PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   Airprox at Heathrow? (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/616911-airprox-heathrow.html)

DaveReidUK 4th Jan 2019 08:21

Airprox at Heathrow?
 
... or just a radar processing glitch ?

This, from Heathrow's own WebTrak system, appears to show an extremely close encounter between an Air Canada 737 MAX and a Swiss CSeries on converging tracks inbound to LHR:

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....9ae47b3e0a.jpg

Heathrow WebTrak

Given that it's from last weekend, it would no doubt have been all over the media by now had it actually occurred, so presumably it's an artifact from NATS' radars.

Cany anyone account for what might have caused it ?

HEATHROW DIRECTOR 4th Jan 2019 09:35

Only 49 ft apart. Wow, they're packing them in nowadays.

Packer27L 4th Jan 2019 11:18

Surely a processing glitch. TCAS would not permit them to get that close, not to mention the keen-eyed ATCOs at Swanwick nor the mk1 pilot eyeball.

Gonzo 4th Jan 2019 17:49

Pretty sure that's a Webtrack error, SWR35B (LX352 GVA-LHR) was already on the ground by this time. No record of a SWR5717 or any other Swiss flights from GVA-LHR on that day around that time on the usual sites. It's not a LHR callsign/flight number that I recognise, nor does it appear on FR24 or other ADS-B tracker sites that I can see.

DaveReidUK 4th Jan 2019 21:34


Originally Posted by Gonzo (Post 10351913)
Pretty sure that's a Webtrack error, SWR35B (LX352 GVA-LHR) was already on the ground by this time. No record of a SWR5717 or any other Swiss flights from GVA-LHR on that day around that time on the usual sites. It's not a LHR callsign/flight number that I recognise, nor does it appear on FR24 or other ADS-B tracker sites that I can see.

Quite so. It would also be rather unusual to see a GVA-LHR flight on an Ockham STAR for 27s, as in this case.

Still showing on WebTrak as I write - drilling down shows the mystery flight as being operated by HB-JBB, the same aircraft that landed as LX352 20 minutes previously.

Very strange, I'll see if Heathrow can shed any light on it.

HEATHROW DIRECTOR 5th Jan 2019 06:54

Forget it Dave. I trust Gonzo far more than all the on-line "radar".

DaveReidUK 5th Jan 2019 09:16


Originally Posted by HEATHROW DIRECTOR (Post 10352316)
Forget it Dave. I trust Gonzo far more than all the on-line "radar".

I do, too.

The strange thing is that we're not talking here about FR24-type "radar" (i.e. crowd-sourced ADS-B), with all its limitations. Instead, it's the official Heathrow Airport flight monitoring website powered by data from NATS radars.

Heathrow tells us:

The flight data for Webtrak is taken directly from the National Air Traffic Services (NATS) radar that is used to direct aircraft at Heathrow. The accuracy of the system has been verified by the Civil Aviation Authority and by independent Dutch company NLR.
See Heathrow - track flights on maps

Notwithstanding the above endorsement, it's certainly not unknown for WebTrak to miss flights completely (a BA DUB departure and a UA EWR arrival in recent weeks, for example), but I can't remember any previous occasion where an entirely fictitious flight has been shown, as in this case.

Hence my professional curiosity as to what might have caused it. :O

chevvron 5th Jan 2019 09:38


Originally Posted by DaveReidUK (Post 10352425)
I do, too.

The strange thing is that we're not talking here about FR24-type "radar" (i.e. crowd-sourced ADS-B), with all its limitations. Instead, it's the official Heathrow Airport flight monitoring website powered by data from NATS radars.

Heathrow tells us:


See Heathrow - track flights on maps

Notwithstanding the above endorsement, it's certainly not unknown for WebTrak to miss flights completely (a BA DUB departure and a UA EWR arrival in recent weeks, for example), but I can't remember any previous occasion where an entirely fictitious flight has been shown, as in this case.

Hence my professional curiosity as to what might have caused it. :O

Another one of Putin's little tricks; I'm convinced the Gatwick drone was one too.
He's got egg on his face after the Salisbury poisonings so he's trying to get back at us by economic means.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:29.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.