PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Freight Dogs (https://www.pprune.org/freight-dogs-41/)
-   -   DC8-70 vs A300 (https://www.pprune.org/freight-dogs/133049-dc8-70-vs-a300.html)

Larry in TN 6th Jun 2004 19:38

DC8-70 vs A300
 
Can anyone compare the freight carrying capability of the DC8-70 series (71 or 73) which the older A300?

I would have thought that the A300 carried at least as much but someone else thought the DC8 carried more.

alapt 7th Jun 2004 05:22

Depending on the EOW of the -8, it is an easy 42 tons! Great aircraft. Great engines, easy airframe and a real cockpit...three drivers!

Flip Flop Flyer 7th Jun 2004 07:24

Larry
 
Under ideal circumstances, you can get around 50 tons onboard a -73. An A300B4 will max out at around 45. However, the Bus has much more in the way iof volume and is capable of carrying a wider selection of ULD types. The -73 has superior range over the B4.

For an integrator doing short/medium routes, the B4 will probably be a better deal. For long hauls or dense loads, the -73 will probably be a better choice. Horses for courses and all that.


The A300-600F will lift more than the -73, albeit at slightly shorter range.

PS
The B4 also has a "proper" 3-man cockpit. :ok:

Larry in TN 7th Jun 2004 18:51

Thanks. I didn't realise that their capacities were that similar.

411A 9th Jun 2004 07:55

Those that are looking at the -B4 should also note that there is a rather severe (read expensive) airworthiness directive regarding fuselage structure, which may well affect many aircraft.
Ain't no free lunch.:uhoh: :uhoh:

Clarence Oveur 9th Jun 2004 11:12

Could you be a bit more specific 411A?

411A 9th Jun 2004 16:11

Section 46 (if I recall correctly), very similar to Boeing's 747 section 41 difficulties.

anguspm 10th Jun 2004 12:49

411A,

You are thinking of the Frame 47 cracking at the lower radius.

The repair is expensive (circa half a million €) but thankfully isn't present on many airframes (six I think at the moment) and can be accomplished in 20-25 days (same as a standard 2C and 5yr CPCP chk).

"Why plan when you can react?"


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:01.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.