Germany. light aircraft crashes under parachute, mistaken for balloon

[N707ZS]

Sadly it sounds like no survivors from the aircraft and no mention of the balloon pilot

https://www.swanseasound.co.uk/news/world-news/germany-plane-hit-hot-air-balloon-before-crash-killing-three-say-witnesses/

[atakacs]

Obviously don't know the specifics but shouldn't be that hard to take evasive action from a hot-air balloon 🤔

[BDAttitude]

Local newspaper reports, that the chute was pulled.
Wouldn‘t be suprised if that turns out to be the hot air balloon.
Weather wasn‘t quite that great for driving balloons as well.
Apparently three dead. So one casualty from the house hit.

[Pugilistic Animus]

That's why in the US free hot air balloons have the right of way over all other aircraft... I don't think that I could handle being in a balloon.

[ShotOne]

...and everywhere else !

[atakacs]

Local newspaper reports, that the chute was pulled.
Wouldn‘t be suprised if that turns out to be the hot air balloon.

Chute pulled from the hot air balloon ?? What sequence of events do you envision ?

[treadigraph]

I think BDAttitude envisions the "hot air balloon" was actually the BRS chute, perhaps triggered too late to save those who died, or by the impact.

[BDAttitude]

I think BDAttitude envisions the "hot air balloon" was actually the BRS chute, perhaps triggered too late to save those who died, or by the impact.
:ok: Thanks!
Pedestrians and the press .... gotta love'em.

[Pugilistic Animus]

BRS... now I get it...
They cite a pilot and a Copilot.... probably not knowing that an SEL plane doesn't require a Copilot

[c52]

The local press reports that the aircraft was a "TL 98" and there was no collision with a balloon. https://rp-online.de/nrw/staedte/wesel/flugzeugabsturz-wesel-mindestens-3-tote-verletztes-kind-wohnhaus-zerstoert_aid-52395373

[atakacs]

Aha - an ultralight (http://www.tl-ultralight.cz/en) with a BRS chute - ok that makes more sense !

[gearlever]

Here the headline says it was a glider.....

Jeez

Großeinsatz: Segelflugzeug stürzt auf Wohnhaus – drei Tote (https://www.ruhrnachrichten.de/nachrichten/segelflugzeug-stuerzt-auf-wohnhaus-zwei-tote-1540681.html)

[vanHorck]

The article in the body speaks of an ultralight. Also that it apparently broke up in flight, that pieces were found away from the crash site.

[DaveReidUK]

The local press reports that the aircraft was a "TL 98" and there was no collision with a balloon.

TL 96 Star (Rotax-powered Czech ultralight).

[Pugilistic Animus]

That BRS seems to cause more problems than it fixes...plus it encourages some pilots to do stupid things. Aviation is going to pot!

[Maoraigh1]

If it broke up in flight as stated, a parachute is the only hope.

[evil7]

If it broke up in flight as stated, a parachute is the only hope.

Or it broke up because of the parachute - maybe it deployed in cruise flight unintentionally?!
Only speculation, though.

[rnzoli]

When it comes to speculations, a strong contender is always the late deployment of the BRS.

[Duchess_Driver]

That BRS seems to cause more problems than it fixes...plus it encourages some pilots to do stupid things. Aviation is going to pot!
Quote (https://www.pprune.org/newreply.php?do=newreply&p=10846437)

Interesting POV... based on?

Ask the 70 odd Cirrus “Saves” their opinion.

BRS deployments inside their design parameters is surely a step in the right direction to making aviation safer all round.

[Jonzarno]

When it comes to speculations, a strong contender is always the late deployment of the BRS.

That sounds plausible: the picture of the damage to the apartment suggests impact at a speed quite a bit higher than would be likely under a properly deployed chute, especially given the relatively small size / weight of the aircraft involved.

[Jonzarno]

Interesting POV... based on?

Ask the 70 odd Cirrus “Saves” their opinion.

BRS deployments inside their design parameters is surely a step in the right direction to making aviation safer all round.

Actually 96 with 193 survivors.

[Duchess_Driver]

Actually 96 with 193 survivors

Been a couple of years since I checked...:ok:

[jmmoric]

Is the recommendation to use the shute if equipped, or only if no apparent landing site is within reach?

[Pugilistic Animus]

It appears as if I rushed to judgement, here is a less predjudiced opinion

https://www.avweb.com/ownership/cirrus-at-25-a-safer-airplane/