PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Fragrant Harbour (https://www.pprune.org/fragrant-harbour-19/)
-   -   new recruiting grounds for CX (https://www.pprune.org/fragrant-harbour/474914-new-recruiting-grounds-cx.html)

tipsy.skipsy 15th Mar 2012 07:28

indians = Herd mentality
 
today you hire 10 , next year there will be 100 , by the time you old fellas know it - the best and brightest of the indian skies will be hopping puddles in a cx jet and and the skies of hong kong will smell of curry fart. :}

but hey .. still safety is our number 1 priority ... so we at qantas believe .. racism and appalling customer service is the way forward. :}

404 Titan 15th Mar 2012 07:53

Spitfire88

This comming from a Australian whos working for a HK airline??
There is a fundamental flaw in your argument here. India has copious amounts of unemployed pilots. Hong Kong doesn’t. Infact Hong Kong has a huge shortage of pilots.

This has happened because of little or insignificant opposition from the unions and because of market conditions.
Again another wet behind the ears wannabe who hasn’t a clue what he/she is talking about. How about you tell us what the unions here should do about the inferior T&C’s being offered to people like you. Before you answer that question I suggest you do some serious research into Hong Kong labour laws and the implication to union leaders and members for taking unprotected industrial action, i.e. not approved by your employer.

Do you know what the market conditions are that you speak of? CX have manipulated market forces by dramatically lowering the experience levels required to apply. They have deliberately compromised safety for the almighty dollar and people like you are accomplices to this degradation in safety levels. First they offered this pathetic deal to starry eyed wannabes from the UK, Aus, NZ, Can and the US. When it became obvious that there weren’t enough suitable suckers in these countries they are now praying on the suckers in India. Thank god all the successful applicants in Pakistan saw this package for what it really is, indentured slave labour and turned it down. :ugh::yuk:

robin.pereira 15th Mar 2012 08:02


First they offered this pathetic deal to starry eyed wannabes from the UK, Aus, NZ, Can and the US.
are you one of them?

if yes (chuckles).

If not, why are you still working with CX?

like smurf84 mentioned, why don't you have the gall to walk out <assuming you are working with CX> when you're not able to help yourself. we are not here to make things easier for you by not taking up this offer.

AQIS Boigu 15th Mar 2012 08:11

Back in Karachi
 
It looks like CX managers are in Pakistan this week...

robin.pereira 15th Mar 2012 08:19


and the skies of hong kong will smell of curry fart.
tipsy.skipsy - that's fine as long as the very same skies don't smell of vegemite.

:)

404 Titan 15th Mar 2012 08:44

robin.pereira

are you one of them?
No.

If not, why are you still working with CX?
You really are dopy idiot aren’t you? People like me are jumping up and down about the conditions being offered because, apart from safety implications of almost all the new recruits over the last several years having ˂250 hours, all we want is for you to have the same T&C’s we have.

like smurf84 mentioned, why don't you have the gall to walk out <assuming you are working with CX> when you're not able to help yourself. we are not here to make things easier for you by not taking up this offer.
Like I said to Spitfire88, I suggest you do some research into Hong Kong labour laws before you make such an uninformed comment about current CX pilots. So you are under no misconception or confusion, for any CX pilot to just walk as you have suggested, would be a breach of contract and leave them open to law suites.

What your comments and others of your like are really alluding to is that you want us to do all the work and take all the risk so you can have a job here.

robin.pereira 15th Mar 2012 10:30


You really are dopy idiot aren’t you?
you should be asking yourself whether you're one. you people keep mentioning the same thing again and again. you are also kind enough to say that you want us to get the same T&Cs.

okay so what do you suggest we do? i can only imagine if CX would place the offer letter right in front of me - and I say " hang on, I'm turning this down, since there aren't any jobs in India for low-timers and also because i'm not happy with the T&Cs, and so are the pilots currently in CX who aren't happy with the current T&Cs either and i want to sgo back home, watch Tv all day, warm up my couch"?????? boom! there goes my job in thin air. maybe i'll be doing you a favour. but what do i lose - an airline job i've been waiting for the past 1-2 years.


I suggest you do some research into Hong Kong labour laws before you make such an uninformed comment about current CX pilots. So you are under no misconception or confusion, for any CX pilot to just walk as you have suggested, would be a breach of contract and leave them open to law suites.
so that is your problem? fear of breach of contract and strict labour laws. what happened? u didn't see that coming, did you?. may i ask what were you doing your research on all this while - how to stop indian pilots from joining CX? with all due respect Sir, you are totally helpless, running out of options and trying to pull us into your blame game and telling us what to do and what not to do. it isn't going to work that way, if you thought we were vulnerable to your opinions. definitely not a good idea.

boxjockey 15th Mar 2012 10:41

Robin,

Pure AWESOMENESS!!! You are the FUTURE!!!! ...........

box (snoring)

3rd Floor 15th Mar 2012 10:56

@Robin


you should be asking yourself whether you're one.
You are the dopy fool robin :ugh:


you people keep mentioning the same thing again and again.
I wonder why that is? Maybe because YOU don't listen!! :ugh:


but what do i lose - an airline job i've been waiting for the past 1-2 years.
Typical SJS response. Go fly for Spice Jet first and hopefully you'll change your mind about CX. Who knows, you might join CX under better terms and conditions


you are totally helpless, running out of options and trying to pull us into your blame game and telling us what to do and what not to do.
Pull your head in fool!!! We all don't want to be listening to you whining in the future about your terms and conditions that you signed to.

The only reason CX is interviewing in India is because they are desperate!! It's as simple as that. :=

broadband circuit 15th Mar 2012 13:39

As previously posted by myself, the argument is not about your nationality, it's about your experience. All this stuff about giving Indian pilots a hard time is just smoke & mirrors.

The reality is that in terms of experience, they're scraping the bottom of the barrel. Here's a few gems to prove my point:


First they offered this pathetic deal to starry eyed wannabes from the UK, Aus, NZ, Can and the US
Sorry, India isn't Robinson Crusoe when it comes to starry eyed, ultra low experience pilots. They have them everywhere. Put simply, in the past, they didn't meet the min requirements for an interview at CX. It's about experience, not nationality.


an airline job i've been waiting for the past 1-2 years
Most pilots at CX now, and in the past, waited a hell of a lot longer than 1-2 years for their airline job, either serving in a military uniform, or scraping their way through GA into a commuter airline, in a bid to meet the min requirements. That took an absolute minimum of 7 years, usually 10. Once again, it's about experience, not nationality.


They havent called any1 from India with less than 250 hrs
In the past, 250 hrs would not have got you an interview, regardless of nationality. The fact that they are even considering bare minimum 250 hr guys demonstrates that anyone with experience sees the new contract for what it is. Bare minimum experience is the same whether you're Indian, Aussie or Canadian. You're still bare minimum, and in the past would not have been considered for an interview at CX.

So stop this "you're an ignorant bunch of Indian bashers" rubbish. It's not about your nationality, it's about your experience (or lack thereof)

flyhardmo 15th Mar 2012 14:36

The fundamental problem
 

Also u forget cx is a business, If u cant get similar skilled or better for a cheaper amount, theyd be stupid not to.
And you would be stupid to encourage it. You are basically saying its ok to be payed less and have a tougher life because cx is a business.


We would love better terms, but if not and manageable we'll settle.
the main reason cx are lowering T&C's is because of the undercutting the undercuttters attitude that you possess and justify. :ugh:

Once again this is aimed at anyone stupid enough to accept these conditions

ckalli 15th Mar 2012 15:21

this has become quite a senseless argument ..

all the senior pilots posting.. you guys had better t&c because u earned it! im sure all of u joined with more than 250hrs. therefore better terms.

todays recruitment is for 250-1500hrs. you think a fresher at 250 hrs has options? that too in india? people have been waiting for 3-4yrs for a job. and cx is capitalizing on that.

what ever bull**** offer they hand out.. guys have no choice. its no longer about terms and conditions.. its about flying! its about surviving.

im sure no cadet with 200hrs offered a job with cx will even worry about the terms. all he/she sees is a break! an opportunity to start their career; with a good airline, flying wide body jets! sounds like a pretty good deal to me!

maybe like you all said later on it might not seem as good. but then again... at that time there were no other options.

its take whats offered. or do nothing.

slowjet 16th Mar 2012 00:04

Ooooooh, love all this. And to think, good mate of mine , FAILED to get into Cx way back in 1978, because they thought he was an I N D I A N !!!
.........................er, and the same guy, told a really black looking Massai Warior type that he would not get into CX...ER, beacause he was..BLACK, and the Massai failed the initial interview............... Luv it." On behalf of Captain Ranjit Banjit& the crew!"..........................Turn in your grave Laurie !!.................It IS going to happen !
& the

uspilot 16th Mar 2012 00:27

flying wide body jets! sounds like a pretty good deal to me

you get more action flying flight simulator at home on your PC than being a SO...YOU ARE NOT A PILOT....:ugh:

But really...who promised you guys a job when you signed up to become a pilot...you guys are starting to sound like it's owed to you...:=

Cpt. Underpants 16th Mar 2012 01:00

slowjet

You are the twisted racist. Leave the race card at home. There are many people of color in Cathay already, you're not breaking any mould.

They didn't come with the baggage you clearly have.

Oh, AND I suspect they're a lot more capable than you'll ever be.

404 Titan 16th Mar 2012 02:27

Spitfire88

Let me put it in simpler terms so your winnie little pea brain can understand. You think you’re hard done by because you can’t get a job in India with 250 hours where there are allegedly 6000 unemployed pilots. India isn’t alone here my friend. Europe reportedly has about 8000 unemployed pilots and the USA 20000+. It would be very interesting to see India open its aviation labour market for any foreign pilot with ≥250 hours. That would put the cat amongst the pigeons with you bunch of spoilt Indian brats who thinks the world owes them a living. My guess is you’re probably from a well off middle to upper class Indian family, your parents sent you to Australia, New Zealand or the USA and paid for your flying training. You probably haven’t worked a real job in your life and like your buddy robin.pereira, who claims that he sits on the couch watching TV all day if he can’t fly, my guess is you do the same. You probably still live at home with mummy and daddy. It is clear from your posts though that you have a severely inflated opinion of your own self importance. Get over yourself buddy. The world owes you nothing and if you were stupid enough to be fooled by the Indian Aviation bubble over the last 5-10 years, that is your fault. If, god forbid you actually make it to CX and you come here with the attitude you have, i.e. self importance and racial intolerance, you’re in for a very rude shock.

boxjockey 16th Mar 2012 03:53

Very well said 404. It has nothing to do with race, it has everything to do with experience. There has been a consistent decline in experience levels entering this airline for many, many years. I can include myself in that equation, as I'm sure I had less experience that some of my predecessors. The thing is, there needs to be a minimum level of experience in order to do this job safely, and efficiently. I am a big believer in experience. I think it is what you draw on when things turn pear-shaped. I don't believe we are enhancing our safety culture if ALL of our current recruits are of the same experience levels that are being described in this thread. Eventually all of the holes in the swiss cheese will line up, and then what is the inexperienced crew going to rely on? Simply my opinion, but one I believe is shared by many of my colleagues, as well as the flying public, I would imagine.

box

Oval3Holer 16th Mar 2012 04:24

Pear-shaped?
 
boxjockey:


I am a big believer in experience. I think it is what you draw on when things turn pear-shaped.
Pear-shaped? Your username shows you to be in the U.S. Are you a transplant or have you been brainwashed into talking like THEM?

crewsunite 16th Mar 2012 08:45

From CEO himself
 
Flight Ops, meanwhile, has been sounding out potential pilot recruits in India and Pakistan and will launch recruitment ads soon in countries such as Singapore and Malaysia.

:eek:

CX have finally reached a dead-end!

I hope those that those whom actually carry out the interviews have there heads on straight!

A Bowl of "juicy ripe fruit" is easily spoilt by one bad apple!

I know that's exactly the point of the guys at the top " I.e Changing the culture of the work force yet again"

But Recruiters & then T&C etc that are pilots - Should be proud to filter out the bad ones please, otherwise we're heading slowly downhill with gathering speed!
:ugh:

boxjockey 16th Mar 2012 08:50

Oval,

Please tell me who THEY are? And yes, I am a transplant. :eek:

box

flyingkiwi 16th Mar 2012 09:43

you will be pleased to hear that all the line pilots that were involved in recruitment have been replaced by managment and ground interviewers apparently the pilots were demanding too high a standard.

Forward CofG 16th Mar 2012 10:04

At least we won't have to go to Nathan Rd to find a fake Rolex watch or a cheap suit.
Maybe the new recruits will also know where to get a good curry. I hate getting harassed when going into Chungking mansion.

crewsunite 16th Mar 2012 12:57

@ Flying kiwi
 
Oh - dear no I did not realize.
whats next STC have there hands tied by management and they cannot fail their line check or an PC either!

:\

cxorcist 16th Mar 2012 23:11

I think I'm going to be sick! Must have had a bad curry. Off to throw up... ("if at all required")

nitpicker330 16th Mar 2012 23:54

So how do you Indians feel knowing CX went to Pakistan first!!

Doh:D

404 Titan 17th Mar 2012 00:13

shivamjoshi

Firstly there are close to 30000 unemployed pilots in Europe and the US combined. Secondly 250 hours isn’t experienced. It is, to put it bluntly extremely inexperienced. Indian applicants may be desperate, but desperation won’t get you the job here sunshine, even with management pilots doing the interviews.

CX never has spent limitless amounts on wages. They have always been as tight as a fishes ar*e. Now they are compromising safety to be even tighter.

As for the rest of your dribble, if you can list for me, a generic airlines total operating costs and break it down in percentage order, then I will have a discussion regarding why some airlines operate on wafer thin margins.

Anyway your whole post is a bit rich for someone who aspires to become an expat pilot but hates expat pilots in India. As limited as your previous posts are you are clearly a racist idiot. If you come here with that attitude sunshine, I can assure you , you will be ripped a new ar*ehole.:yuk:


Recently i went to get my class 1 med done and i was shocked to count 19 people besides me who had come for the same purpose as i had. I was expecting people to abandon their CPL plans in a big way. But i am disappointed. Lets hope the government acts tough and throws out expats.

Harbour Dweller 17th Mar 2012 02:37


Why India is not a superpower

Amrit Dhillon

March 15, 2012



http://images.smh.com.au/2012/03/14/...lums-420x0.jpg


'It hurts the pride of Indians to be reminded of the country's poverty. But the existence of poverty itself does not hurt their pride.'


Rich Indians have forgotten the country cannot meet the basic needs of poor people.

Rich Indians hallucinating about India becoming a superpower have had delivered a much-needed thump on the head courtesy of a study by the London School of Economics, which found that it's doubtful if the country can ever become a superpower.


The whole notion that India is an ''emerging superpower'' has always been ridiculous and whoever first mooted the idea - Bill Clinton or George Bush - during the excess of goodwill that invariably accompanies a state visit, should have been bundled off to a laboratory to have his brain dissected to locate the precise site of the raving lunacy.


Even more preposterous has been the uncritical alacrity with which rich Indians embraced the notion when all they have to do is drive a few kilometres outside the big cities to rural India for a flashback to the 18th century or, even closer to home, to a nearby slum to see disease, hunger and misery that beggars belief.


The LSE study by nine India experts concludes that, despite ''impressive'' achievements, India is unlikely to become a superpower for many reasons including "the increasing gap between the rich and the poor; the trivialisation of the media; the unsustainability, in an environmental sense, of present patterns of resource consumption; the instability and policy incoherence caused by multi-party coalition governments''.


The study adds: "India still faces major developmental challenges. The still-entrenched divisions of caste structure are being compounded by the emergence of new inequalities of wealth stemming from India's economic success.''


These inequalities take your breath away. While the rich consume luxury goods and the middle class buys fancy cars and gadgets and holidays in Bangkok, they blind themselves to the reality for 700 million or so immiserated Indians.



In their vainglorious dinner-table talk about ''superpower'' status, they forget that a country that cannot meet a poor person's most basic needs - enough food, clean drinking water, and electricity - has no business aspiring to superpower status.


One has always heard that Indians have traditionally lacked a certain respect for the facts but this wilful disregard of reality is disturbing. Affluent Indians have bought the superpower fantasy not just because of a contempt for the facts, but from pride and vanity and a tendency to get all puffed up the moment the country manages any achievement.


So an obscure international award for some Indian film, a bronze medal in a sport that no one watches, an Indian company's takeover of a foreign company, or an Indian kid topping a maths exam in the US, are all trumpeted as evidence that India has conquered the world.


This is the reality: about 400 million Indians have no electricity; India has more mobile phones than toilets; millions of children are not in school; most cities have no sewage treatment systems; no major city has a continuous water supply; disease is rampant; infrastructure is pitiful; and a UNICEF report released this month says there is acute malnutrition and hunger among the urban poor, with 54 per cent more infants dying from among the urban poor than from the urban non-poor. Another UNICEF report found that 93 million Indians live in urban slums, on pavements and construction sites.


Yet should anyone plead that the poor have been left behind they will be subject to heated criticism. It hurts the pride of Indians to be reminded of the country's poverty. But the existence of poverty itself does not hurt their pride.
Economic growth rates of about 8-9 per cent over the past few years have been justifiably praiseworthy. But the benefits of this growth have been confined to the middle class and the rich.


The poor still do not have homes, basic sanitation, decent schools or nutritious food. As a young girl in American author Katherine Boo's much-acclaimed new book Behind the Beautiful Forevers, about life in a Mumbai slum, says: "We try so many things but the world doesn't move in our favour."


Middle-class Indians need to read Boo's book about life in a rat-infested hovel, near a sewage lake, with rampant dengue fever, malaria and tuberculosis, with scraps for meals, a single toilet for 100 families and then try claiming that India is becoming a superpower. There are many criteria for defining a superpower, but for India an extra one should be added. Let no one utter the world ''superpower'' till every Indian family has a toilet in their home.


Amrit Dhillon is a freelance journalist based in New Delhi.

Whilst the article itself is a little off the topic it clearly points out the attitude of some our Indian iCadet applicants who come from a rather well off background.


Shivamjoshi is described perfectly by the author, one of his own countrymen.



"One has always heard that Indians have traditionally lacked a certain respect for the facts but this wilful disregard of reality is disturbing. Affluent Indians have bought the superpower fantasy not just because of a contempt for the facts, but from pride and vanity and a tendency to get all puffed up the moment the country manages any achievement."


Primed 17th Mar 2012 06:41

Lack of experience can be overcome by high IQ and hard work. All these so called experts that had only flown small planes before going to Cathay just got lucky that they had the necessary hours to apply at the time. Now that all can apply there will be a larger pool to choose from and they can get candidates with higher IQ which is most important.

SloppyJoe 17th Mar 2012 09:02

I hate to break it to you, although as you both have such high IQ's I am surprised you don't know this, a high IQ is not the most important thing. Experience is number one when it comes to being a safe pilot.


Lack of experience can be overcome by high IQ and hard work. All these so called experts that had only flown small planes before going to Cathay
Are you serious or is this a wind up.

sarge75 17th Mar 2012 09:27

Anyone with a high IQ wouldn't consider this offer.

Where as those that think they have a high IQ......

Primed 17th Mar 2012 09:39

It should be considered that possibly the company is looking to increase the general IQ level amongst the pilot group by hiring more Indian educated pilots. Do not be too surprised if we are able to bring many more fresh new ideas to to the cockpit!

Kenny 17th Mar 2012 09:46

So let me get this straight......

You wannabe muppets are proud that Indians will work for less than everyone else and because CX is offering less, that it's a perfectly justifiable proposition?

Unbelievable!!

Gents, we are all farked in the expat world.


BTW, All you wannabe's talk about how a high IQ is a requirement to be an able pilot. Actually it's common sense and the two don't necessarily go hand in hand; I've come across some extremely intelligent individuals, who thought because they were book smart, they would make able pilots. They weren't.

3rd Floor 17th Mar 2012 09:50

@ Primed


Lack of experience can be overcome by high IQ and hard work. All these so called experts that had only flown small planes before going to Cathay just got lucky that they had the necessary hours to apply at the time. Now that all can apply there will be a larger pool to choose from and they can get candidates with higher IQ which is most important.
How is your statement possible when real line pilots were taken off the interview selection panel as they weren't recommending any of the applicants?!! IE: the inexperienced (low hour) iCadets didn't meet the requirements. Experience is not something you can rote learn from a book!!

Yet again... this is someone from CX recruitment or management :ugh:

A total windup!! :=


@shivamjoshi


First of all, my apologies for that hateful comment that i had posted on another forum. It is hard to hold back when people attack your country. I was unable to ignore the provocations on that forum.
Your apology is not accepted. You have already 'burnt your bridges'... you hypocrite!!

Primed 17th Mar 2012 09:54

3rd floor and sloppy Joe,

Surely you will want to defend your position and pride however you must learn to look truth in the eye!

Primed 17th Mar 2012 10:04

It is well known that flying the big airliners is all about flying the numbers as they say. Coming from a population where mathematics is a strength is no coincidence!

Kenny 17th Mar 2012 10:30


It is well known that flying the big airliners is all about flying the numbers as they say
It is, is it? And you know this to be true because you've been flying for how long?

Exactly what are you going to do when you have to think on your feet because the numbers don't fit a particular situation?

This like listening to Gen Y'ers on steroids, who've overdosed on SJS!

Primed 17th Mar 2012 10:35

Kenny,

Please do not be insulted by my comments. To answer your question however, high IQ and strength in mathematics show that person could indeed think on their feet. The ability to fly the numbers well should preclude getting into that situation in the first place LOL!!

sarge75 17th Mar 2012 10:42

@ primed
 
Funny, when I taught Math in India, the pass mark was 30% :}

Surely you jokers are not serious about your points about IQs.

Surely you are not that stupid

Kenny 17th Mar 2012 10:44


To answer your question however, high IQ and strength in mathematics show that person could indeed think on their feet. The ability to fly the numbers well should preclude getting into that situation in the first place LOL!!
You really believe that don't you? Boy, are you lot in for a rude awakening.

What I can't work out is if this comes from an overwhelming sense of arrogance, immaturity, naivety or just plain stupidity........

Primed 17th Mar 2012 10:55

Sarge,

Why not go and work for Quantas air?


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.