Lord West, right or wrong?
Thread Starter
Lord West, right or wrong?
Ladies & Gentlemen,
The latest breaking news is that Lord West (he of 1st Sea Lord fame) has said in a press conference, to support Labour's new policy on Defence Procurement, that we're still a first rate military power! Not like Bloody Belgium or Denmark!!
What do we think?
FB
The latest breaking news is that Lord West (he of 1st Sea Lord fame) has said in a press conference, to support Labour's new policy on Defence Procurement, that we're still a first rate military power! Not like Bloody Belgium or Denmark!!
What do we think?
FB
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: France 46
Age: 77
Posts: 1,743
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Liquid Lunch by any chance?
I wonder if he is aware that the only member of the SAS (and its affiliated Units) to win the Victoria Cross in WW2 was a Dane? One of 3 Danes who have been awarded that Decoration.
I wonder if he is aware that the only member of the SAS (and its affiliated Units) to win the Victoria Cross in WW2 was a Dane? One of 3 Danes who have been awarded that Decoration.
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: N. Spain
Age: 79
Posts: 1,311
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Looks like he has embarrased his "friends", if that's possible.
Labour apologises after peer insults 'bloody Denmark' - Telegraph
Labour apologises after peer insults 'bloody Denmark' - Telegraph
Originally Posted by FB
Ladies & Gentlemen,
The latest breaking news is that Lord West (he of 1st Sea Lord fame) has said in a press conference, to support Labour's new policy on Defence Procurement, that we're still a first rate military power! Not like Bloody Belgium or Denmark!!
What do we think?
FB
The latest breaking news is that Lord West (he of 1st Sea Lord fame) has said in a press conference, to support Labour's new policy on Defence Procurement, that we're still a first rate military power! Not like Bloody Belgium or Denmark!!
What do we think?
FB
The Labour Party has apologised after one of its most senior politicians described Belgium and Denmark as "second-tier" countries. Outlining the party's defence policy review, ex-Security Minister Lord West said the UK retained a "certain clout". And he argued that too much downgrading of military capacity would make it more like "bloody Denmark or Belgium"...
The problem comes in the UK acting on the world's stage as though it is ranked 2nd. That said, it is fair to say that it still has significantly more 'clout' than Denmark or Belgium. Whether it was tactful to point this out is another question.
Red On, Green On
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Between the woods and the water
Age: 24
Posts: 6,487
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Worth noting that while Belgium might not have a very big or aggressive military, they help us out when we don't have enough SAR resources in the South of the UK.
Link to BBC news report and link to thread on Pprune
Link to BBC news report and link to thread on Pprune
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Lincolnshire
Posts: 543
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hardly the most diplomatic statement by a former Chief.
It may be telling that we are now in the position that we are comparing our capabilities with Denmark and Belgium.
It may be telling that we are now in the position that we are comparing our capabilities with Denmark and Belgium.
West does have a habit of saying daft things.
If there is one country in Europe the UK can count on, it is Denmark. They have consistently punched well above their weight (measured in GDP and population) in overseas military and civilian cooperation, invariably closely aligned with UK foreign policy objectives.
As Whenurhappy points out, they have had 42 casualties in Afghanistan (many from the Jaegerkorpset - their excellent SF). In terms of relative population, that is equivalent to us taking about 600 casualties.
If there is one country in Europe the UK can count on, it is Denmark. They have consistently punched well above their weight (measured in GDP and population) in overseas military and civilian cooperation, invariably closely aligned with UK foreign policy objectives.
As Whenurhappy points out, they have had 42 casualties in Afghanistan (many from the Jaegerkorpset - their excellent SF). In terms of relative population, that is equivalent to us taking about 600 casualties.
I recall way back in the cold war days a smug Danish government minister praising her own country's spending on social services, child welfare and the like whilst making unfavourable comments on British spending in those areas.
She neglected to point out (if indeed she was aware) that at that time a British Armoured Division based in Germany had as its primary war role the defence of Danish territory in the event of a Soviet invasion.
Pleased to see that Denmark is pulling its weight in Afganistan now, although personally I'd like to see the whole lot pull out and leave the s**thole to the Afghans.
Wonder if his lordship has had a congratulatory phone call from Prince Philip btw
She neglected to point out (if indeed she was aware) that at that time a British Armoured Division based in Germany had as its primary war role the defence of Danish territory in the event of a Soviet invasion.
Pleased to see that Denmark is pulling its weight in Afganistan now, although personally I'd like to see the whole lot pull out and leave the s**thole to the Afghans.
Wonder if his lordship has had a congratulatory phone call from Prince Philip btw
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Southern UK
Posts: 372
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
And, might I add (and depending on how you measure this, the stats are a minefield), the Danes and Belgians have contributed quite significantly to the kinetic activity in the Libya operation - with the Danes ahead of both UK and France in terms of either bombs or weight of ordnance dropped (can't remember which) for a significant period.
And no surprise to see WEBF has raised SHAR again! Can we have a 'most tenuous connection to SHAR thread' to see what he can possibly insist on raising SHAR in in future?
Yeah but...
....having sat through lots of NATO meetings, when a Royal Navy VSO opens his remarks "Speaking as a simple sailorman....." my defence shields used to select RED ALERT as someone in the vicinity was about to be shafted.
Fortunately, it was never me but I saw lots of chaps being skewered.
The Ancient Mariner
Fortunately, it was never me but I saw lots of chaps being skewered.
The Ancient Mariner
It was intended as irony...
Labour had 13 odd years to reform Defence Procurement, and left office with the MOD having a £38Bn black hole in the procurement budget.... A great testament to their ability to manage.
Labour had 13 odd years to reform Defence Procurement, and left office with the MOD having a £38Bn black hole in the procurement budget.... A great testament to their ability to manage.
True enough, Biggus, and I hold no brief for Labour, new or old, but I have to say that defence procurement has been a bloody mess ever since I can remember, no matter what colour the party in power is.
True in turn, and I'm no great fan of the current government.
However, after 13 years at the tiller, the idea that within about 15 months in opposition Labour are now saying they have the solution I find incredulous, unlikely and somewhat insulting to my intelligence!
However, after 13 years at the tiller, the idea that within about 15 months in opposition Labour are now saying they have the solution I find incredulous, unlikely and somewhat insulting to my intelligence!
Aspersions on the Danish fighting forces tend to come from retired officers, based on a half-remembered anecdote about some misunderstood event which they vaguely heard about while on exercise in the Seventies.
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: at home
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just another snivelling yes man when he was in, and didn't stop the £38 bn black hole created. Now he deems it suitable to make wholly inappropriate comments about the brave men and women in the Danish military. Shameful.