PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Flying Instructors & Examiners (https://www.pprune.org/flying-instructors-examiners-17/)
-   -   effect of flap on vmca (https://www.pprune.org/flying-instructors-examiners/234674-effect-flap-vmca.html)

glenb 14th July 2006 09:42

effect of flap on vmca
 
Consider a particular aircraft with a published vmca speed with flap in the takeoff setting, what effect will an increase or decrease of flap setting have on that speed and why? cheers

FlyingForFun 14th July 2006 18:04

None - because Vmca is always given for the take-off flap setting.

I think what you meant to ask was what effect flaps have on Vmc (as oposed to Vmca). My understanding is that the answer is still very little, if any.

FFF
-------------

B2N2 15th July 2006 00:53

Differences might be academic but theoretically there is a difference,
accelerated slipstream on the "live" side will increase lift generated also with flap deployment. On the "dead" side the flap will cause less of a lift increase because of the lesser accelerated airflow.
Therefore lift assymetry as a result of engine failure will increase, therefore a stronger roll moment.
Vmc concerns directional control however, so it is arguable as to how increased roll moment will affect yaw.
Roll towards the dead engine will generally increase the yaw towards the dead engine, which will need to be corrected with more rudder deflection.
So as a secondary effect I will say that flap does affect Vmc.
If it is actually noticeable in a real life situation , I don't know.
Vmc is a fairly academic number in itself anyway.
Standard atmosferic conditions, max gross weight
, full pwr working engine, windmilling dead engine, max aft cg etc etc etc.
You will hardly ever fly under those exact conditions anyway, so "published"
Vmc is a best guess indication, not you "true" Vmc for your conditions.
It's just as vague a number as Va.
I don't like anything below Vsse anyway.

Yon Garde 15th July 2006 08:59

In general terms, anything that increases drag will increase Vmc all other things being equal. Anything that reduces drag will reduce Vmc.

As someone else said, the actual IAS is fairly academic as the real Vmc on any given day (as opposed to published Vmca) is anyone's guess.

realcapitano 15th July 2006 12:33

The use of flap lowers Vmc beacuse your AOA reduces hence a bigger fin area is exposed in the stream flow.
The rudder is the primary control related to Vmc, so assumed the CG remains the same, so the arm, a larger rudder exposure in the airflow ensures a positive controllability also at some knots below the same situation with a lower flap setting.
Generally speaking, many aircraft models have more selectable flap positions within the flap take off range, so the use of a higher one reduces the Vmca,althought it affects other factors as the climb gradient and so on.

homeguard 16th July 2006 14:41

Vmca
 
http://gav.customer.netspace.net.au/vmca.htm

The above link is helpful with regard to the question


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:38.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.