PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Biz Jets, Ag Flying, GA etc. (https://www.pprune.org/biz-jets-ag-flying-ga-etc-36/)
-   -   Crash at Austrian Airshow, pilot killed (https://www.pprune.org/biz-jets-ag-flying-ga-etc/566921-crash-austrian-airshow-pilot-killed.html)

unworry 31st Aug 2015 08:53

Crash at Austrian Airshow, pilot killed
 
This is the sixth fatal incident at airshows this month.


The accident happened at the Hirt airfield, near the town of Friesach in the southern province of Carinthia.
Plane Crashes at Austrian Air Show, Fatally Injuring Pilot - ABC News


LiveLeak video: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=220_1440986637

DaveReidUK 31st Aug 2015 09:08

BFU investigating.


http://www.kleinezeitung.at/images/u...D67DC_v0_h.jpg

Less Hair 31st Aug 2015 09:19

As it happened in Austria, the german BFU has nothing to do with it.
The "Flugunfalluntersuchungsstelle Österreich" at Bundesministerium für Verkehr, Innovation und Technologie (BMVIT) in Vienna would be the investigator envolved in Austria.

Hotel Tango 31st Aug 2015 10:29

Judging by his first stunt (beginning of the longer video), this guy was not leaving himself much room for error. Was it really necessary?

sovereign680 31st Aug 2015 10:47

Well the German BFU will be involved since the Pitts was ob the German registry.

Tourist 31st Aug 2015 11:16


Originally Posted by Hotel Tango (Post 9100653)
Judging by his first stunt (beginning of the longer video), this guy was not leaving himself much room for error. Was it really necessary?

It doesn't really work like that.

It is common, once you are sure to complete the loop safely, to deliberately reduce the pull and let the aircraft get low to give exactly the impression you have received.

That is very different from what happened on the accident however. He was pulling as hard as he could on that one.

Volume 31st Aug 2015 12:09


Was it really necessary?
Especially as you can see from video that going so low just means a lot of spectators can not see you.
50 meters higher and you are always visible for all spectators and have some margin for error...

RAT 5 31st Aug 2015 12:18

One snap too many. It must have felt mushy entering the last one. Perhaps very difficult to cancel that last one if you felt committed. Damn shame.

Less Hair 31st Aug 2015 13:42

Crashed Pilot is said to have been the private jet pilot of german billionaire Ingrid Flick according to Krone newspaper in Austria.

Machinbird 31st Aug 2015 14:12


One snap too many. It must have felt mushy entering the last one. Perhaps very difficult to cancel that last one if you felt committed. Damn shame.
Maybe just a half snap too many. That looked like it was intended to be a half cuban eight profile.
In any case, he was cutting it too close.:sad:

malabo 31st Aug 2015 14:33

Shoulder roll, somewhat unpredictable as it is part gyroscopic, though here it was initiated at the top of a manoeuvre so should have been benign with recovery with margin. Held in too long, trajectory eventually goes to vertical where there is no shortcut to horizontal. Like Machinbird says, probably meant to be a half-cuban profile, we could check his sequence card to be sure.

The first loop low? Nah, just airshow where you complete a recovery and then drive it down for drama.

That's a lot of fatalities in airshow in Europe this year. UK, Italy, Ireland, Austria, Switzerland. What the hell is wrong with EASA regulations that would permit this carnage?

Lonewolf_50 31st Aug 2015 14:35


Originally Posted by malabo (Post 9100900)
That's a lot of fatalities in airshow in Europe this year. UK, Italy, Ireland, Austria, Switzerland. What the hell is wrong with EASA regulations that would permit this carnage?

Why would you assume that there is something wrong with regulations? Accidents happen rarely, but it's interesting how sometimes those that do happen cluster: there isn't always a correlation between them other than the calendar date.

Toruk Macto 31st Aug 2015 14:59

To all the talented , competent pilots out there . Take it easy .

golfyankeesierra 31st Aug 2015 15:13

And so close to the public!
Ok, the performance was not over the public but losing control after those rolls it looks like it easily could have hit the crowd!

And sorry I am no aerobatics expert but what have the multiple rolls to do with a cuban eight? Shouldn't it be only a half roll?

mv031161 31st Aug 2015 15:18

You see four snaps. Last one definitely unintentional catching the pilot of guard and exiting off heading. High Speed Stall also noticed before crash due to pull

golfyankeesierra 31st Aug 2015 15:24

But what maneuver was it supposed to be then?

mv031161 31st Aug 2015 16:05

Golf...without his sequence card or Air boss calling his maneuvers, we can only guess that his intentions were to enter the Y axis, do a 3 snaps and exit in the same on course direction.

deptrai 31st Aug 2015 18:22

Poor guy. I feel physically unwell after watching aircraft (and pilots) flying into the ground. Unrelated to this or any specific accident, just a general rant: There's a reason they're called AIRcraft, and imho when they just skim the ground they resemble redneck "monster" trucks with suspension lift kits. I've watched some pretty spectacular displays flown with recovery at minimum 100, or 300m (not ft) AGL. High precision, highly skilled aviators. For me, the feeling that maneuvers are executed reasonably safely makes me enjoy the display more (again, just a personal opinion). Personally I can't understand why many air show spectators seem not to enjoy competitive aerobatics where margins are slightly - only slightly - better. I do realise, also from posts here, that many seem to think "the lower, the more spectacular", but if that's what you like, why not watch the great american trucking show, or a steam engine display. They're built for that kind of display. Nothing personal, just a thought.

RAT 5 31st Aug 2015 19:17

In 1976 Dave Perrin, of Rothmans fame, used to start his solo display with a roll on takeoff. It was amazing to see the a/c lift off, and, seemingly, before he was half a wing span in the air he was starting the roll. It was scary; and then the inverted flight at 20' into a -ve push up to vertical. All in a Pitts S2A. 40 years ago; it was considered exceptionally skillful, but not outrageous, because we all trusted he knew what he was doing and wanted to continue to do it for many more years. Mr. Tucker does even more exceptional. I guess, as Dirty Clint Harry said; " a man's got to know his limitations". Rather than, "do you feel lucky; well do you?" Luck shouldn't be in the plan; it is skill & judgement. When there is a crack in either of those luck may be the saving grace, but as often as not you will feel the painful bite of very sharp teeth in you backside.
Is it the case that very capable aero-pilots visually assess airshow routines, regularly, to approve the capability of various pilots? I know that this will not stop the odd 'push the envelope for a little extra' by some guys on a one-off basis. In my days with air shows it was common to see the same guys on tour with their set routine. It was all well practised, thought out and performed many times per season. Is there any 'recurrency' requirement for todays airshow pilots?

deptrai 31st Aug 2015 19:49

in brief, regarding Display Authorization regulations, for the UK, CAA CAP 403, Part A - Pilot Display Competency, only stipulates that evaluators (the equivalent of a TRE) should "normally be an active Display Pilot."

Flying Displays and Special Events | Air Operations | Operations and Safety

EDIT: and..."In addition to a valid Certificate of Test and Competence, a Display
Pilot is required to meet certain recency requirements before his DA is
valid. In the 90 days preceding a demonstration at a flying display for
which an Article 162 Permission is required, a minimum of three full
display sequences must have been flown or practised, with at
least one display sequence flown or practised in the specific type
of aircraft to be displayed."

and "If the display sequence has not been practised recently, the pilot
should set himself appropriately higher minima, for practice or actual
display purposes, until such time as full currency is regained."


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:52.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.