Formatting An External HD
 

Our computers at work are formatted to NTFS. We have a Maxtor 320Gb external HD that has also been formatted to NTFS. I want to reformat it to FAT16 so that I can use it with the Mac that we also have.

Now, I know how to do that using the Mac, but how would I do it using the PC, and would it still work with the PC afterwards?

The maximum volume size supported by FAT16 is 4 GB, so that's a lot of partitions you will have to create!!!!:eek:

FAT32 would be a better bet. You can use Disk Manager to format the disk up to 32GB FAT32 volumes in Win2K or WinXP. That's still a lot of volumes (and a large block size).

Interestingly, Win98 supports formatting much larger FAT32 volumes - up to 127.5GB - while the theoretical maximum FAT32 size is far larger (up to 8 terabytes with 32KB clusters, but as the boot sector uses a 32-bit field for the sector count, this limits the volume size to 2 TB on a hard disk with 512 byte sectors).

To create and format larger volumes you can use a 3rd party tool (e.g. this) (or MAC OSX), or indeed the command-line Format.exe utility in any Windows > 98.

However, Mac OS X doesn't manage FAT32 volumes of more than 137GB AFAIK, but you could presumably make 3 x 106GB partitions. Also MS does not recommend FAT32 volumes larger than 32GB (for "efficiency") and does not recommend larger than 127.5GB (apparently not tested). But of course Win2K / XP can use large FAT32 volumes - MS just doesn't want you to, as it wants the world to use NTFS.

I'm sure that a MAC expert can provide more up-to-date information about MAC FAT32 / NTFS support.

If Mac OSX can now reliably write to NTFS partitions, that's probably the way to go.

SD

Thanks, Saab. I've never owned a Windows PC so I'm not that familiar with their formatting. The reason I said FAT16 is that is what my USB stick is formatted to!

The Mac can read the Maxtor in it's present format, but can't write to it.

I shall ask on the Mac forum that I frequent.

I have a 250GB external HDD, formatted as a single FAT32 partition, which I can read and write to in both Windows and Mac OSX.

I wouldn't bother with FAT if I were you.

A Mac can read and write NTFS discs with the correct software (free):
http://www.lifehack.org/articles/lif...-mac-os-x.html

A Windows machine can read and write HFS+ discs, using MacDrive (cheap).

Well, I would if I were you. FAT32 is simple and readily understood. Your recommended NTFS driver is a work in progress. There's a reason most devices can read NTFS but not write to it: the structure contains secrets MS cares not to divulge. Those that write use informed guesswork, but there's till risk involved.

NTFS together with FAT32?
 

I have bought an external HD for my desktop PC as it's HD is pretty much full.
The PC's HD is in NTFS, the external HD is in FAT32.
Do I need to reformat the external HD to NTFS? (Partition magic could do that for me)
I intend to store photos and music on the external HD.

Thanks in advance for your recommendations

Spui

No.


Here's some more characters for "help help it's shorter than 10 characters" vBulletin.