PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Middle East (https://www.pprune.org/middle-east-44/)
-   -   US3 v ME3 - 'The Economist' weighs in (https://www.pprune.org/middle-east/560704-us3-v-me3-economist-weighs.html)

paokara 21st May 2015 23:56

On the news what the lady in charge from Holland said today

Research it : aviation daily

Etihad frozen as well

Her name : Wilma Mansveld Dutch Secretary of Transportation



More countries to follow

SOPS 22nd May 2015 00:32

Have you got a link for that?

Popgun 22nd May 2015 01:16

Link
 
Dutch Government Freezes Gulf Carrier Routes | TravelPulse

PG

baps 22nd May 2015 06:45

My guess there will be a legal challenge to this before EK drop their second flight to AMS so that could go on for months. As for supply and demand the loads on the AMS flight would suggest that the demand for the EK flights is there.

donpizmeov 22nd May 2015 11:13

Msnbc getting in on the act.
 
The battle for the international skies | MSNBC

fliion 22nd May 2015 11:49

Getting from EU/ US to Kerala with one stop is what the market demands & now expects.

If the powers that be change the regulatory dynamics then the market will adjust.

For example it is not beyond the realms of reality that in the event that the U.S. rolled back or restricted access to US points then look for large equity investments by ME3 in US (EU) partners to feed Dubai et al.

JetBlue 380's JFK to DWC in the next decade?

Laugh if you want.

f.

6000PIC 22nd May 2015 13:36

Well done Holland.
Until the ME3 treat ALL employees fairly with regards to their employment rights , compensation , collective bargaining and union affiliation , their strong arm tactics will be met with resistance.
The Dutch , the Americans , the Germans , the Canadians and Scandinavians are not about to surrender their aviation markets in order to sell the ME3 aircraft. Equally , they are not about to enable the ME3 to gain market share at the expense to the indigenous aviation business.
The ME3 business plan is based on seizing this market share by a combination of leveraging aircraft manufacturing with traffic rights , and by unequal labour practices.
Flawed ? Possibly.

Iver 28th May 2015 01:21

Not sure if anyone saw this recent article:

http://www.cnbc.com/id/102707034

How can Al Baker argue that QR is not related/tied to the government when other foreign contracts in Qatar are tied to airport slots for QR? Very confusing!

paokara 28th May 2015 04:29

Sometimes money does not buy everything

Determination and perseverance does


By the end of the year we will find out but so far it does not look good for the ME 3

Buford 28th May 2015 07:04

Worth a watch
 
US airline CEOs speaking at National Press Club about ME3

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rn35xebnG7M

Stone_cold 28th May 2015 08:39

Qatar Airway's 200 billion dollar threat to European airports - Business Insider

LHR Rain 28th May 2015 09:24

Hopefully Qatar will lose the World Cup and lose the Open Skies debate.
Everyone knows they bribed their way to win the votes and the government supports the airline. A double loss.
Exposer. What every country in the Middle East hates because the facts have a way of coming out and how the dictators hate facts.

Stone_cold 28th May 2015 11:40

UAE Canada dispute

Seems to be the regional method of getting their own way .

Trader 29th May 2015 00:55

Everyone behaves the same way with agriculture. Look at the the Euro market which has even more arcane protections. Two minutes on Google and you will find that this debate has been raging for years.

paokara 29th May 2015 00:58

Dubai 2004




Make sure if you get an chance to interview with any of the 3 legacies to tell them about their service and how you could contribute from your experience in Dubai


If you apply of course

Wizofoz 29th May 2015 08:27

Well, unless he's American, he can't, can he?

Metro man 29th May 2015 09:47

The U.S. Cruise industry registers it's ships under foreign flags and employs third world workers on far inferior terms and conditions than American workers would command.

Their airlines are obviously jealous that they can't do the same thing. If they could they would have done it years ago and wouldn't be complaining now.

shorty2rj 31st May 2015 05:26

So MetroMan, rather then complain should we just accept ME3 flight ops culture as the new template for this profession?

north flyer 31st May 2015 06:03

There are some very good points about the US3/ME3 thing

US industry/corporations are just as brutal as any in the world, it's just business.

Airlines will always be in a fight and it will always be a dirty fight for market share, hub dominance, profits, whatever, it is ongoing and never ending.

That is the normal state of business, but that is EK's business, not ours as pilots.

Our business as pilots is to get and keep working condition that we can live with, with the limited means we have available to us.

I came to Emirates 7 years ago after 21 years with USAirways (now American) because the working conditions were better at EK than they were at USAirways, things have changed.

I would argue that what we are seeing here at EK is the playbook that was developed at the US carriers 30 or so years ago, before EK even started operations, by Frank Lorenzo, Carl Icahn and others, nothing new by EK, just the way it is and will be. One example is the overtime, taken away on 9 Feb 2009 with a simple email and a third of it given back 6 years later. I looked at the seniority, there are 3800 pilots (+/- a few) 2000 hired after 9 Feb 2009, so the company looks better to them than the 1800 hired before 9 Feb 2009, divide and conquer, simple, just business.

I have learned that you love your family, your country and your dog (you can pick your own order) but not your company. You have a business contract with your company. You are expected to hold up your end of the contract and you expect them to hold up their's. If you don't hold up your end, you will be fired, just business.

After what happened last week with our contract, it is time for us to get down to our business and let the US3/ME3 handle theirs.

As the saying goes, "it's not personal, it's just business".

Metro man 31st May 2015 06:54

It depends on which point of view you are looking at the ME3 from.

As a passenger you are getting low fares, new aircraft and good service.

As a pilot you have career opportunities with these airlines which have undoubtedly grown the market. Compare the time to the left seat for a new joiner in EK vs Delta for example. However there are significant negatives such as the lack of union protection and employment laws.

As a western airline you have competition which you cannot match in terms of price and service. Your standards have declined over the years and suddenly your customers, who you have taken for granted are deserting you for a better and cheaper product.

As a western government you are keen to protect your local airlines but don't want to alienate the voters who want cheaper fares. Other industries have had to change with the times, some succeeded others didn't. Some sectors, particularly agriculture have tremendous lobbying power and have won significant protection and subsidies.

How much power should unions have ? Ideally more than the ME but less than the west were they can prevent change and ultimately send an industry broke.

When you take a cruise on Royal Caribbean the fares are low because third world wages are paid to the Philippinos working in the dining room, the Chinese cleaning the cabins and the Indians working below decks. Would you be prepared to pay the increased fares which would be needed to pay union rates to American workers ?


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:41.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.