The Great Escape
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Canada
Posts: 464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Most people might kind of think that was a bit out of the ordinary, and possibly not legal. The Nazis apparently did, since many of them appear to have found subordinates to do it for them on verbal orders, in the hope they wouldn't be blamed.
The preceding discussions miss the point entirely. The 50 officers killed had already been recaptured, and were in custody. They were undoubtedly murdered as an act of revenge using 'shot while escaping' as an excuse. It was certainly an illegal order and no amount of rationalisation post-event will excuse, or justify, any of the murders done. The word 'Execution' suggests some form of judicial process which did not happen; the recaptured officers were murdered, no ifs, no buts or whatevers; they were murdered as an act of revenge by the German government at the time.
While on the subject of what did not happen, Paul Brickhill's brilliant account of the escape never mentions the character played by Steve McQueen, as it was a compilation character of several British officers' efforts, not American officers, and the motor-bike scene is pure Hollywood fantasy only to sell the film to the US audiences. But unfortunately, it is the first scene that everyone recalls about the film....and he is riding a BSA!
While on the subject of what did not happen, Paul Brickhill's brilliant account of the escape never mentions the character played by Steve McQueen, as it was a compilation character of several British officers' efforts, not American officers, and the motor-bike scene is pure Hollywood fantasy only to sell the film to the US audiences. But unfortunately, it is the first scene that everyone recalls about the film....and he is riding a BSA!
I do understand what you are all saying and do not disagree, but my point is that in the context of that war, it is unlikely that anyone would have outwardly questioned the directive of the leadership's commands, let alone raising a red card on the validity or legality of an order.
I feel I know what I am trying to argue, but really don't want to in light of the sensitivity of the issue. So I will drop it out of respect to those brave people who sadly didn't make it.
I feel I know what I am trying to argue, but really don't want to in light of the sensitivity of the issue. So I will drop it out of respect to those brave people who sadly didn't make it.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Australia - South of where I'd like to be !
Age: 59
Posts: 4,261
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
cynic
I can forgive the BSA / Steve McQueen bike scene as being fiction because it had a purpose and isn't the main part of the film !
At least they didn't make the whole damn thing "by Americans" like they did with the Enigma machine capture !
I can forgive the BSA / Steve McQueen bike scene as being fiction because it had a purpose and isn't the main part of the film !
At least they didn't make the whole damn thing "by Americans" like they did with the Enigma machine capture !
Join Date: Oct 1998
Location: Kalgoorlie, W.A. , Australia
Age: 86
Posts: 458
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My late English master missed out on the Great Escape by fortunately drawing too high a number., either in the 140s or 170s.
His was a war of mixed fortunes. Rescued from a dinghy in the North Sea on about his 4th or 5th mission, only to be shot down again on his 8th. Either his parachute landing in a tree or the subsequent fall to the ground broke his ankle. After a spell in hospital he is sent to Stalag Luft III. Where rejoicing on finally being free from crutches he jumps down the hut steps only to find himself waist deep in sand, also having done his ankle no good.
Being summoned before Wing Commander Herbert Massey he was informed that initial there was no organisation in Stalag Luft III and the place was like a giant rabbit warren hence his unfortunate accident. However now things were organised and if he observed any odd behavior he was to take no notice.
Somewhere out on the web is a note on his dinghy practice and he mentioned as one of the regular female leads in Stalag Luft III's theatrical performances.
His was a war of mixed fortunes. Rescued from a dinghy in the North Sea on about his 4th or 5th mission, only to be shot down again on his 8th. Either his parachute landing in a tree or the subsequent fall to the ground broke his ankle. After a spell in hospital he is sent to Stalag Luft III. Where rejoicing on finally being free from crutches he jumps down the hut steps only to find himself waist deep in sand, also having done his ankle no good.
Being summoned before Wing Commander Herbert Massey he was informed that initial there was no organisation in Stalag Luft III and the place was like a giant rabbit warren hence his unfortunate accident. However now things were organised and if he observed any odd behavior he was to take no notice.
Somewhere out on the web is a note on his dinghy practice and he mentioned as one of the regular female leads in Stalag Luft III's theatrical performances.
Executions
Recently, I took my family around the Tower of London and there is a rather chilling tableau of the executiuon of a German spy during WWII, containing the diary of the CSM who organised the squad and set up the point of execution in the miniature range, in accordance with an order issued by the GOC. He makes it clear that the APM had to produce the Death Sentence and Execution Order and confirm that it was 'right and proper' before the firing party could go about their business.
With respect to separating the term 'German' from 'Nazi', much of this was an immediate post-war re-engineering. At the end of the war there was a tremendous purge of party officials and even low-level Gemeinde arbeiter had to undergo detailed scrutiny by the Allied Powers. When Russia (re)emerged as a threat, the US took the lead under then-General Eisenhower to both demonising the 'bad' SS (and Waffen SS) and the mythologising of the 'good' German Army, eventually paving the way for establishment of the Bundeswehr a few years later, officered by some characters with some rather dubious service histories. The scandal of files destroyed in recent years by the German BMD underlies this.
Occupation accounts from both official and private sources make it quite clear that the vast, vast majority of the German peoples were either Nazi party members or sympathisers. The US CIC reports until c 1949 do show frequent concerns about Fascist recidivisim. Certainly there were resistance groups but they were small and fragmented. The so-call von Stauffenberg Plot (actually devised by Generalleutenant Fellgiebel) was, at best, hair-brained, and was more concerned about Hitler's meddling in the conduct of the war, rather than his philosophy, per se.
Germans are our friends, and quite rightly so. The 3 post-war generations have been educated over and over again about 'that dark period of history' (as they might refer to it) but it is seen both embarrasing and irrelevent compared with the remarkable sucess of (west) Germany over the last 70 years. Although there may have been complicity at very high levels to rehabilitate former Nazi nomenklatura in nthe 50s - 70s, that is now history.
With respect to separating the term 'German' from 'Nazi', much of this was an immediate post-war re-engineering. At the end of the war there was a tremendous purge of party officials and even low-level Gemeinde arbeiter had to undergo detailed scrutiny by the Allied Powers. When Russia (re)emerged as a threat, the US took the lead under then-General Eisenhower to both demonising the 'bad' SS (and Waffen SS) and the mythologising of the 'good' German Army, eventually paving the way for establishment of the Bundeswehr a few years later, officered by some characters with some rather dubious service histories. The scandal of files destroyed in recent years by the German BMD underlies this.
Occupation accounts from both official and private sources make it quite clear that the vast, vast majority of the German peoples were either Nazi party members or sympathisers. The US CIC reports until c 1949 do show frequent concerns about Fascist recidivisim. Certainly there were resistance groups but they were small and fragmented. The so-call von Stauffenberg Plot (actually devised by Generalleutenant Fellgiebel) was, at best, hair-brained, and was more concerned about Hitler's meddling in the conduct of the war, rather than his philosophy, per se.
Germans are our friends, and quite rightly so. The 3 post-war generations have been educated over and over again about 'that dark period of history' (as they might refer to it) but it is seen both embarrasing and irrelevent compared with the remarkable sucess of (west) Germany over the last 70 years. Although there may have been complicity at very high levels to rehabilitate former Nazi nomenklatura in nthe 50s - 70s, that is now history.
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Somewhere flat
Age: 68
Posts: 5,558
Likes: 0
Received 45 Likes
on
30 Posts
"The Germans who carried out this execution were most likely members of the Nazi Party but they were still Germans!"
Not necessarily - many security personnel seconded from the SS were foreign conscripts - usually, but not exclusively - from Eastern Europe and the Balkans who chose to fight for the Germans rather than suffer the horrors of the prison camps. These unfortunates were often used to carry out the dirty work during WW2, and as the murders were carried out in Eastern Europe then it is possible that they carried out the deed. Unlike the film, the victims were sent out in small groups of about 3-4 to be shot during a "rest period" in their journey. The bodies were burned and their ashes scattered to hide all evidence of the crime. The orders were undoubtedly of German origin however, and the greater responsibility lies with them.
Not necessarily - many security personnel seconded from the SS were foreign conscripts - usually, but not exclusively - from Eastern Europe and the Balkans who chose to fight for the Germans rather than suffer the horrors of the prison camps. These unfortunates were often used to carry out the dirty work during WW2, and as the murders were carried out in Eastern Europe then it is possible that they carried out the deed. Unlike the film, the victims were sent out in small groups of about 3-4 to be shot during a "rest period" in their journey. The bodies were burned and their ashes scattered to hide all evidence of the crime. The orders were undoubtedly of German origin however, and the greater responsibility lies with them.
A very interesting book was published a year or two back, The Human Game, which covered the post-war investigations and trials of those responsible for the murders. It explores the chain of command fully. See here HOME - Sky & Bullets
A report of the 70th anniversary ceremony at the site of the camp is shown on here
BBC iPlayer - BBC News at Six: 24/03/2014
I'd be interested if anyone can identify the Scottish Air Commodore (?) who is seen speaking at around 26m 20 s on the report. Answer by PM if you prefer. Confused by the gold rank braid on his greatcoat - is this a recent thing?
BBC iPlayer - BBC News at Six: 24/03/2014
I'd be interested if anyone can identify the Scottish Air Commodore (?) who is seen speaking at around 26m 20 s on the report. Answer by PM if you prefer. Confused by the gold rank braid on his greatcoat - is this a recent thing?
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: East Sussex UK
Age: 66
Posts: 6,995
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
TTN ...
I believe the VSO is Air Officer Commanding No 1 Group Air Vice-Marshal Stuart D Atha DSO MA BSc RAF
There are some good pics on Twitter ... Some screen grabs to follow
I believe the VSO is Air Officer Commanding No 1 Group Air Vice-Marshal Stuart D Atha DSO MA BSc RAF
There are some good pics on Twitter ... Some screen grabs to follow
Last edited by CoffmanStarter; 25th Mar 2014 at 10:37.
Coffman
Correct.
TTN
Agree with the confusion. New one to me as well (unless it's an optical illusion).
Correct.
TTN
Agree with the confusion. New one to me as well (unless it's an optical illusion).
The brave men they are commemorating went into battle wearing RAF blue uniforms
Next you'll be having a go at the colour parties for not wearing fur lined boots, Irvin flying jackets and mae wests.....
V_G - they are wearing what AP1358 calls 'operational clothing', which is the nearest we have today to the War Service Dress that the RAF officers would have been wearing at the time of the escape.
Also, bearing in mind that the escapers included 2 FAA officers and Major Johnnie Dodge (who ended up in Sachsenhausen for his pains), the tri-service nature of the chosen dress seems somehow apposite for this occasion.
I thought it quite impressive that (thanks to the editing of the piece) Stu Atha managed to be simultaneously speaking at the microphone and sitting next to Air Cdre Clarke at one point in the news clip...
Also, bearing in mind that the escapers included 2 FAA officers and Major Johnnie Dodge (who ended up in Sachsenhausen for his pains), the tri-service nature of the chosen dress seems somehow apposite for this occasion.
I thought it quite impressive that (thanks to the editing of the piece) Stu Atha managed to be simultaneously speaking at the microphone and sitting next to Air Cdre Clarke at one point in the news clip...
Thanks for the ID on AVM Atha, chaps. I'd like to see a close-up of all that gold stuff on his epaulettes though as I can't quite work it out (as you know I'm a bit of a medal/badge nerd!)
I see Air Commodore Clarke is wearing the Bomber Command clasp on his 1939-45 Star - great to see somebody wearing this, as unfortunately the majority of those issued will be to the next of kin of those who did not live long enough to receive it.
I see Air Commodore Clarke is wearing the Bomber Command clasp on his 1939-45 Star - great to see somebody wearing this, as unfortunately the majority of those issued will be to the next of kin of those who did not live long enough to receive it.
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Pasadena
Posts: 633
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Let's not confuse the members of the Gestapo that murdered the escapees after they were recaptured with regular Germans.
What type of character volunteers to be a secret policeman for a brutal and repressive regime? I strongly suspect that the occurrence of such psychopaths is relatively uniform amongst nations, but that most just don't get the chance to play out their potential roles in most places.
I also doubt that such illegal acts against high-profile prisoners would be carried out by foreign help.
After a quick search, the trials that lead to the execution of 13 of the 18 accused in 1947, and the imprisonment of the other 5, seemed to be directed against men with traditional German names.
Stalag Luft III murders - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
What type of character volunteers to be a secret policeman for a brutal and repressive regime? I strongly suspect that the occurrence of such psychopaths is relatively uniform amongst nations, but that most just don't get the chance to play out their potential roles in most places.
I also doubt that such illegal acts against high-profile prisoners would be carried out by foreign help.
After a quick search, the trials that lead to the execution of 13 of the 18 accused in 1947, and the imprisonment of the other 5, seemed to be directed against men with traditional German names.
Stalag Luft III murders - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia