PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   Finland's air force quietly drops swastika symbol (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/633729-finlands-air-force-quietly-drops-swastika-symbol.html)

India Four Two 2nd Jul 2020 03:51

Finland's air force quietly drops swastika symbol
 
https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....4a4c8a557f.jpg


The old emblem for the Finnish Air Force Command (left) featured a swastika, but the current emblem of the force does not
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53249645


Islandlad 2nd Jul 2020 05:34

Catching up. Better late than never. Started to go out of fashion after about 1939. There will be people defending it in some convoluted way. That will tell us more about them than the Swastika history. Good luck it may have been, but it lost that title a long time ago. Reversed. Backward swastika: backward thinking.

SpringHeeledJack 2nd Jul 2020 07:32

The symbol, in all iterations has been around for many thousands of years used in many different world religions. The National Socialist Party that came to power in Germany decided to tilt it and make it their own.representing the qualities desired to defend and put forward the cause of the Aryan race. Sadly due to the horrors of WW2 and the emotional charge instilled in people because of this association ANY Swastika is immediately associated with the Nazi Hakenkreutz, no matter how different in design, colour or form.

About 30yrs ago I had the experience of watching a friend give a slideshow presentation to a room of 60-70yr old Germans of his mountaineering expedition in Nepal. During the slideshow there were a few images of Swastikas on buildings, monasteries mostly, and there was an audible collective gasp by the audience and a following mini-hysteria that lasted several minutes. This was caused by the emotional charge associated with seeing this symbol again. Once pointed out that it was over 1,000 years old and was a sign of harmony and auspiciousness and was different in every way to the Nazi version, the room settled down again.

Whilst I agree that as a symbol, the associations are too strong to be workable because of sensitivities, it is a shame that something that has been around since before the Nazi Party, in the case of the Finnish and Latvian forces, and for millennia in religions should be quashed.

fauteuil volant 2nd Jul 2020 17:25


Originally Posted by Islandlad (Post 10826925)
There will be people defending it in some convoluted way. That will tell us more about them than the Swastika history.

I don't think that to be a fair remark.

Peter47 3rd Jul 2020 10:25

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Swastika_Society

https://redswastika.moe.edu.sg/about-rss/our-history

My reaction when I saw references to Red Swastika on arrival in Singapore were initially of shock but it predated an odious regime on the other side of the world.

Saint Jack 4th Jul 2020 02:41

Not only Red Swastika's in Singapore, the Mee Toh Primary School has a yellow swastika in it's school crest. https://meetoh.moe.edu.sg/

tdracer 4th Jul 2020 19:55


Originally Posted by SpringHeeledJack (Post 10826977)
The symbol, in all iterations has been around for many thousands of years used in many different world religions. The National Socialist Party that came to power in Germany decided to tilt it and make it their own.representing the qualities desired to defend and put forward the cause of the Aryan race. Sadly due to the horrors of WW2 and the emotional charge instilled in people because of this association ANY Swastika is immediately associated with the Nazi Hakenkreutz, no matter how different in design, colour or form.

Whilst I agree that as a symbol, the associations are too strong to be workable because of sensitivities, it is a shame that something that has been around since before the Nazi Party, in the case of the Finnish and Latvian forces, and for millennia in religions should be quashed.

Well said. On this side of the pond there has been a big controversy about the "OK" sign you might with the right thumb and forefinger. It's been used my whole life (and presumably for generations before that) to simply signal "things are OK". But then some white supremacists started using it as a sort of 'gang sign' - so now the woke crowd has declared anyone who flashes the OK sign - no matter how innocently - is automatically a vile racist.
WTF!
I'm just waiting for some woke idiot to declare the "thumbs up" signal to be racist or otherwise vile :ugh:

SpringHeeledJack 4th Jul 2020 20:44


I'm just waiting for some woke idiot to declare the "thumbs up" signal to be racist or otherwise vile https://www.pprune.org/images/smilies2/eusa_wall.gif
They'll have the angry ghosts of the Romans to deal with!

FlightlessParrot 4th Jul 2020 23:51


Originally Posted by tdracer (Post 10829104)
I'm just waiting for some woke idiot to declare the "thumbs up" signal to be racist or otherwise vile :ugh:

When I went to live in Australia in the '60s, I was told that "thumbs up" was an obscene gesture, which being interpreted meaneth "sit on this." That sense seems to have fallen into desuetude with the passage of time, as I suspect will the appropriation of the OK gesture. Swastikas are different, and I must confess, until I recently discovered the history, I was surprised to see pictures of Finnish aircraft during the Winter and Continuation war wearing that symbol. "Weren't they good guys?" I thought, and then discovered they also got some arms from Germany. Now I understand it was a case of "my enemy's enemy," the same principle on which Churchill accepted an alliance with the USSR, and that swastikas had nothing to do with it. But still, that symbol is irretrievable in the Euro-American world (First Nations excepted).

megan 5th Jul 2020 04:22


When I went to live in Australia in the '60s, I was told that "thumbs up" was an obscene gesture, which being interpreted meaneth "sit on this."
In my near eight decades never heard of it I'm afraid, not someone having a lend of you, or do I need to get out more? Middle finger on the other hand....

meleagertoo 5th Jul 2020 11:50

The thumb-up hitch-hiking sign is the equivalent of a raised middle finger in some countries, Greece being one istr, although they do realise that a hitch hiker dosn't intend that meaning. That understanding is not present in some other places though.

FlightlessParrot 6th Jul 2020 02:13


Originally Posted by megan (Post 10829279)
In my near eight decades never heard of it I'm afraid, not someone having a lend of you, or do I need to get out more? Middle finger on the other hand....

Could have been someone having a loan of a new chum, but there are famous cultural incompatibilities. My favourite, relevant to the context, concerns the Australian colloquial expression for a minor greebie (and this is one I've heard people using IRL). Australian woman goes to London for working holiday, catches a bad cold, rings the office to call in sick and, in total innocence, says "I can't come to work today, I'm in bed with a wog." Also a once common Australian brand of adhesive tape which caused similar problems when approaching UK stationery departments: Durex.

My info on hand signs was NSW, '60s, where the middle finger was only known to people with an interest in Americana.

Edited to add: Quora thread Thumbs up in Australia suggests that my memory of a long time ago is perhaps accurate, though maybe it was only used in such coarse places as the NSW country.

jensdad 6th Jul 2020 03:23

Anyone know why the new Finnish Air Force emblem seems to have a crown in it when Finland is a republic?

fauteuil volant 6th Jul 2020 06:57


Originally Posted by FlightlessParrot (Post 10829999)
Could have been someone having a loan of a new chum, but there are famous cultural incompatibilities. My favourite, relevant to the context, concerns the Australian colloquial expression for a minor greebie (and this is one I've heard people using IRL). Australian woman goes to London for working holiday, catches a bad cold, rings the office to call in sick and, in total innocence, says "I can't come to work today, I'm in bed with a wog." Also a once common Australian brand of adhesive tape which caused similar problems when approaching UK stationery departments: Durex.

My info on hand signs was NSW, '60s, where the middle finger was only known to people with an interest in Americana.

Edited to add: Quora thread Thumbs up in Australia suggests that my memory of a long time ago is perhaps accurate, though maybe it was only used in such coarse places as the NSW country.

As Shaw said, perhaps here we have another two nations separated by a common language?

megan 7th Jul 2020 00:25

NSW? Say no more. :p Re Durex, I made that mistake when posted to the US and went to the stationary section of the PX and asked the young lass for a rubber (eraser as it's called in the US). Australian dictionary,

https://slll.cass.anu.edu.au/centres...gs-origins/all

FlightlessParrot 7th Jul 2020 01:42


Originally Posted by megan (Post 10830787)
NSW? Say no more. :p

Thought that might have been the prob. Togs or bathers?

Mr Mac 7th Jul 2020 10:52

As an exchange student in the states in mid 70,s I was staying with a family who had a couple of daughters of the Cheer leader / girl next door variety, and we were going up to Washington for couple of days which involved an early start. I offered the previous evening to "knock" them both up in the morning for the early start. This caused both girls to burst out laughing, while parents looked at me some what aghast,needless to say my error was corrected.There was also an issue when I called their female Labrador a "bitch", not a female dog. Two countries separated by a common language !!
Cheers
Mr Mac

Haraka 7th Jul 2020 18:06

I once had an interesting query from a lady American Officer when describing the Harrier as the "Bona Jet".......

megan 8th Jul 2020 02:45


Togs or bathers?
Budgie Smugglers is an additional option.

Bull at a Gate 8th Jul 2020 11:50

FlightlessParrot and I must be about the same age. When I was at school in NSW the thumbs up gesture was considered very rude. The V Sign was ruder. But the middle finger (“the bird”) was unknown.


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:06.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.