PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Engineers & Technicians (https://www.pprune.org/engineers-technicians-22/)
-   -   Opening turbine oil cans properly? (https://www.pprune.org/engineers-technicians/408318-opening-turbine-oil-cans-properly.html)

Peter Fanelli 14th Mar 2010 14:15

OK, after wading through this thread I am forced to ask....

Just how many mechanics does it take to open a can of oil and add it to an engine?
:E

Real engines require a 5 gallon drum to be carried out on the wing for top up.


Puts me in mind of the adage about not turning a piston engine over backwards by hand because it will destroy the vacuum pump vanes. Absolute nonsense - I've got it in writing from Parker Hannefin, who make the things...
And the more that get broken the more they sell.

blackhand 14th Mar 2010 14:46

Still an intriguing argument
 
Gazin.ASKAP, Tinwacker and others:

I ask you the following:
Is opening an oil can with the correct tool an unsafe workshop practice?
Do you consider inverting oil cans before opening an unsafe workshop practice?

It behooves us as senior maintenance personnel to impart high maintenance standards to those we supervise and advise.

Using a screwdriver to open oil cans shows less than professional standards, or perhaps incorrect instruction on the use of hand tools at the base trade level. There are also OHS issue if one is using palm of the hand to strike the screwdriver.

To shake or not to shake. Appears from the posts here, to be a matter of personal experience, those that have seen frothing of the oil and those that haven't.

Those that have experienced oil foaming/frothing of turbine oil - mobil jet11 and Aeroshell 555 in my case, will err on the side of safety and shake the can. Is it akin to saying a prayer?

Peter Fanelli

Real engines require a 5 gallon drum to be carried out on the wing for top up.
And 23 inches at idle:ok:

Hi mate, I had to laugh about PH service bulletin when it came out several or more years ago, just after I had a pilot break two on an Islander, he wound the props through several times ADOR - less than 50 hours TIS.

Cheers
BH

Krystal n chips 15th Mar 2010 05:52

" Using a screwdriver to open oil cans shows less than professional standards, or perhaps incorrect instruction on the use of hand tools at the base trade level. There are also OHS issue if one is using palm of the hand to strike the screwdriver."............:ooh:

I was mortified to learn that, over the years, I ( and numerous colleagues )have clearly been guilty of such flagrant acts. I am thus indebted for this advice. Indeed, with regard to workshop practices, clearly the instructors at Halton (many years ago now) were mere amateurs with little or no experience in this area.

I hate to use the old adage "never check, always assume"...cough....but do I take it you have never actually worked in a Line environment ( Mil or Civil ) and are thus more office engineering orientated shall we say ?.

Just curious though as to where your organisation, Air Utopia, operates from........:E

Runaround Valve 15th Mar 2010 06:25

Over the years I opened many Esso TJ15, Esso 2380 amd Mobil Jet 2 oil cans. You would think that if it was necessary to shake the cans before opening, that it would be written on them.

flame_bringer 15th Mar 2010 07:39

I wonder why most engineers are stingy to buy a can's opener and prefer using flat head screw drivers to open them .
Its only for about 1 buck ..

Kiwiconehead 15th Mar 2010 08:23


I wonder why most engineers are stingy to buy a can's opener and prefer using flat head screw drivers to open them
Probably the fact that theres only so much crap you can carry around on your belt or in your pocket on the the line, flat blade opens cowls, removes panels, pokes things in the cabin, levers things and opens cans. Can openers just open cans.

SeldomFixit 15th Mar 2010 09:32

Fer Christ's sake - does it say shake before opening on the bloody can ? The manufacturer would add that if needed :mad:

TURIN 15th Mar 2010 10:34


I wonder why most engineers are stingy to buy a can's opener and prefer using flat head screw drivers to open them .
Its only for about 1 buck ..
Yup, most line mechs/techs/engs have purchased these very expensive can openers called leathermans, (other multitools are available but that's a whole new thread) Sixty-odd quid gets you a shiny Victorinox Swisstool. So far from being stingy, they are actually a bit flash with the cash and will do anything to save a trip back to the van for the correct tool. :}
The GS is old hat now unless opening cowlings or, gawd forbid, actually undoing a large screw!:eek:

Blacksheep 15th Mar 2010 10:40

One never opens oil cans. One has a chap to do that. ;)

blackhand 15th Mar 2010 13:07

Jon Starr
 
Hey Jon
Have you had an opportunity to refill the oil and ground run/test fly?

Cheers
BH

Jon Starr 15th Mar 2010 23:09

Hey blackhand, nope haven't filled the engines up yet. I'm waiting for my CanKeys to arrive.

The GTD-350 will be filled this coming weekend, although it's not quite ready for a full run yet (need to do some welding work on the exhaust deflectors) so it'll just be an oil pressure test on the starter.

The Williams needs some hydraulic work and I sheared a bolt on the rear turbine housing on Sunday, so that's probably a month and a lot of swearing before I can refill that one.

I've taken your advice (and that of the people who PM'd me!) to not change the oil on the Williams, so it will get BPTO 2380 again when I do fill it.


If you're interested what I'm up to I have all of my engine work online at http://www.cursorkeys.com, thanks again to you and everyone else for all the help and tips.

lordofthewings 16th Mar 2010 04:54

New a bloke that use to open oil cans with a an old valve stem sharpened to a point...Good area for knocking it with the palm of your hand...
Personally i use a flat blade, mainly due to convenience....never can find a can opener when you trying to do theright thing...

blackhand 16th Mar 2010 06:04

Air Utopia
 

Just curious though as to where your organisation, Air Utopia, operates from.
Some technicians require only a blade screwdriver, two size shifting spanners and a large hammer to carry out complex aircraft maintenance tasks:}

Meanwhile, here at Air Utopia, technicians are paid to use the correct tool for each task.:ok:

Air Utopia's Engineer Trainer:E:E, has identified the flat blade screwdriver as the tool to be used for .......(wait for it) screwing slotted screws. At times people have tried to use it for phillip headed screws, pry bar, tooth pick, haemorrhoid probe, and to short starter motor terminals - he is still adamant that is for slotted screws.

Is like old saying from my russian friend - when all you have is hammer treat all problem like nail.
But we are not Russian Peasants, we are Aircraft Maintenance Engineers and as much as possible are REQUIRED to carry out tasks with the correct tools.

Mr Krystal and chips, I doubt very much that you are a trainer of engineers as you claim in your profile.

Cheers
BH

Krystal n chips 17th Mar 2010 06:29

" Some technicians require only a blade screwdriver, two size shifting spanners and a large hammer to carry out complex aircraft maintenance tasks"

Alas, not quite........a rag and a pen are also required. The horse hair shirt is, presumably, standard working dress in Air Utopia. :rolleyes:.....otherwise, sums up my tools nicely.

But thanks for your comments. I can use them as a feature of my Flight Safety lessons to demonstrate to students the dangers of myopic egocentricity within a maintenance environment. :E

Dodo56 17th Mar 2010 08:12

Just a suggestion to go easy on the syllables in your lessons there Krystal, should you be teaching folks who prefer to improvise than use the right tools for the job ;)

TURIN 17th Mar 2010 10:36


Just a suggestion to go easy on the syllables in your lessons there Krystal, should you be teaching folks who prefer to improvise than use the right tools for the job
Quite right. Big words tend to confuse people. You should concentrate on the Syllabus too. :8;)

Dodo56 17th Mar 2010 13:00


Originally Posted by TURIN
Quite right. Big words tend to confuse people. You should concentrate on the Syllabus too. http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...ilies/nerd.gifhttp://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/sr...lies/wink2.gif

Definitely, and never confuse "syllabus" with "syllables" :p

Krystal n chips 18th Mar 2010 06:35

Dodo,

You can relax.....I have long subscribed to the K.I.S.S principle...:)...even when teaching baby engs the fabled "best practice"....as one always does.....albeit with some practical engineering of course.....such as how to open oil cans ( various ) for example.....;):E

Swannecker 18th Mar 2010 08:07

4 pages referenced to opening a bloody tin of oil.....quality :D

Nopax,thanx 18th Mar 2010 10:19

We ain't started yet :ok: I've got a couple of combined opener/spout thingys that I got in the local hardware shop years ago. Just plunge into said can and you have a nice curvy spout to pour with. Keeps your hands clean for more important stuff like bacon sarnies. Very Gucci :cool:


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:01.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.