PDA

View Full Version : There are training aids and there are training aids


NutLoose
27th Jul 2020, 10:23
But the Iranians take that to a whole new level

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/800x400/1595845184_c66eae228bdc79d13eb05c10354b96cd52a24a68.jpeg

Iran has moved a mock-up U.S. aircraft carrier to the strategic Strait of Hormuz, satellite images show, suggesting it will use the look-alike vessel for target practice in war games in a Gulf shipping channel vital to world oil exports.

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/iran-moves-mock-up-us-carrier-to-mouth-of-gulf-satellite-images/ar-BB17etES

Their previous one including films

https://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/iran-blows-up-gigantic-u-s-carrier-mock-up-during-nava-1688057598

https://theaviationist.com/2014/04/02/iran-fake-aircraft-carrier/

Green Flash
27th Jul 2020, 10:31
I wonder if China will drop a DF-21 on it? :E

ORAC
27th Jul 2020, 12:55
https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/586655-iran-20.html#post10807338

Archimedes
27th Jul 2020, 16:16
I wonder if China will drop a DF-21 on it? :E

For entertainment value, perhaps the USN should sink it with a couple of AGM-158s before the Iranians have their SINKEX...

Ascend Charlie
28th Jul 2020, 04:48
For some reality, put a couple of Phalanx on the deck and see how many of the lads are willing to enter a 2-way shooting gallery.

treadigraph
28th Jul 2020, 05:31
For some reason I am reminded of a - no doubt apocryphal - story I once heard about the Germans building a decoy airfield somewhere in the Low Countries during WWII. They erected wooden hangars, wooden workshops, a wooden tower, wooden aeroplanes, etc. No sooner was it completed than those dastardly Britishers sent their own wooden aeroplane (a Mozzie for the uneducated) over on a raid and dropped a wooden bomb...

I'd like it to be true.

Jhieminga
28th Jul 2020, 07:57
It may have been a true story: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/lip-bomb/

Chugalug2
28th Jul 2020, 08:54
Treadigraph, the ultimate dummy ruse was featured in the BBC's Goon Show. A full sized cardboard replica of the British Isles was to be constructed and floated off of Southern England prior to German invasion. Once their troops were safely onboard it was to be towed into mid Atlantic and sunk. It was only one of many high tech solutions featured, such as the Great African trans-Continental Aeroplane Canal which allowed for the ditching of aircraft in distress. It was hard to outdo reality though, given real wartime projects for mid-Atlantic aircraft carriers constructed not of wood but of ice.

teeteringhead
28th Jul 2020, 20:52
mid-Atlantic aircraft carriers constructed not of wood but of ice. To be fair, wasn't it sawdust AND ice??

HMS Habbakuk (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Habakkuk)

etudiant
29th Jul 2020, 00:57
Treadigraph, the ultimate dummy ruse was featured in the BBC's Goon Show. A full sized cardboard replica of the British Isles was to be constructed and floated off of Southern England prior to German invasion. Once their troops were safely onboard it was to be towed into mid Atlantic and sunk. It was only one of many high tech solutions featured, such as the Great African trans-Continental Aeroplane Canal which allowed for the ditching of aircraft in distress. It was hard to outdo reality though, given real wartime projects for mid-Atlantic aircraft carriers constructed not of wood but of ice.

Think that the last was actually a brilliant idea, a lump hull of sawdust and ice, with lots of space for aircraft and gear.
It died because it took too long to get into service, but the basic idea would be still useful today, a 200,000+ ton hull that could shrug off torpedoes and bombs, self repairing and extensible at need.

Green Flash
29th Jul 2020, 08:09
Pykrete is the stuff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pykrete#:~:text=Pykrete%20is%20a%20frozen%20ice,6%20to%201%2 0by%20weight). and an update on the Iranian sinkex https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/35150/iran-fires-missiles-at-its-fake-carrier-says-its-satellite-has-been-watching-from-above

ORAC
29th Jul 2020, 09:09
Misleading headline as it appears everything missed.......

https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a33446736/iran-fake-us-carrier-great-prophet/

Iran Blows Up Fake U.S. Aircraft Carrier. Again.

John Rogers
3rd Aug 2020, 10:14
So what do you think the airfields, SAM sites, etc at Nellis and Spadeadam were/are based on? Makes perfect sense if that's who you expect to fight.

TEEEJ
3rd Aug 2020, 22:58
The saga of Iran’s fake aircraft carrier, intended as a propaganda coup, is turning into an own goal. The Iranian armed forces, particularly the IRGC-N (Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Navy) delight in attacking the mock U.S. Navy aircraft carrier. It makes their war games more dramatic. And it may be intended to symbolize that they could, if called upon, sink an American carrier. The carrier itself, actually an elaborate target barge, is not intended to sink, however. It is meant to be reusable and has been symbolically ‘destroyed’ twice already. But now it really has sunk. And in very much the wrong place.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/hisutton/2020/08/03/iran-accidentally-sinks-fake-aircraft-carrier-in-wrong-place/#1af43e75fe75

MPN11
4th Aug 2020, 12:41
Oh, I really shouldn’t laugh, but .... 😂 🤣 🤪 😎

Martin the Martian
4th Aug 2020, 13:14
So what do you think the airfields, SAM sites, etc at Nellis and Spadeadam were/are based on? Makes perfect sense if that's who you expect to fight.

Yes, but Nellis and Spadeadam are designed to offer the most realistic training possible without actually being shot at by real missiles, with appropriate anti-aircraft radars and aggressor aircraft etc. The Iranians seem to think they could land commandos onto a US carrier without any attempt by its crew to defend it.

MPN11
4th Aug 2020, 14:05
.... The Iranians seem to think they could land commandos onto a US carrier without any attempt by its crew to defend it.
Direct assault on USS [insert name here] in International Waters (maybe disputed by Iran) would lead to some interesting, and presumably RoE based, responses from the Command.

Full-on Military counter-action is surely not something the Iranians would want to provoke? Like most bullies, they would surely prefer to flex their muscles, and enhance domestic political prestige, by ganging up on the defenceless oil tankers.

Video Mixdown
4th Aug 2020, 15:36
The Iranian commanders must know that if they were foolish enough to launch such attacks on an actual US carrier, their forces would have an exciting but short life, probably along with the bases they came from and the headquarters they sit in.

TEEEJ
4th Aug 2020, 19:55
Imagery showing the target carrier on it's side.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/679x269/eeaphwjwaaaajic_34ce08204293c36a2ce471a56f9db55adedf678d.jpg
From
https://twitter.com/AuroraIntel/status/1289904738314547201

meleagertoo
4th Aug 2020, 23:32
Fnaaar!
The bloody thing sank! The ineptitude! The shame, the disgrace!
Alhamdulillah!

tdracer
5th Aug 2020, 02:03
Oh, I really shouldn’t laugh, but .... 😂 🤣 🤪 😎
Oh yes, you should definitely laugh. Everyone else (outside of Iran) is 🤣

The US may not have to worry about knocking off any more Iranian Generals/Admirals - the leadership in Tehran may start taking them out it this keeps up...