PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Melbourne satellite re entry? (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/543315-melbourne-satellite-re-entry.html)

Tankengine 11th Jul 2014 11:29

High altitude chemtrail sprayer?:E

500N 11th Jul 2014 11:33

Arnold,

It says you are 64.

Don't you remember haileys comet ?

Or the space junk that re entered and spread metal over Southern aus ?

Or seeing shooting stars ?

Did yo not see all the pictures and video of the russian meteorite re entry and explosion a few years ago ? It was on all the news and in the papers.

All since 1982.

aroa 11th Jul 2014 12:09

the battered earth...
 
spend a few clear nights away from the bright lights and you get plenty to look at.
"Shooting stars" going every which way, big and small. Its the much bigger ones we have to worry about :eek: And satellites too, many of

The SYD MEB burn up of space junk was beauty. Falling aeroplane comments notwithstanding

Saw goody a few weeks ago... tracked NW to SE over FNQ, made a stripe in the sky, a few bits fell away before it burnt out. Not quite as speccy as MEBs

What we really need for CB is a Tunguska Event.!! :ok:

500N 11th Jul 2014 13:06

It just occurred.

It reminded me of an F-111 doing a dump and burn.

compressor stall 11th Jul 2014 14:06

Leonids in 98 or 99 were spectacular. Camped on top of a dune in mungo np and lay in our swags watching fireballs rip across the night sky. Lit up the ground.

And I was airborne and saw the Hyabusa re entry over Woomera a few years back. That was a spacecraft with a story. The NASA DC8 that came over sure had some toys in it. Optically perfect glass cabin windows.

If you think how ignorant the general population is about aviation (media too ) there is a similar level of ignorance regarding astronomy.

There were media references to this being an asteroid or a comet. That's as bad a clanger as a Boeing Airbus 747.

Stanwell 11th Jul 2014 14:49

Arnold,
Come spend a few nights with us under the stars in the Outback.
That'll cause you to raise an eyebrow - and just on 'ordinary' nights.


And, of course, the difference between a meteor and a meteorite is only its location. OK?

fujii 11th Jul 2014 18:45

500N
 
Don't you remember haileys comet ?

No, but I do remember Halley's Comet.

500N 11th Jul 2014 18:50

OK, valid point :O

compressor stall 12th Jul 2014 02:07

And here's a good report as to what it was.

Re-Entry of Soyuz Rocket Stage catches Australian Observers by Surprise - SPACEFLIGHT101

Hydromet 12th Jul 2014 03:16


It reminded me of an F-111 doing a dump and burn.
In September or October 1991 I was outside Wagga Wagga and saw what I first thought were three RAAF aircraft doing a dump & burn, but then noticed a number of smaller burning objects on parallel courses. I watched these as they passed north-south, for between 30 & 60 seconds, by my estimation. They were reported over a wide area.
It was very quiet, no traffic noise, and it seemed to me that I could hear the sound from these, like a high-flying jet aircraft. Would one of our astronomically knowledgeable members be able to comment if this was feasible, or a figment of my imagination.

500N 12th Jul 2014 03:24

Hydro

Night or day ?

Were they travelling horizontal or vertical or across the horizon so to speak.

Reason I say is one aircraft makes the noise and flares create the other lights,
If of course it was at night. Flares last 30 - 60 seconds and are often fired in 2 - 3's.

Wagga is an army training area, especially in 1991.

You get some amazing patterns.

Captain Gidday 12th Jul 2014 03:36

This thread will probably now get longer than Alan's Not Happy, but have you ever thought what might happen if even a tiny bit of incoming debris, natural or man made, impacted your thin aluminium tube at altitude?
Sends shivers up and down your spine, if you stop to think about it.
Probably better not to stop to think about it.

500N 12th Jul 2014 03:38

Do a google search on space shuttle debris collision.

Some doozy photos of holes in skin and nice dent, star in windscreen - from a fleck of paint :rolleyes:

compressor stall 12th Jul 2014 03:55


but have you ever thought what might happen if even a tiny bit of incoming debris, natural or man made, impacted your thin aluminium tube at altitude?
Not really as the odds are spectacularly low. Like really really low. The odds of impacting incoming debris in the collective shape of another aircraft is orders of magnitude larger. Only one person has been hit by a meteorite as it came through her roof as she lay in bed - although I think a dog was killed by one back in the 50's.

Most meteoroids (and space junk) burn up by the time they get anywhere near the stratosphere. On the Space Station, however, 430km up they have installed shields to protect against the very real risk of depressurisation due to meteoroid impact.

le Pingouin 12th Jul 2014 04:53

CaptG, ask yourself where all the buildings full of holes from meteorite impact are. By the time most meteors/space junk that survives to reach the lower atmosphere (such as where aircraft fly) they are at terminal velocity so a small piece won't be carrying a huge amount of energy. Would a 5mm rock travelling at 200kph penetrate an aircraft skin?

ruddman 12th Jul 2014 05:05


Would a 5mm rock travelling at 200kph penetrate an aircraft skin?

Who wants to find out? Maybe all jet aircraft need to have mattresses taped to them just in case. :8


They also say there is more chance of being killed by a donkey then killed by being in an aircraft accident. :confused:

My luck the flight would go perfectly fine, touch down smoothly then hit the damn donkey on the runway taking me out in the ensuring fireball. :{

Avgas172 12th Jul 2014 05:58

So the moral of the story is stay away from someone's ass on the runway .... :}

Captain Gidday 12th Jul 2014 07:00


Would a 5mm rock travelling at 200kph penetrate an aircraft skin?
Probably not.
Would a 5mm rock coming in head on with a closing speed of nearly 1100 km/hr penetrate an aircraft skin?
I suspect it would.

aroa 12th Jul 2014 07:40

the 5mm rock....
 
ouch !

Jumbo at 1000 kph meets rock at 200 kph,....I reckon it might put more than just a dent in the Jumbo skin !!! :eek:

Hydromet 12th Jul 2014 08:16

500N
Sightings (at night) were reported from a large parts of western NSW and Victoria. All the objects were on parallel straight tracks, and were later reported to be either a meteorite breaking up or space junk. They travelled at a uniform velocity, and I watched them through an arc of at least 90 deg. I estimated their max. altitude angle at about 60-80 deg.

Definitely not flares. As I say, at first I thought they may have been RAAF from Forest Hill.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:18.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.