more than her expected compensation.
Eliciting her location I suddenly remembered, "Oh yes, I remember, your husband repaired my wrought iron gates".
She went deep and silent and we heard no more about it. Clearly her husband's disability allowance was worth more than her expected compensation.
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: London
Posts: 2,916
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm surprised the Grob fatal near Porthcawl (£118,600) is included in the list of 'Low Flying' compensation payments.
The two aircraft collided at about 3000 ft agl. (Feb 2009)
Also, if the Grob fatal at Abingdon (£85,000) refers to the mid-air with a glider in June 2009, then the aircraft were at about 4000 ft amsl.
I have a vague recollection, which may be inaccurate, that the MoD regard low flying as <2000' (fixed wing) and <500' (helicopters).
Torque Tonight
You may well be right.
In the civilian world, it's not unusual for insurers to balance the cost of settling a claim against the cost of contesting it (in personnel time as well as legal costs) and take the least costly option.
Where the MoD is involved, potential adverse publicity is understandably a factor to be considered.
This can be, and to my knowledge has been, used by claimants and/or disreputable lawyers to generate unjustified 'David v Goliath' stories in the press with the objective of embarrassing the MoD into settling instead of contesting a dubious claim.
A long time ago, but interesting reading: MoD paid vet millions for fake post mortems
The two aircraft collided at about 3000 ft agl. (Feb 2009)
Also, if the Grob fatal at Abingdon (£85,000) refers to the mid-air with a glider in June 2009, then the aircraft were at about 4000 ft amsl.
I have a vague recollection, which may be inaccurate, that the MoD regard low flying as <2000' (fixed wing) and <500' (helicopters).
Torque Tonight
I think where any doubt exists the claims are paid just to make the problem go away.
In the civilian world, it's not unusual for insurers to balance the cost of settling a claim against the cost of contesting it (in personnel time as well as legal costs) and take the least costly option.
Where the MoD is involved, potential adverse publicity is understandably a factor to be considered.
This can be, and to my knowledge has been, used by claimants and/or disreputable lawyers to generate unjustified 'David v Goliath' stories in the press with the objective of embarrassing the MoD into settling instead of contesting a dubious claim.
I'm sure some people make an income stream out of this.
Between 1993 and 1995 the MoD paid out more than £15 million, almost all to farmers in South Armagh.
As soon as the police investigation, Operation Saddle, began, the figure for 1996 fell to just over £2 million and this year the payout will be around £300,000.
As soon as the police investigation, Operation Saddle, began, the figure for 1996 fell to just over £2 million and this year the payout will be around £300,000.
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: On the ORP
Posts: 98
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Years ago, I was involved with 2 claims, both fraudulent.
There used to be a woman farmer who was on the SW corner of the Dartmoor danger area and yes, there was a choke point between Dartmoor and Plymouth but she was claiming millions. The cops investigated and asked her to log all overflights in a weeks period, they did the same from down the road. When she presented her figures, she had exaggerated the number of overflights by a factor of 10---case dismissed.
Leading a pair of F4s descending to low level, a claim was made against us that we had upset a horse pulling a cart, horse bolted, 2 girls thrown out, one with a broken arm. We were there but estimated we flew over the site at @1500ft as we descended and luckily still had our maps to show our plan. Again the cops investigated and discovered the truth. The lasses had lost control of the horse a couple of minutes before we flew over and as you would expect, as we were descending we were throttled back not really making any noise. They also took film of the 'broken arm' girl shovelling horse manure just a couple of weeks after the supposed instance.
So from me, full marks to the cops for sorting things out. I understand that in the second instance they got their info from buying beer for some locals in the pub!
As an aside, the National Farmers Union used to produce a pack of how to claim against the MoD, don't know if that's still the case
There used to be a woman farmer who was on the SW corner of the Dartmoor danger area and yes, there was a choke point between Dartmoor and Plymouth but she was claiming millions. The cops investigated and asked her to log all overflights in a weeks period, they did the same from down the road. When she presented her figures, she had exaggerated the number of overflights by a factor of 10---case dismissed.
Leading a pair of F4s descending to low level, a claim was made against us that we had upset a horse pulling a cart, horse bolted, 2 girls thrown out, one with a broken arm. We were there but estimated we flew over the site at @1500ft as we descended and luckily still had our maps to show our plan. Again the cops investigated and discovered the truth. The lasses had lost control of the horse a couple of minutes before we flew over and as you would expect, as we were descending we were throttled back not really making any noise. They also took film of the 'broken arm' girl shovelling horse manure just a couple of weeks after the supposed instance.
So from me, full marks to the cops for sorting things out. I understand that in the second instance they got their info from buying beer for some locals in the pub!
As an aside, the National Farmers Union used to produce a pack of how to claim against the MoD, don't know if that's still the case
How on earth does a Chinook cause £25k damage to the ground!
I've also blown out the back window of a brigadier's Mondeo.
A great many years ago, a lorry driver claimed that his lorry was blown off a ramp by a low flying aircraft*.
We were told that, because it was his first claim, the driver would get the compensation; only subsequent claims would be investigated!
* The aircraft was a USAF 8-jet ... perhaps the driver was gawping at the airborne menace rather than driving his lorry
We were told that, because it was his first claim, the driver would get the compensation; only subsequent claims would be investigated!
* The aircraft was a USAF 8-jet ... perhaps the driver was gawping at the airborne menace rather than driving his lorry
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
Shucks, I could have had a new car
or perhaps MOD employees would not claim against the MOD in those days.
I was driving up the A1 past Wittering. A very grey day, 50 shades of murk.
Suddenly, no noise, rose this looming shape. I thought at first it was a Bloodhound but it was actually a Victor 2. I had never seen one before with its underwing jugs and over wing chaff dispensers. It was awesome.
I should have pranged my car and claimed a new one
or perhaps MOD employees would not claim against the MOD in those days.
I was driving up the A1 past Wittering. A very grey day, 50 shades of murk.
Suddenly, no noise, rose this looming shape. I thought at first it was a Bloodhound but it was actually a Victor 2. I had never seen one before with its underwing jugs and over wing chaff dispensers. It was awesome.
I should have pranged my car and claimed a new one
By virtue of living way off base in the Dales, I did once meet a guy down the pub who'd fallen off a rock face when scared ****less by a low-flying jet that morning. And we worked out that it was in fact me who had been the pilot. I'd been pulling a tight turn round a valley corner, approx. level with him, 250' MSD, so he could see the aircrew. He'd been roped up (obviously 
), and I bought him a pint, so we had a laugh about it.
It was quite a revelation because of course we are used to looking for jets, and Joe Public isn't, so I didn't realise just how shocking it could be. Equally, living in the country, I could see how horses especially could be bothered, but also saw and was told that sheep aren't bothered a bit. Big Noise, they look up, they can't see anything 'cos the jets already gone, back to grass-munching (exception - Falklands; remember SheepTAMs?). Sheep get bothered by hot-air balloons, because there's the burner noise and there is a big ball in the sky when they look up.
), and I bought him a pint, so we had a laugh about it.It was quite a revelation because of course we are used to looking for jets, and Joe Public isn't, so I didn't realise just how shocking it could be. Equally, living in the country, I could see how horses especially could be bothered, but also saw and was told that sheep aren't bothered a bit. Big Noise, they look up, they can't see anything 'cos the jets already gone, back to grass-munching (exception - Falklands; remember SheepTAMs?). Sheep get bothered by hot-air balloons, because there's the burner noise and there is a big ball in the sky when they look up.
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 1,958
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The complaints culture is all a bit annoying but for anyone thinking of moving on to airline flying, it gets worse. An orbit over a friends BBQ at 2000' in a 757 was enough to trigger a low flying complaint which cost the pilot his job.
I wonder if the way the complaints system for govt aircraft has been (generously) monetised is responsible for some of the nonsense we have to field from individuals after a quick buck?
I wonder if the way the complaints system for govt aircraft has been (generously) monetised is responsible for some of the nonsense we have to field from individuals after a quick buck?
Last edited by ShotOne; 15th Feb 2015 at 08:25. Reason: Speculation on money angle
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Axminster Devon
Age: 83
Posts: 166
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was, for a couple of years in the mid 1970s, half of the air staff general purposes cell in HQSTC called "Ops Nav & Wpns". We were lightly involved in low flying complaints, although the real paperwork was done in London.
Fox3WMB (#11) is no doubt right about sheep while Flying Lawyer (#6) touches on the subject of farmers a long way from London.
In my day perhaps 75% of the claims were for dead sheep in South Wales, I seem to remember mostly littering the Brecon Beacons. Virtually none now.
Fox3WMB (#11) is no doubt right about sheep while Flying Lawyer (#6) touches on the subject of farmers a long way from London.
In my day perhaps 75% of the claims were for dead sheep in South Wales, I seem to remember mostly littering the Brecon Beacons. Virtually none now.
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 32,757
Received 2,742 Likes
on
1,168 Posts
Those fatality payments are a pittance of what I feel they should have got.
One Day:
Ooh, our brave boys in [insert conflict]. It's digraceful they don't get the equipment or the training they should have. The government should give them the money they need.
Another Day:
Why do those bastards have to fly over my patch? Two flew over my house today and caused my 90 year old horse to have a heart attack. I want a million pounds.
God help the UK.
Ooh, our brave boys in [insert conflict]. It's digraceful they don't get the equipment or the training they should have. The government should give them the money they need.
Another Day:
Why do those bastards have to fly over my patch? Two flew over my house today and caused my 90 year old horse to have a heart attack. I want a million pounds.
God help the UK.
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Leicestershire, England
Posts: 1,170
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not a low flying related compensation claim, but nonetheless, an interesting break down of the clean up costs after the F-15D crash near Spalding in October last year...
BBC News - US Lakenheath fighter jet crash in Lincolnshire cost revealed
-RP
BBC News - US Lakenheath fighter jet crash in Lincolnshire cost revealed
-RP
A huge amount of effort went into Op Saddle, as I recall. Most days JATOC lost two SAC AATC to the cause, although they were ably assisted in their diligent research by some very friendly LEC.
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: East Anglia
Posts: 1,873
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting to see that it cost more than £1/4mil to put the contaminated soil from the Lakenheath jet into landfill, theres got to be something wrong with that figure
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: lincoln
Age: 63
Posts: 1
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I wish to claim a few million because I have not seen an AWACs (or anything else) for ages, they used to fly over my house but since that bloke in charge at Waddington decided he needed more concrete its all gone