PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Australia, New Zealand & the Pacific (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific-90/)
-   -   Qantas Fined $61m (Merged) (https://www.pprune.org/australia-new-zealand-pacific/302205-qantas-fined-61m-merged.html)

Ang737 27th Nov 2007 20:10

Qantas Fined $61m (Merged)
 
Just heard on the early morning news that QF have been fined $61m for price fixing on their cargo prices between US and OZ... Ooops :eek:

Jabawocky 27th Nov 2007 20:23

Ouch!:ouch:

Is that here in Oz, because I bet they will get pinged both here and the US which could mean a bit more loose change is about to be confiscated.

Of course that will come out of executive bonuses not the T&C's of the workers, so do not fear!

J:E

Annulus Filler 27th Nov 2007 20:45

If I remember correctly, Qantas had this money set aside to cover this expense 12 months ago.

Ang737 27th Nov 2007 21:06

Yeah they did. In Sept this year they annouced that had put aside $41m in anticipation. A 20 million short fall is a significant amount and would have to hurt.

Keg 27th Nov 2007 21:12


QANTAS has agreed to plead guilty and pay a $US61 million ($69.4 million) fine in a US court after being charged with price-fixing international air cargo rates for more than six years from January 2000.

The US Department of Justice filed charges against Qantas Airways Limited in the US District Court in the District of Columbia in Washington DC today.

The department accuses Qantas of engaging in a "conspiracy to eliminate competition by fixing the rates for shipments of cargo to and from the United States and elsewhere from at least January 2000 to February 2006".

During that time Qantas was the largest carrier of cargo between the US and Australia and made more than $US600 million ($683.7 million) from its cargo flights along the route.

Representatives from the airline were not immediately available to comment.

Under the plea agreement, which still needs to be approved by the court, Qantas has agreed to cooperate with the ongoing US investigation.

"Qantas's guilty plea sends a clear message that those who engage in price fixing and other forms of illegal collusion will pay a heavy price for their crimes," assistant Attorney-General Thomas O Barnett said.

Mr Barnett, who is in charge of the US Department of Justice's antitrust division, said: "The shipment of consumer products by air transportation is critical to our global economy.

"Our investigation into this important industry will continue, and we will aggressively pursue those who engage in criminal conduct that harms American consumers," he said.

Qantas was charged with carrying out the price-fixing conspiracy by participating in meetings and talks in the US and elsewhere to discuss the cargo rates to be charged on trans-Pacific routes to and from the US.

It also engaged in meetings and talks to enforce the agreed rates.

The US Justice Department said in August, British Airways and Korean Air Lines pleaded guilty and were sentenced to pay separate $300 million criminal fines for their role in price-fixing on cargo prices.
www.news.com.au

Capt Wally 27th Nov 2007 21:17

..............hmmmmmm have Pratts & QF merged?:}

gaunty 27th Nov 2007 21:25

OK lets see here, whether I steal a gazzilion dollars at gunpoint or not I can expect to go to gaol, hard time.

So who in Qantas is going to step forward and take it like a man for the team???:mad:

Just like our paper/board manufacturer friends. At least Qantas didn't try that sleazy PR/Australian magazine/philanthropist routine, what a prat. :{

Sunfish 27th Nov 2007 21:38

Why am I not surprised that Qantas would engage in illegal behavior?
I hope that one of the things Mr. Rudd does during his first 100 days in office is to provide for a criminal (rather than civil) convictions for price fixing and similar anti competitive behaviour and attach mandatory long jail terms.

QFinsider 27th Nov 2007 23:06

Corporate Governance and repsonsibility should see the board resign en mass...

Sadly both are lacking at Q and it will be business as usual.

Torres 27th Nov 2007 23:38

One assumes the three or four hundred million dollar windfall goes into the US consolidated revenue and not one cent is returned to the victims of the alleged cartel?

qantasjetstar 28th Nov 2007 00:07

QANTAS fined $60 million. Not a good example from the flag carrier
 
Qantas were fined $60 million for price fixing. A lot more than the $47 million they had set aside. ( Channel 7)
At the recent Qantas A.G.M the directors made light of the charge, but it just shows that Qantas act illegally when it suits them. Surely the directors and not the shareholders should be held responsible.
Imagine how many bottles of plonk they could have given the passengers.
Has Mrs Dixon's little boy Geoff been caught with his fingers in the cookie jar. If not then why won't he speak up.

Phileas Fogg 28th Nov 2007 00:12

Do BA not hold a shareholding in Qantas, price fixing is old hat to BA!

Ralph the Bong 28th Nov 2007 00:50

Yes Torres, perhaps the victims of this scam could take civil action.

BD1959 28th Nov 2007 01:00

No Phileas, not since 2005.

It will be interesting to see what spin Margaret Jackson puts on this little blot of her tenure.

BD

rmm 28th Nov 2007 01:18


Yes Torres, perhaps the victims of this scam could take civil action.
Looks like it's already underway,

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2...28/2103509.htm

Lowkoon 28th Nov 2007 01:37

If I set u a business to conduct illegal activities, wouldnt i be held responsible? Why are these people never held responsible or made accountable?

Earl 28th Nov 2007 03:22

Wonder who the other 30 are?
 
http://edition.cnn.com/2007/BUSINESS....ap/index.html
Qantas admits price-fixing in U.S.
WASHINGTON (AP) -- Qantas Airways Ltd. on Tuesday became the third international airline this year to admit to price-fixing and agree to pay a multimillion-dollar fine to the U.S. government.
art.qantas.getty.jpg

Qantas acknowledged imposing fuel surcharges in the airline's freight division.

The Australian carrier's CEO said U.S. and foreign antitrust regulators are investigating up to 30 airlines for similar conduct.

Qantas sought to eliminate competition by fixing the rates for shipments of cargo to and from the U.S and elsewhere from at least January 2000 through February 2006, according to the charges filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

During the time covered by the felony charge, Qantas was the largest carrier of cargo between the U.S. and Australia, earning more than $600 million from its cargo flights between the two nations, according to the Justice Department.

Under the plea agreement, which is subject to court approval, Qantas has agreed to cooperate with the Justice Department's ongoing investigation and pay a $61 million fine.

Qantas Chief Executive Geoff Dixon apologized for the illegal conduct, which he said involved fuel surcharges in the airline's freight division. The company's financial statements include a $40 million provision for the U.S. case, and "we do not believe this or any further financial penalties will materially affect future operating results," he said.

Qantas has cooperated fully with antitrust investigations in the U.S. and elsewhere since May 2006 and expects them to take up to two years to complete. "We understand more than 30 other airlines are included," Dixon said in a release.

Earlier this year, British Airways PLC and Korean Air Lines Co. Ltd. each pleaded guilty and agreed to pay separate $300 million criminal fines for their roles in conspiracies to fix the prices of passenger and cargo flights.

Qantas was charged with carrying out the price-fixing by participating in meetings to discuss the cargo rates to be charged on certain trans-Pacific routes to and from the U.S., and then levying rates according to the agreements reached.

Four former and two current Qantas employees have been excluded from the plea agreement and the Justice Department has reserved the right to investigate further. The two current Qantas employees "deny involvement in any illegal conduct," Dixon said.

"It was so unnecessary, they didn't really have to collude," said airline consultant Michael Boyd, adding that cargo rate increases and fuel surcharges were justified based on rising oil prices in recent years.

Fuel costs accounted for the largest piece of U.S. airlines' operating expenses in the second quarter of 2007 at 25.4 percent, and are expected to represent more than 26 percent of airlines' expenses globally in 2007, according to domestic and international trade groups.

It's unclear if any U.S. carriers eventually will be incriminated in the Justice Department probe. If a domestic airline simply saw its foreign competitors raise rates and did the same "that's not illegal," Boyd said. "But picking up the phone and talking about it is."

RevMan2 28th Nov 2007 06:38

Lufthansa Cargo was one of the first to be investigated and cooperated with the authorities for a reduced fine of $85m

The CEO took immediate early retirement "for health reasons"....

qantasjetstar 28th Nov 2007 07:01

Qantas C.E.O Geoff Dixon won't resign
 
I think that more than the CEO should resign. This type of operation is not what Qantas stands for.
Are they working for themselves or the shareholders?
Dixon has just been awarded 1 million shares, for what? Breaking the law again.

Reeltime 28th Nov 2007 08:39

So the shareholders have to fork out for this fine? What about the individuals responsible?

I sincerely hope this is just the beginning of this, someone has got to start digging into the goings on with the management of this once proud company.

It's interesting to note that the price fixing has been going on for the last six or so years.

ACCC and ASIC get your acts together and start doing what you're supposed to be doing....having a damned good look into the board and management of Qantas!


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:07.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.