PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Aviation History and Nostalgia (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia-86/)
-   -   DAMBUSTERS (Film) Remake - 2009 (https://www.pprune.org/aviation-history-nostalgia/348860-dambusters-film-remake-2009-a.html)

MRAF 29th Oct 2008 02:57

DAMBUSTERS (Film) Remake - 2009
 
Peter Jackson, (3-time OSCAR film director, producer and screenwriter, best known for directing The Lord of the Rings trilogy) announced back in 2006 that he had bought the rights to remake the DAMBUSTERS and intended on going ahead with the project.

FilmStew.com • Defending Dambusters

There has been little news since and most of it very low key, but it is now confirmed that filming will start for the $66 million project in 2009.

They are going to find 'another appropriate name' for the dog.

The script has been written by Stephen Fry.

Casting is still to be announced.
Following the 'BofB casting' thread, what do we think of this project that IS going to happen?

Who should be cast…

Cast list from original:
• Richard Todd as Wing Commander Guy Gibson
• Michael Redgrave as Dr. Barnes Wallis
• Ursula Jeans as Mrs Wallis
• Basil Sydney as Sir Arthur Harris
• Patrick Barr as Captain Joseph Summers
• Ernest Clark as Honorable Ralph Cochrane
• Derek Farr as Group Captain J N H Whitworth
• Charles Carson as Doctor
• Stanley Van Beers as Sir David Pye
• Colin Tapley as Dr. W H Glanville
• Raymond Huntley as Laboratory Official
• Harold Goodwin as Wing Comdr. Gibson's Batman
• Richard Leech as Squadron Leader H.M. Young

:hmm:

JEM60 29th Oct 2008 08:16

I believe that the suggested name for the dog is'African American'..........

Max Tow 29th Oct 2008 08:25

Why not just shuffle the same letters & call it "Ginger"?

Runaway Gun 29th Oct 2008 08:57

Because an Orange Labrador won't be anyones best friend.

Will Hung 29th Oct 2008 08:58

Why not just keep it's proper name ?

It's a rhetorical question. I know why not. Because the do-gooders and PC brigade would denegrate one of the greatest Englishmen ever, who risked his life countless times, gaining a VC in the process, fighting a genuinely racist regime.

How did we ever get by without them ?

Avitor 29th Oct 2008 09:34

Why not remake The World at War? The PC brigade can then have a field day and all of us would have to apologise for something or other. One never knows, perhaps the little Georgian might emerge as a hero and the mad Austrian as an honourable ethnic cleanser!
Could never happen again though, we now have the EU.
What I mean to say is leave out the dog altogether, it would cause too much controversy.
If that makes little sense, then so does a remake, or is it a modern slant, on the heroic and legendary Dambusters. imho.

PPRuNe Pop 29th Oct 2008 09:42

I was in a tropical fish shop on Monday and I noted that a particular fish I liked when I kept fish was a nigger barb, orange with black vertical bars, but now it is called something else, which I thought was crass.

As for Guy Gibson's dog. It was called Nigger and no amount of PC crap can change it. When I was young I too had a dog called Nigger. GG's dog is an important part of history and the name should remain untouched. The film, if made, will forever be known as the film that didn't stick to the facts, albeit a Labrador dogs name. But that dog was a part of Gibson and it is NOT for others to change history.

Anyway, I doubt that anyone can ever capture the atmosphere of the original Dambusters film, however hard they try.

Brian Dixon 29th Oct 2008 10:00

Not just the name of Gibson's dog, PP. It was also the code word for a successful dam breach.

I totally agree with you - It is not for others to change history.

S'land 29th Oct 2008 10:05

It seems that the world today wants to re-write history so that anyone who so much as swore at someone else is vilified as a war criminal, let alone name a dog with a word that has become un-PC. I suppose that in these PC, huggy fluffy days the name of the dog will always be a bone of contention. However, if they change the name they move away from historical accuracy. The name of the dog was also the code name for the successful breach of the Mohne Dam.

PPRuNe Pop 29th Oct 2008 10:13

Brian and S'Land - I didn't think of that! See, another part of history apparently being swiped from history, and yet a vital, nay pivotal, moment in a true to life film.

It makes me mad. What with the PC'ers and Elf 'n Safety what is the world coming to? :ugh:

Brian in answer to your time question. The time is PCT in San Fransisco where the owners of PPRuNe reside. Usually six hours but we retarded ours, if you see what I mean!

rogerk 29th Oct 2008 11:10

What a bloody stupid idea !!
 
You can't "remake" a classic film ??
Look the American remake of "The Italian Job" just don't work.

Will Hung 29th Oct 2008 11:26

Agree with that rogerk. I'd still watch it though !!!

rogerk 29th Oct 2008 14:15

So will I Will Hung !!
Just to see if they have named the dog "Mugabe" !!

Gainesy 29th Oct 2008 15:58

Now that's an insult to Black Labs.

JB007 29th Oct 2008 16:45

I suppose the water affects in the new film will be better though!

Peter Jackson's a brave man! Anyone name a remake that surpassed the original?!?

TURIN 29th Oct 2008 16:55


Anyone name a remake that surpassed the original?!?
Casino Royale. :ok:

s'land

....let alone name a dog with a word that has become un-PC.
It was un-PC back in the 40s it's just that we didn't have many black folk around then so no-one batted an eyelid.

BTW this was done to death on JetBlast a few weeks ago.

JB007 29th Oct 2008 17:02

Ahh...now Casino Royal was originally a 1 hour, made for US TV Drama back in 1955...and just for the Americans, Felix Leiter was the swarve brit and 'Jimmy' Bond the hero...and the Peter Sellers spoof doesn't count, so not letting you have that!!

NutherA2 29th Oct 2008 17:21


Anyone name a remake that surpassed the original?!?

Casino Royale (1967)


Directed by Val Guest, Ken Hughes. With Peter Sellers, Ursula Andress, David Niven. In an early spy spoof.........

The Daniel Craig version was certainly an improvement on this cr@p

kluge 30th Oct 2008 03:50

chaps - similar thread debated on Jet Blast recently.

I'm hoping for a Bollywood version to be produced.

PPRuNe Pop 30th Oct 2008 13:55

OK. Back to topic please.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:13.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.