PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   Hectopascals (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/599374-hectopascals.html)

Thrush 12th Mar 2019 05:41

HPa
 
its all to do with the US habit of knocking off the “2” so 29.91 becomes 991 on the RT.... There was an Airprox a while ago in the Shetland Isles between a US crew in a Kimg Air and an ATR. That’s what caused it all, I’m told. The AAIB report refers.
Having said that, I went to SNN recently and the atco asked us what units we were using. Mb obv....! Well, we were tempted to say it for a bit of sport but remained professional with HPa.

faoiarvok 12th Mar 2019 09:07


Originally Posted by Thrush (Post 10414563)
Having said that, I went to SNN recently and the atco asked us what units we were using. Mb obv....! Well, we were tempted to say it for a bit of sport but remained professional with HPa.

Yep, we’re required to say it even above 1000, plus we add a zero if below 1000: “Zero Niner Niner Seven hectoPascals”

The result of a number of level busts including a couple where terrain was a factor, from 99X being misunderstood as 29.9X

chevvron 13th Mar 2019 05:56

There was a suggestion a couple of years ago that an abbreviation of 'hectopascals' might be looked into and agreed, but I've heard nothing since.

meleagertoo 13th Mar 2019 12:55


Originally Posted by chevvron (Post 10416184)
There was a suggestion a couple of years ago that an abbreviation of 'hectopascals' might be looked into and agreed, but I've heard nothing since.

There is always millibars, a universally-used unit that we all understand and can relate to, unlike the bizarre, meaningless Eurobabble hector-pastilles.

Oh? What? Were they?

Well why the digamma did they change it then? That is not progress.

DB6 13th Mar 2019 14:30

Millibars? Nah, not enough syllables :E.

ZOOKER 13th Mar 2019 18:09

DB6,

We're lucky........It could have been Gay-Lussac who did the pressure experiments......Or even worse, Avogadro. :uhoh:

ZOOKER 13th Mar 2019 19:43

Imagine if there had been more recent research into pressure by Prof. Brian Cox.

'Hectocox'? Or 'Hectocoxes'.

chevvron 14th Mar 2019 09:18


Originally Posted by meleagertoo (Post 10416624)
There is always millibars, a universally-used unit that we all understand and can relate to, unlike the bizarre, meaningless Eurobabble hector-pastilles.

Oh? What? Were they?

Well why the digamma did they change it then? That is not progress.

Regretfully hectopascals is an ICAO SARP, not an EU requirement. Nobody knows why ICAO decided on hPa instead of mb especially as the value is the same.

LookingForAJob 14th Mar 2019 14:18


Nobody knows why ICAO decided on hPa instead of mb especially as the value is the same.
Not strictly true. ICAO has chosen - with a small number of well defined exceptions - the International System of Units to be used as the standard system of units of measurement for all aspects of international civil aviation air and ground operations. This makes some sense - why pick/develop/use something else when the vast majority of States worldwide (although, notably, not the US) have agreed to use SI units. By practise and general agreement the units are given names related to scientists whose work was related to the element being measured; for pressure the work of Blaise Pascal was selected (perhaps interestingly, the same Pascal after whom the computer programming language is named). ICAO, since its inception, has sought to harmonise the units of measurement used in aviation - originally it recognised five different sets of units that were used globally - and adopted a harmonised set of units based on SI in 1979. In 1984 ICAO States agreed that the days of the bar were numbered and set the end of 1985 as the final date that the bar would be used in aviation. The UK held out against the change for some time and continued to use the millibar for met reports and related purposes - clearly there are a few people on this form who think this is a good thing although personally I tend to find more important things to get excited about and got used to using hPa within a day or two of their eventual mandate in UK ATC. Oh, and just in case the final bit of the puzzle is still not obvious, 'hecto' is the SI prefix for hundreds of things.

ZOOKER 14th Mar 2019 14:34

Thank heavens we're still using feet for all things vertical. Long may it continue to be so.

meleagertoo 14th Mar 2019 14:51

Since (on an appropriate scale) metric aircraft use milimetres to measure length, mililitres to measure volume, miliamps to measure current, milivolts in the electronics, miliTeslas in magnetic fields, and above all pressure in bars it seems a completely retrograde step to suddenly divert from this logical and self-evident progression to abandon milibars in favour of the (to most) largely meaningless hectopascal, be it an SI unit or not.

To me, progress that ain't.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:46.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.