PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Pilots land at wrong airport. (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/585645-pilots-land-wrong-airport.html)

skol 13th Oct 2016 06:00

Pilots land at wrong airport.
 
Not the first time by a long shot. I remember QF in the 1980's lining up on Hughes Field, miles away from LAX doing a visual approach.

Passenger plane lands at the wrong airport after pilots ignore their navigation equipment.

Passenger plane lands at the wrong airport after pilots ignore their navigation equipment - Travel - NZ Herald News

DaveReidUK 13th Oct 2016 06:25

PPRuNe thread at the time (4 years ago!):

http://www.pprune.org/south-asia-far...g-airport.html

Pinky the pilot 13th Oct 2016 09:15

Hey, I once landed at Kaintiba and requested cancel SAR Kamina!:ooh::eek:
Or was it the other way 'round?:confused:

Middle of the Wet, it was...

Any ex PNG lapuns will savvy.:D :E

tail wheel 13th Oct 2016 10:58


Hey, I once landed at Kaintiba and requested cancel SAR Kamina!
Don't feel bad about it Pinky. I remember when a Government Airline landed a Green Gravel Truck at Tefalmin instead of Telefomin then had to whistle up a Chook to lift it out as the runway was a tad too short!!

:}

Metro man 13th Oct 2016 12:19

The airports look very similar from the air, and being on the coast the runways are the same direction. The mistake is quite easy if you try and eyeball it, thats what navigation equipment is there to prevent.

In India, the ATIS for Chennai warns pilots not to mistake the nearby military airbase for the civil airport, something to do with a cargo jumbo landing there by mistake.

Pinky the pilot 14th Oct 2016 00:46

Taily;

Green Gravel Truck
A 'Bou?:confused:
Thought those things could get into and out of nearly anything a Bongo Van could!

Derfred 14th Oct 2016 01:39

What navigation equipment?

tery84vx 14th Oct 2016 02:12

Air india also came close to landing a 787 at Essendon

TBM-Legend 14th Oct 2016 02:16

TAA came close to landing on the highway at Mackay once..

JamieMaree 14th Oct 2016 08:32

Skol,
You need to check your facts before you splash!
The airport that was the mistake was Hawthorn which is about 3-4 miles from LAX. You go past it at about 1200' depending on which runway you are landing at in LAX. No excuse for it but LAX in the haze can be an issue specially if ATC has left you high.

Metro man 15th Oct 2016 02:19


What navigation equipment?
RNAV can give you the extended centreline of the runway.
GPS on the runway threshold to give bearing and distance.
ILS/DME tuned in even for visual approach.

That way if you are on short final but your instruments show the airport is 10 miles away it may indicate you are in the wrong place.

Chris2303 15th Oct 2016 04:56

A Globemaster trying for 29 at NZCH was going to land on Memorial Drive.

Many years ago now of course

KeepItRolling 15th Oct 2016 07:30

Air India also came close to landing a 787 at Essendon

And Garuda (multiple times).

And United.

ShyTorque 15th Oct 2016 09:30

I once landed at exactly the correct place, but a month early!

(Tasking cell's mistake, not ours..they sent us in June and the user wanted us in July).

Old Fella 16th Oct 2016 09:58

JamieMaree is spot-on SKOL. Having followed the QF across the Pacific from HNL we landed ahead of it into LAX. Later in the evening in SFO the story came out and I cannot recall whether or not the QF boys bought the beers, but maybe they should have. It was late September 1980. BTW, Hughes has been closed now for about 30 years.

skol 24th Oct 2016 03:48

I'm quite sure I'm correct, it was in the early 1980's, I was posted to Los Angeles at the time.

Wunwing 24th Oct 2016 05:35

I agree, early 1980s. There was a bit more to it though. As I remember, it was only the second QF landing into LAX and the crew were given a "mud map" by the 1st crew which was supervisory crew. The mud map featured fuel tanks as a marker. The trouble was that there were 2 different lots of fuel tanks. One lot not seen by crew number one and that was what caused the confusion.
I was on crew 3 waiting in HNL and we rapidly had the mud map withdrawn from our brief sheets.
Wunwing

ACMS 24th Oct 2016 06:48

Didn't they have an ILS in LAX then? Why use a mud map to fly a visual approach into an unfamiliar Airport???

In the past I've done a visual right base onto 24R from SMO, but that was in blue sky and I'd been there multiple times before.....

Old Fella 24th Oct 2016 07:24

I would be amazed if Qantas did not have Jeppesen Approach Plates for LAX and if they had not required operating crews to have done at least one simulated approach to LAX before operating into the facility. It is too long ago to remember exactly, but I am pretty sure we used the ILS for arrival, at least until visual with the runway. We were a B707.

TBM-Legend 24th Oct 2016 07:38

C-17A lands at GA airport instead of Homestead AFB, Florida>>


http://www.google.com.au/url?q=https...JGcerHRtz32FJA

another oops!


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.