France rejoin NATO?
Thread Starter
France rejoin NATO?
At first I thought it must be April 1st
BBC NEWS | World | Europe | France ends four-decade Nato rift
Wonder why it suits them now?
BBC NEWS | World | Europe | France ends four-decade Nato rift
Wonder why it suits them now?
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Detroit MI
Age: 66
Posts: 1,460
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's one of two things:-
1. Sarkozy is trying to bring France back to reality.
2. France wants to have more of an influence on NATO policy.
Neither one gives me the "warm and fuzzies"... It'll end in tears.
1. Sarkozy is trying to bring France back to reality.
2. France wants to have more of an influence on NATO policy.
Neither one gives me the "warm and fuzzies"... It'll end in tears.
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: AEP
Age: 80
Posts: 1,420
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
France...
When it comes to anti-French, anti-UK, anti-USA "popular antics" I wish that people would educate theirselves.
xxx
About France, and white flags...?
(1) Remember World War I (1914-1918) - The French fought valiantly.
(2) World War II (1939-1945) - yes, they surrendered in June 1940... but their "Resistance" against Nazis was the most effective of Western Europe. They bought havoc to their railroads tracks and bridges used for Nazi logistics. They helped thousands of downed aircrews to escape/return to UK.
(3) Their armed forces took active part to 1944 D Day for the liberation of France.
(4) They received very little help in Indochina (1954). Was it an excuse for US to make their Vietnam War ten years later...?
(5) Yet they took part as NATO member, to the Korean War (1950-1953). France was to the side of UK, for the Suez Canal (1956).
(6) Asking help again (1958) for Algeria (then a French Metropole Province) they received NO help, paving the way for DeGaulle's anti-US attitude.
(7) If DeGaulle policies had continued, UK would never been part of EU.
(8) The French always liked Americans, at worst they question US politics. I think UK does it too.
(9) Sarkozy is strongly pro-US, pro-UK and pro-NATO politician. Their forces are in Afghanistan NOW.
xxx
So criticize France... Shows you to be poorly informed about that nation.
They still put flowers to the military cemeteries in Flanders, and Normandy.
And yes, I like French cheeses and French wines...
xxx
Happy contrails
xxx
About France, and white flags...?
(1) Remember World War I (1914-1918) - The French fought valiantly.
(2) World War II (1939-1945) - yes, they surrendered in June 1940... but their "Resistance" against Nazis was the most effective of Western Europe. They bought havoc to their railroads tracks and bridges used for Nazi logistics. They helped thousands of downed aircrews to escape/return to UK.
(3) Their armed forces took active part to 1944 D Day for the liberation of France.
(4) They received very little help in Indochina (1954). Was it an excuse for US to make their Vietnam War ten years later...?
(5) Yet they took part as NATO member, to the Korean War (1950-1953). France was to the side of UK, for the Suez Canal (1956).
(6) Asking help again (1958) for Algeria (then a French Metropole Province) they received NO help, paving the way for DeGaulle's anti-US attitude.
(7) If DeGaulle policies had continued, UK would never been part of EU.
(8) The French always liked Americans, at worst they question US politics. I think UK does it too.
(9) Sarkozy is strongly pro-US, pro-UK and pro-NATO politician. Their forces are in Afghanistan NOW.
xxx
So criticize France... Shows you to be poorly informed about that nation.
They still put flowers to the military cemeteries in Flanders, and Normandy.
And yes, I like French cheeses and French wines...
xxx
Happy contrails
Last edited by BelArgUSA; 12th Mar 2009 at 11:40. Reason: date change typo 1958/1956
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: In Hyperspace...
Posts: 395
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
(9) Sarkozy is strongly pro-US, pro-UK and pro-NATO politician. Their forces are in Afghanistan NOW.
At least they built their own chow hall....which they don't let anybody else use...
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Hanging off the end of a thread
Posts: 32,866
Received 2,816 Likes
on
1,200 Posts
They also helped out in so many ways during the Falklands war, providing information on the Exocet, delaying deliveries to Argentina and providing combat training against Aircraft the Argentinians operated............
So don't knock them.
So don't knock them.
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 1,451
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
but their "Resistance" against Nazis was the most effective of Western Europe
Despite Allied propaganda to the contrary, the French "Resistance" was small and marginalised and looked upon as terrorists by the vast majority of the French population - until August 1944 - when magically, damn near everyone turned out to be a (very) secret member of that same resistance.
The exception were the Communists, who became very active against the Germans after Sept 41, but who were looked upon as dangerous radicals by the vast majority of the French. Most of those communists - (the few who survived the Germans and the very active Milice) - were promptly locked up by the post Vichy government and many ex-Milice were employed by the new government to continue locking up the very same people they'd been chasing under Vichy.
In mitigation, I'd say the majority of most nations tend to go with the flow and take the easy course, whoever is in power, and the French who did fight in the Resistance and others who went to England to join De Gaulle were very brave people indeed.
BelArgUSA
Your points are all well made but these will only enrage the Daily Mail readers in this forum as they'll be itching to drag out the same old same old tired witty stereotypes yet again.. (cheese eating surrenders monkeys, blah blah)
Sarko would be damned by this same element here if he kept France out of NATO and he'll be damned by them for returning to the fold..
Sarko would be damned by this same element here if he kept France out of NATO and he'll be damned by them for returning to the fold..
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
BelArgUSA also missed out Suez in 1956 and GW1 in 1992. In the latter the French were, I believe, the first with the post-attack videoes on the news.
When I hear stuff thrashing France I always look up WW1 Casualty list and get reminded of the sheer level of casualties that France suffered.
Casualties of World War 1 - World War 1 Killed and Casualties
75% casualty rate of those mobilised suffered by France.
If UK had the same casualty rate would it have changed the way the Govt had done things later and the likelihood is that it would have.
If UK had suffered same casualty rate it would have added another 41% (280,000) to those who had died and 81% (1.4 Million) more to those who were wounded.
Travelling through rural areas in UK and France I have often stopped and looked at the War Memorials saying a silent prayer in recognition for their sacrifice and with guide books they give you an idea roughly of current population. Most particularly in France counting the names and getting to 125 and finding out current population in the surrounding area in only 175 gives you an idea of the sacrifice across France. I have yet to come across anything like that scale in the UK.
I can understand why a World War 1 hero such as Petain made peace in 1940 having watched the wholescale slaughter in WW1 and the wiping of a generation and being unable to do it a second time.
Casualties of World War 1 - World War 1 Killed and Casualties
75% casualty rate of those mobilised suffered by France.
If UK had the same casualty rate would it have changed the way the Govt had done things later and the likelihood is that it would have.
If UK had suffered same casualty rate it would have added another 41% (280,000) to those who had died and 81% (1.4 Million) more to those who were wounded.
Travelling through rural areas in UK and France I have often stopped and looked at the War Memorials saying a silent prayer in recognition for their sacrifice and with guide books they give you an idea roughly of current population. Most particularly in France counting the names and getting to 125 and finding out current population in the surrounding area in only 175 gives you an idea of the sacrifice across France. I have yet to come across anything like that scale in the UK.
I can understand why a World War 1 hero such as Petain made peace in 1940 having watched the wholescale slaughter in WW1 and the wiping of a generation and being unable to do it a second time.
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: AEP
Age: 80
Posts: 1,420
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Friends
xxx
I gave my personal opinion about France, a country and culture I know well, as I am a native of Brussels, Belgium (French was my language). The constant criticism of French politics by many in UK, and USA, is often not deserved. Having lived 25 years in USA (1969-1993), I never failed to defend France when criticized by anti-French Americans, as much as I defended USA or UK when they in turn were criticized by the French I would meet on my frequent visits in France...
xxx
Pontius Navigator
Sorry, I made a typo - 1958 for 1956 in mentioning the Suez Canal.
xxx
Wiley
Gladly will elaborate . My mother, born 1925, and young lady during WW2 was a "messenger" passing papers and scrolls inside her bicycle frame (removing the seat post) and when stopped by Nazis guards, she would flirt them and offer them a "date" for a dance the next saturday... Incidentally, she was part of a Communist cell (many in Belgium as well). She also escorted half a dozen downed aircrews, RAF and USAAF back into France, some all the way to the Spanish border, the airmen disguised as Flemish workers as they spoke no French, with false ID provided by her Resistance group. I owe my "being in the world" to a USAAF 2nd Lt, and the numerous haystacks they probably used to spend the night on the way to the Spanish border in 1943. Agree with you, the Norwegian, the Dutch, the Danes did a great job too, I would personally have thought that the Yugoslavs of Tito were the best at it. I grew up as a kid, around many people who were in the Resistance, or escaped to UK to join the miltary. My stepfather was in the Belgian Brigade, attached to the Canadian Army on D Day Normandy (Brigade Piron), my uncle, with the RAF.
xxx
So, still having UK-France animosity, ever since Hastings 1066...?
Time to forget it, except for soccer or rugby...
xxx
Happy contrails
xxx
I gave my personal opinion about France, a country and culture I know well, as I am a native of Brussels, Belgium (French was my language). The constant criticism of French politics by many in UK, and USA, is often not deserved. Having lived 25 years in USA (1969-1993), I never failed to defend France when criticized by anti-French Americans, as much as I defended USA or UK when they in turn were criticized by the French I would meet on my frequent visits in France...
xxx
Pontius Navigator
Sorry, I made a typo - 1958 for 1956 in mentioning the Suez Canal.
xxx
Wiley
Gladly will elaborate . My mother, born 1925, and young lady during WW2 was a "messenger" passing papers and scrolls inside her bicycle frame (removing the seat post) and when stopped by Nazis guards, she would flirt them and offer them a "date" for a dance the next saturday... Incidentally, she was part of a Communist cell (many in Belgium as well). She also escorted half a dozen downed aircrews, RAF and USAAF back into France, some all the way to the Spanish border, the airmen disguised as Flemish workers as they spoke no French, with false ID provided by her Resistance group. I owe my "being in the world" to a USAAF 2nd Lt, and the numerous haystacks they probably used to spend the night on the way to the Spanish border in 1943. Agree with you, the Norwegian, the Dutch, the Danes did a great job too, I would personally have thought that the Yugoslavs of Tito were the best at it. I grew up as a kid, around many people who were in the Resistance, or escaped to UK to join the miltary. My stepfather was in the Belgian Brigade, attached to the Canadian Army on D Day Normandy (Brigade Piron), my uncle, with the RAF.
xxx
So, still having UK-France animosity, ever since Hastings 1066...?
Time to forget it, except for soccer or rugby...
xxx
Happy contrails
I don't own this space under my name. I should have leased it while I still could
They also helped out in so many ways during the Falklands war, providing information on the Exocet,
I love Sarkozy, he reminds me so much of Mr Bean.
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: london
Posts: 379
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
BelArg is spot on. France never left NATO: from 1/7/66 she stopped participating in ACE/AFCENT and other fora...but stayed at Council level, retaining Ops compatibility if not integration. CDG held one Nation intact despite internal stress: "apres moi le deluge". France's elite, 1930s-90s, was informed by 1936 near-descent into Spanish-style Left/ Right Civil War. That, BelAir, not US "pressure" (who has ever pressed a Frenchman?), was the reason CDG quit Algeria: risk of revival of that schism (plus the cost, in treasure and conscript flesh). He did not object to getting up the odd Anglo nose ("defense a tous azimuts"), but during Cuba, 10/62: 'he did not think we would have war but if Soviets forced US in such places as Berlin, France would be with US "France will act in accord with you."' Avalon Project - Cuban Missle Crisis - Telegram From the Embassy in France to the Department of State.
HQ2, why come in from the cold now? Cost. France has decided that its interests continue to require Power Projection, such as in Africa, and that new, Out-of-Area NATO offers an affordable, coalition-centric means of doing that. So, no PA2 CVF: Task-share with the willing.
HQ2, why come in from the cold now? Cost. France has decided that its interests continue to require Power Projection, such as in Africa, and that new, Out-of-Area NATO offers an affordable, coalition-centric means of doing that. So, no PA2 CVF: Task-share with the willing.
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Detroit MI
Age: 66
Posts: 1,460
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Task-share with the willing.
... and they wonder why the rest of the world treat them like a red-headed stepchild...
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: St Annes
Age: 68
Posts: 638
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Evanelpus....
remind me again where the Argentinians got their modern destroyers?
There are actually 3 obvious factions in the "frog-bashing" threads :
1 - Francophiles - those who actually quite like the french. Typically composed of those who have actually met Frech chappies, perhaps those who have always admired anyone whose in flight rations include a wine allowance. May know some history, eg Dien Ben Phu. May be old enough to remember a young Miss Bardot.
2 - Banter types. Don't REALLY have anything against the French, it's just a sort of comic device in all honesty, a bit like calling small people lofty and so on. Genuinely just using a stereotype that they know isn't actually accurate because the punchline is actually funny. (This is, in my opinion, the origin of the wickedly humorous 'cheese eating surrender monkeys' phrase - a beautifully expressed piece of work, only lacking in actual factual content).
3 - Genuine Francophobes. Probably never met anyone who is actually French, quite probably spends 23+ hrs a day at the keyboard and has hygiene issues.
I try to be type 1, but have a bad habit of being type 2
I should bloody well think so, they gave the missiles to the Argies in the first place.
There are actually 3 obvious factions in the "frog-bashing" threads :
1 - Francophiles - those who actually quite like the french. Typically composed of those who have actually met Frech chappies, perhaps those who have always admired anyone whose in flight rations include a wine allowance. May know some history, eg Dien Ben Phu. May be old enough to remember a young Miss Bardot.
2 - Banter types. Don't REALLY have anything against the French, it's just a sort of comic device in all honesty, a bit like calling small people lofty and so on. Genuinely just using a stereotype that they know isn't actually accurate because the punchline is actually funny. (This is, in my opinion, the origin of the wickedly humorous 'cheese eating surrender monkeys' phrase - a beautifully expressed piece of work, only lacking in actual factual content).
3 - Genuine Francophobes. Probably never met anyone who is actually French, quite probably spends 23+ hrs a day at the keyboard and has hygiene issues.
I try to be type 1, but have a bad habit of being type 2
May be old enough to remember a young Miss Bardot.
That should get the "Nurse, quickly please!" alarms going at the old PPRuNers rest home!