PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Qantas tops airline safety rankings (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/572932-qantas-tops-airline-safety-rankings.html)

anito4a 9th Jan 2016 00:51

Qantas tops airline safety rankings
 
Well done to Qantas for topping the Airline Safety Rankings for 2016. Virgin Australia also features in the top 20 list and QantasLink scores a 7/7 in the rankings as well. But what about the other Australian based airlines?

Rex, VARA, Air North and Tiger Australia don't have IOSA accreditation according to AirlineRankings.com.

Airline Ratings

This is what IATA says about their safety audit.

The IATA Operational Safety Audit (IOSA) program is an internationally recognized and accepted evaluation system designed to assess the operational management and control systems of an airline.

Should airlines not having IOSA accreditation be of concern to the travelling public?

Stanwell 9th Jan 2016 01:14

Hello Geoffrey! :E

airdualbleedfault 9th Jan 2016 04:25

HK Express made top 10 LCCs which makes the whole thing seem like a farce

gordonfvckingramsay 9th Jan 2016 05:58

Quite obviously not an exhaustive audit then. They failed to take into account the multitude of latent threats that saturate the industry.

Engineering cutbacks, fuel saving initiatives, efficient (read predatory) roster practices, sub-sub-subcontracts, desperate management practices, cabin crew pay and conditions approaching poverty levels, shorter turn around times, less ground staff, failing morale, and the real doozie, a regulator that doesn't/can't afford to care.

Only a matter of time till we are witness to a tragedy in this country. They have whittled away everything but the bare minimum components required to maintain the illusion of safety.

Slippery_Pete 9th Jan 2016 06:50

Personally, I've always wondered which airlines a bag chucker/rampie would recommend.

compressor stall 9th Jan 2016 07:04

Is it any surprise? Geoffrey Thomas is an editor of the "company" that commissioned this. It's payroll masquerading as news.

A 2 second domain search reveals that the airline ratings.com is hosted by wa newspapers....

GT, its a good idea to cover your tracks to your master's door a little better.

HeartyMeatballs 9th Jan 2016 08:12

And in Europe flyBE are listed as one of the safest LCCs which made me chuckle. Why isn't Hawaiian top who've not had a hull loss since they were formed in 1929. And no safety ratings for easyJet and Ryanair, two of the biggest airlines in the continent. I wonder how many FF miles QF issue the 'judges' of the ratings.

4Greens 9th Jan 2016 09:00

You dont need judges. Qantas is the second oldest airline and the world and has never lost a passenger in the jet age.

The name is Porter 9th Jan 2016 09:45

Geoffrey Thomas - Member of the Qantas Chairman's Club.

Some would say conflict of interest.

Stanwell 9th Jan 2016 09:52


Originally Posted by 4Greens (Post 9233192)
You dont need judges. Qantas is the second oldest airline and the world and has never lost a passenger in the jet age.

Don't know about that...
They lost me. :*

Boe787 9th Jan 2016 10:11

Gordon, 100% on the money, they have indeed whittled away at everything,
But at the same time managed to reward themselves with all time high salaries and bonuses!

Compylot 9th Jan 2016 13:48

Gentlemen.

Geoffrey Thomas is world renowned multi award winning writer, author and commentator (with a stern yet professional, slightly smug, but responsible look) who has had a holistic view of the aviation industry for more than 40 years.

He has an outstanding reputation...with aviation personnel...

Airline Ratings

Please, some respect :=

CurtainTwitcher 9th Jan 2016 17:58

"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"
--Upton Sinclair
I, Candidate for Governor: And How I Got Licked
(1935)

Metro man 9th Jan 2016 19:33

JACDEC put Cathay first with QANTAS in 7th place.

Airline Safety Ranking 2015 » JACDEC

VH-UFO 9th Jan 2016 23:50

Poor poor Geoffrey.

scavenger 10th Jan 2016 05:14


A 2 second domain search reveals that the airline ratings.com is hosted by wa newspapers....

GT, its a good idea to cover your tracks to your master's door a little better.
Given that "Presented by the West Australian" is written on the homepage right next to the website name, I'm not sure covering tracks was the intention. Good sleuthing though...

BuzzBox 10th Jan 2016 05:47


Geoffrey Thomas is world renowned multi award winning writer, author and commentator (with a stern yet professional, slightly smug, but responsible look) who has had a holistic view of the aviation industry for more than 40 years.

He has an outstanding reputation...with aviation personnel...
Sounds like a massive case of self-aggrandisement on the part of Geoffrey Thomas. He might think he has an outstanding reputation with aviation personnel, but most people I've met think he's a complete plonker!

Stanwell 10th Jan 2016 07:12

No, that was just another of Compylot's attempts at wry humour. (Keep trying son - you're getting a little bit better.)

Personally and professionally, I've encountered few people who are further into self-aggrandisement than GT.
The former bag-chucker from Port Hedland now describes himself as an "Aviation Professional".
Baggage handling and despatching as many as two movements a day from there makes you that, don'tcha know?

This self-appointed "Aviation Expert" is always available at short notice to comment on matters on which he's not qualified.
If you're a clueless journalist catering to the 'great unwashed', just ask him a question and he'll give you any answer you want to hear.

As for his relationship with the 'red tail rat', well, that's already been noted on here in the past.

compressor stall 10th Jan 2016 08:18

https://twitter.com/Qantas/status/344331847356006400

Capt Fathom 10th Jan 2016 09:07

They really should just get a room!


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:06.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.