PDA

View Full Version : Exit hold to commence approach


Balkanhawk
24th Aug 2019, 21:56
https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/920x2000/screenshot_20190824_224906_adobe_acrobat_882242d49d934b13942 98b50de2f04487cc30f3a.jpg
EISG Sligo NDB DME Appr 29

Hi all,
Quick question. What's the correct course reversal from this hold to commence the approach from the overhead?
my reading is exit 309 for a minute and then left turn back to overhead and then outbound 115 on the procedure.

ersa
25th Aug 2019, 01:25
Without seeing all the notes for the procedure, yes you would have to fly outbound on 309 degrees and self position . Then track 115 for the procedure .

Chesty Morgan
25th Aug 2019, 03:34
Just do an 80/260(ish) over the fix.

aterpster
25th Aug 2019, 12:39
Under PANS-OPS, when there is a base leg, you are required to enter an alignment holding pattern if your course towards the base leg is not within 30 degrees of the base leg outbound. That would be a standard holding pattern NW of SLG NDB 115 degree inbound, 3,500.

flyboyike
26th Aug 2019, 13:23
I can't make heads or tails out of that plate, I must not be very smart. Someone wanna explain to me what's going on there? What's that holding pattern even doing there?

Balkanhawk
26th Aug 2019, 21:47
I can't make heads or tails out of that plate, I must not be very smart. Someone wanna explain to me what's going on there? What's that holding pattern even doing there?

Here's the link Sligo Approaches (http://iaip.iaa.ie/iaip/IAIP_Frame_CD.htm) it's the NDB DME 29

Balkanhawk
26th Aug 2019, 21:49
Just do an 80/260(ish) over the fix.
I am a fan of the 80/260! The wind up that part of world can make a finessed reversal challenging...

aterpster
27th Aug 2019, 13:11
I can't make heads or tails out of that plate, I must not be very smart. Someone wanna explain to me what's going on there? What's that holding pattern even doing there?
It appears to me that the holding pattern is a mistake, carried over from the NDB Runway 11 procedures, where it is the ICAO compliant base-leg alignment pattern.

Here are all the Jepp charts, so whoever cares, can try to sort it out. There is no doubt in my mind that the proper ICAO compliant was erroneously omitted from the Runway 29 procedure. But, most people probably wouldn't fly the Rwy 29 base leg because of the DME entry routes.

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/566x1000/eisg_1_d8321a57eb5a29dc338382ec5a7fec10981d19b5.jpg
https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/579x1000/eisg_2_ebdfbf66e6f29ba4a46a29d900d1f9c2b9f812d2.jpg
https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/579x1000/eisg_4_31ad4b624a2de1535128600641340eb6c52c2374.jpg
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/579x1000/eisg_3_b67c29bfcca3f8031b36e1b541136d371ea863ee.jpg

ersa
28th Aug 2019, 00:04
The Jepps plate explains it all

Balkanhawk
29th Aug 2019, 02:55
The Jepps plate explains it all
Care to elaborate?

AerocatS2A
29th Aug 2019, 07:21
Yeah, I don’t see that the Jepp plate explains anything additional.

aterpster
29th Aug 2019, 13:26
Yeah, I don’t see that the Jepp plate explains anything additional.
From the snippet the OP posted I wasn't aware of the two transitions that bypass the base leg. I also infer that the SLIGO holding pattern is redundant on the Runway 29 chart.

Balkanhawk
29th Aug 2019, 19:08
From the snippet the OP posted I wasn't aware of the two transitions that bypass the base leg. I also infer that the SLIGO holding pattern is redundant on the Runway 29 chart.

Ah right, I suppose my point is however you end up in the hold (Go around, waiting on weather to clear, other traffic etc.), there has to be a standard way to commence the approach.
There's a similar hold up the road in Carrickfin (EIDL)

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune.org-vbulletin/920x2000/screenshot_20190829_200527_adobe_acrobat_7e91746fce329a0626b 4496327cef741dc19547b.jpg

ersa
30th Aug 2019, 05:29
ICAO DOC 8168: When arriving overhead the beacon first time, the heading must be within certain limits(30° of the entry-track). If not, clearance must be obtained to manoeuvre to get within the limits - manoeuvring space

aterpster
30th Aug 2019, 13:23
ICAO DOC 8168: When arriving overhead the beacon first time, the heading must be within certain limits(30° of the entry-track). If not, clearance must be obtained to manoeuvre to get within the limits - manoeuvring space
Typically, that holding pattern is charted on base-leg IAPs.

aterpster
30th Aug 2019, 15:01
Ah right, I suppose my point is however you end up in the hold (Go around, waiting on weather to clear, other traffic etc.), there has to be a standard way to commence the approach.
There's a similar hold up the road in Carrickfin (EIDL)

At EIDL the portrayed pattern serves as both the base leg alignment and missed approach holding pattern. That is good design, and typical. They should have done the same for Runway 29 at EISG.