PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   Squawk in position report (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/336174-squawk-position-report.html)

moon11 22nd July 2008 10:06

Squawk in position report
 
Dear Aviators: ATC and Pilots,

I have heard on radio in Taiwan and Japan airspace some airlines (AHK,SQ), report squawk in position report.
Is it new ICAO rule or some pilots try to confuse ATC and the rest of us?

Many thanks in advance,

moon

Phantom99 22nd July 2008 19:45

Some Far Eastern and Middle Eastern carriers (mainly) report their squawk on initial contact with London too, it is not required or requested, however it doesn't bother me too much (but I always check it just in case, especially if they give aircraft type as it is sometimes different to that on the flight plan)

moon11 24th July 2008 07:39

Thanks phantom,in my opinion reporting squawk is of 0 (zero) importance
to other pilots and only cause radio congestion on frequency.
Somebody can think that is unsafe also,because more important info as altitude may evaporate from the other pilots memory.

aarongth 24th July 2008 15:39

Side track a bit, does ATC requires pilots to say "maintaining FL XXX" on reaching assigned FL in radar environment?

chevvron 26th July 2008 07:03

Are these flights 'handed over' ie is a radar ident passed, or are they just calling without a handover? If they're just calling without a handover, then it will be helpful to the receiving controller in order to quickly identify them.

parkfell 27th July 2008 09:25

With call sign conversion of the SSR code, this technique on first contact is obsolete. Also wait to be asked to "ident" before doing so, as this is part of the validation process.:)

chevvron 27th July 2008 10:36

Vercingetorix: not all of us have the luxury of automatic C/CS conversion; sometimes we transfer traffic to other units saying 'report squawk on first contact' sometimes other units do this to us.

moon11 31st July 2008 13:06

Many thanks gentlemen,it is clear now,
talk to you soon,
best regards,
moon

powerstall 2nd August 2008 06:04

maybe due to traffic congestion, it would be easier for them to locate you on their screens and if in need give you vectors as soon as possible if they foresee a possible conflict....

just my two cents... :E


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:47.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.