PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   Odd Flight Levels Westbound (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/617162-odd-flight-levels-westbound.html)

pattern_is_full 11th Jan 2019 17:15

Odd Flight Levels Westbound
 
A question about the dynamics of this incident, which shows something I've never experienced, but I haven't flown in all ATC jurisdictions.

Incident: Wizz A320 near Madrid on Nov 10th 2018, descent below cleared level causes near collision

Incident begins with two aircraft straight and level - westbound - at FL310 and FL290. Usually I'd expect westbound aircraft to be at "even" flight levels 280, 300, or 320, for example. Although the primary rule in Class A is "what ATC assigns," of course.

Is this just because the aircraft are closing on 110nm to destination and for ATC purposes are in a preliminary descent? Would the RVSM floor of FL290 be a factor (as low as possible while still allowing RVSM-rules flexibility, regardless of direction)?

Crazy Voyager 11th Jan 2019 17:27

Some places have a north/south division rather than east/west due to traffic flows. France is one and I think Spain might be the same, as I recall it’s then south-odd north-even.

pattern_is_full 14th Jan 2019 18:21

Thanks - I was just waiting to see if other explanations surfaced, but yours is fine!

DTY/LKS 16th Jan 2019 18:09

From what I gather then the aircraft was descended to the safe level of 1000’ on top of the other aircraft. For whatever reason he bust his level.
Although west/east levels still exist, nowadays ODLs are the norm & a lot of the time don’t need to be co-ordinated with the next sector or unit. We use them as an aircraft’s requested FL might not be available so you give them the next best level whether it is correct direction level or not, and also due to the increase in traffic in complex airspace then you sometimes need to use ODLs.

chevvron 16th Jan 2019 18:44

ODLs have been in use for over 40 years; I often handled traffic at 330, 350, 370 all going the same way (westbound) when I was at Lindholme controlling upper airspace traffic in '73.

ATC Watcher 18th Jan 2019 07:20

Semi circular ( E-W) or quadrantal (E-W + N-S) were created for non surveillance airspace and VFR , when under positive ATC surveillance , you can use any level you want .
Also at time created , most airways were bi-directional, which is no longer the case. Capacity is also an issue today , maximizing the use of airspace is the norm .
ODLs were indeed already used widely in the 70,s a s Chevron said . above. ( I used them myself a lot at the time and in fact always did. )
Finally pattern is full : no nothing to do with 100 Nm to destination or RVSM , just maximizing the sue of the airspace .

zonoma 20th Jan 2019 22:51

ODLs are almost a thing of the past in busy airspace. Routes are becoming unidirectional so any level goes. And there are several FIR boundary points that utilises either East or Westbound levels for traffic on routes that are contrary to the East/West rules.


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:09.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.