ANS v NATS
I notice Air Navigation Solutions are advertising for trainee ATCOs at the moment. The timing isn't right for me to apply this time around but hopefully will be next year, which got me thinking - would people recommend ANS compared to NATS?
- With NATS you could end up anywhere (eg, area or aerodrome in London, Aberdeen or anwhere in between) whereas ANS is only LGW / EDI and all aerodrome/approach (I think?). Obviously if you desperately want to avoid London/Edinburgh then NATS might be the better option but if not, ANS offers a little more certainty. - NATS have a long track record of training newbies and developing their careers, how do ANS compare in this regard? - Job security is probably higher at NATS but then again a validated ATCO is unlikely to struggle to find work if the worst happened Any thoughts? Clearly neither are bad options |
NATS offers a much better chance of avoiding London as 90% of the trainees will end up doing Area control instead. In terms of training I have no idea what ANS are like, but being tower only will give you more flexibility to move elsewhere in the country. With my Area rating I'm stuck at Swanwick or Prestwick or the few countries abroad that allow non nationals, and have English as their main language, to work in air traffic.
ANS don't do the approach for Gatwick, that's done by NATS at Swanwick and I'm not sure about Edinburgh. |
ANS remains an unknown entity to most and is building a poor reputation - last week's EFPS failure, one example.
Their ATCO training scheme and its success is unknown. Job security, unknown. ANS do approach radar at Edinburgh only, potential for dual ratings. Word on the street is staff at Gatwick are not happy bunnies, short staff crisis and shipping support in from German towers to make ends meet. Worth noting, since some initial 'success' in securing the ATC Tower contracts at Gatwick & Edinburgh (co-incidentally owned/operated by the same company at the time), ANS have failed to gain any further major business in the UK... |
Worth remembering that should you train at Gatwick and fail to validate, ANS have only Edinburgh to possibly post you too. There are only so many ATCO’s needed there however. At least one such failure was offered a Lighting Operator position at Gatwick, but long term this role will be automated. NATS, having more airfields potentially, may be able to potentially offer those failing to validate at busy airfields more sedat3 locations. There are other ANSP’s however to apply to if you fail. Few of these would be of interest perhaps to either ANS or the greater NATS I think. |
NATS training currently isn't refined to the sunny south coast of the UK either, there have been courses recently sent to Jerez in Spain to do initial training.
NATS can send you anywhere however you also have the ability to move within the company and if you seek a more managerial position then there are very good & numerous prospects available. |
Originally Posted by T250
(Post 10521970)
ANS remains an unknown entity to most and is building a poor reputation - last week's EFPS failure, one example.
Because Nats (or other ANSPs for that matter) never had an equipment failure resulting in major disruption? Or airport closures due to ATC staffing? Or en route restrictions due to ATC staffing? This summer's CTOTs are horrendous on a fairly regular basis. |
Originally Posted by BigDaddyBoxMeal
(Post 10522757)
Other examples?
Because Nats (or other ANSPs for that matter) never had an equipment failure resulting in major disruption? Or airport closures due to ATC staffing? Or en route restrictions due to ATC staffing? This summer's CTOTs are horrendous on a fairly regular basis. |
I find it quite baffling looking at the ANS accounts who got paid for what they did and then researching ANS further online who benefits from all of it too!!!! The 2018 accounts are of most interest.....
|
Some interesting replies so far, keep them coming :ok:
NATS offers a much better chance of avoiding London as 90% of the trainees will end up doing Area control instead NATS can send you anywhere however you also have the ability to move within the company and if you seek a more managerial position then there are very good & numerous prospects available. |
If you do get an interview with ANS you may want to enquire as to the success rate for trainees at Gatwick following the post NATS period.
|
|
My experience to date (after joining ANS in January 18) has been very positive. The success rate of the Ab-Initio programme rivals NATS and the certainty of knowing where I was going to be posted was far better for me. As people have mentioned above, Edinburgh is TWR/APP whereas Gatwick is TWR only. I disagree with the comment above that ANS have a poor track record, the EFPS failure the other day was unprecedented, but failures occur in technology all the time - I don’t feel like ANS has had more than a “normal” amount. If anybody has any questions about the ANS process I’d be more than happy to help where possible 🙂 |
Originally Posted by middles
(Post 10524207)
If you do get an interview with ANS you may want to enquire as to the success rate for trainees at Gatwick following the post NATS period.
|
Originally Posted by DanJaws
(Post 10525365)
My experience to date (after joining ANS in January 18) has been very positive. The success rate of the Ab-Initio programme rivals NATS and the certainty of knowing where I was going to be posted was far better for me. As people have mentioned above, Edinburgh is TWR/APP whereas Gatwick is TWR only. I disagree with the comment above that ANS have a poor track record, the EFPS failure the other day was unprecedented, but failures occur in technology all the time - I don’t feel like ANS has had more than a “normal” amount. If anybody has any questions about the ANS process I’d be more than happy to help where possible 🙂 |
If you fail to validate at Gatwick will ANS offer you a place at Edinburgh and give you an APS rating later on? Rgds AyrTC |
Originally Posted by AyrTC
(Post 10526839)
If you fail to validate at Gatwick will ANS offer you a place at Edinburgh and give you an APS rating later on? Rgds AyrTC Gatwick is a bloody hard place to validate, so I’m sure they have many contingencies in mind! |
Originally Posted by DanJaws
(Post 10526971)
Gatwick is a bloody hard place to validate, so I’m sure they have many contingencies in mind! Not to say some controllers at Gatwick (especially in the tower) in the NATS era weren't ace; I was inbound on a fam flight one day and when we were at 4 miles (the previous lander just vacating), they still managed to get 2 departures away before we were cleared to land. Hopefully this skill has been carried over to ANS controllers. |
Originally Posted by chevvron
(Post 10527331)
Several people from Farnborough were posted there when it was still NATS and they came back with the definite impression that certain persons made it their business to make sure they didn't validate; hopefullly those persons are now gone.
Not to say some controllers at Gatwick (especially in the tower) in the NATS era weren't ace; I was inbound on a fam flight one day and when we were at 4 miles (the previous lander just vacating), they still managed to get 2 departures away before we were cleared to land. Hopefully this skill has been carried over to ANS controllers. |
I think you’ll find that most of the instructors that are at Gatwick now are the same ones who were there when NATS were the ANSP. So they probably have gone!! And like most things in life, there is good and not so good; good instructors and not so good instructors. Also, there are probably some instructors there who really shouldn’t be instructing! It’s also safe to say though, I’m sure your friends from Farnborough ‘impression’ was I’m sure just that. I am certain there is nobody there who ‘made it their business to make sure they didn’t validate’. Maybe they just weren’t good enough?? That’s normally the case �� |
Originally Posted by DanJaws
(Post 10527345)
Not sure about the NATS era, but instructors have made it clear that provided you’re showing the effort and commitment required, they’ll go to great lengths to ensure a successful outcome. I’ve never had a problem with anybody helping me, or guiding me during my training. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 22:25. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.