PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   ATC Issues (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues-18/)
-   -   France: Mulhouse airport traffic controller killed (https://www.pprune.org/atc-issues/449985-france-mulhouse-airport-traffic-controller-killed.html)

rab-k 27th Apr 2011 14:57

France: Mulhouse airport traffic controller killed
 
BBC News story here..

aluminium persuader 27th Apr 2011 16:25

That's not at all good! Thoughts are with the family. :sad:

captplaystation 27th Apr 2011 16:42

One would hope that there is enough sophistication in the security control such that it could identify who had swiped themselves in & out in the preceding hours, thereby perhaps identifying the perpetrator.
Of course, the person could have entered with a stolen badge.

Amexgull 27th Apr 2011 17:26

And how many times have you found a fire door wedged open or such like? Lets hope it is more straightforward than that, poor fella...

ron83 27th Apr 2011 18:16


Of course, the person could have entered with a stolen badge
Even so,what was the motive to do it?:sad:

RIP and condolences to family.:(

captplaystation 27th Apr 2011 18:32

Don't think that was quite what I was discussing :hmm: I was merely suggesting that hopefully the security arrangements may have been sophisticated enough ( & ,if as suggested by another poster, just as critically, followed) they may be of some help in identifying the guilty party.

hangten 27th Apr 2011 20:54


what was the motive to do it?
Indeed, herein lies the real issue. There's likely quite a story behind this. It almost sounds like a murder mystery.

My thoughts and condolences.

BrATCO 27th Apr 2011 21:30

Sad day for French ATC.
My thoughts to his family.
Some of my colleagues were his classmates.:(

And how many times have you found a fire door wedged open or such like?
Doors can be left open inside a tower. The ouside door to enter the tower is closed and secured.

I don't know about Basel tower, but entry points in CDG, ORY, Paris, Reims and Brest ACCs are secured by Gendarmerie (Military Police) or Air Force. We are checked by humans who compare the picture on the badge and the face of the bearer. They usually know us and are very careful with newcomers.

Once inside the center, doors are automated, the badge becomes the only key. We can see posters everywhere reminding us to check everyone's got a badge.
When a badge is lost or stolen, it is immediately deactivated.
Critical doors (access to control or technical rooms, even some non safety related corridors) will remain closed.

Daermon ATC 28th Apr 2011 07:50

This is just speculation, I have no indication whatsoever about this incident other that which has been already reported. :oh:

Assuming that the victim was indeed the intended target (that is, not simply tbeing at the wrong place at the wrong time), there are surely many other places where it would be easier to commit this murder. (Remember Peter Nielsen?)

As already said, this has happened inside a restricted area. I would speculate that the murderer does also have a valid ID for that area as well as access to the victim's schedule.

Sorry if I'm making an distasteful post, no disrespect meant, just pointing a possibility not previously mentioned.

In any case my condolences for those left behind. :sad:

aldegar 28th Apr 2011 14:41

Rest in peace.

My condolences to family, friends and colleagues.

valvanuz 28th Apr 2011 18:58

French Police is looking at an "inside" i.e. professional lead.

ATC Watcher 28th Apr 2011 19:20

Very shocking news. Condolences to the familly.

Daermon ATC :

I would speculate that the murderer does also have a valid ID for that area as well as access to the victim's schedule.
Pure speculation , but indeed this is what the police is looking after apparently.Some of his colleagues are being interrogated/suspected and that is not good for serenity at the workplace.

captplaystation 28th Apr 2011 19:25

Sorry to shatter your "serenity", but that is what I suggested quite a few hours ago in my first post. Shocking ? Yes! Distasteful? Yes! but, as I emphasised in my first post, if indeed he was murdered "airside" (for want of a better word) the Police would have to be total plonkers to fail to solve this one.

baselb 29th Apr 2011 07:29

Police are looking for a 34 year old ATC trainee. He had apparently been in an argument with the victim earlier, due to personal differences.

The man is currently on sick leave and apparently has mental problems. A dozen police officers stormed his house on Wednesday evening only to find that he wasn't there.

http://www.20min.ch/news/kreuz_und_quer/story/30061261 (German)

ATC Watcher 29th Apr 2011 09:08

BaselB : yes, thanks for the link, this is also what I heard .
Capt PS :

Sorry to shatter your "serenity",
Traffic conitnues to fly in LFSB today, and to do this safely you need serenity among other things. France as far as know still does not have CISM in place everywhere. I doubt LFSB has it , but I stand to becorrected.

Nock 29th Apr 2011 12:16

@ ATC Watcher: things have improved now and we do have CISM in France now, it has been implemented for about 2 -3 years I think.
And I completely agree with you, what is really needed is serenity.

Nock

captplaystation 3rd May 2011 15:04

Was there any more news on this, have they found the guy or has he "vanished", in which case they are maybe as likely to find a body as a suspect.

Touny 9th May 2011 19:58

The guy has still not been captured, security has been increased in all airports he might show up to (he sent about 35 letters threatening various ATCs he had been in contact with)...
It must not be an easy time for them, let's hope this does not last too long...

hangten 12th Oct 2011 11:05

And again - was this story ever resolved? I can't find anything online.

budweser 12th Oct 2011 13:56

Last I heard perpetrator was still on the loose...


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:30.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.