PDA

View Full Version : Garuda’s Local Pilots Warn of Strike Over Pay


jetjockey696
13th Jul 2011, 04:33
The Garuda Indonesia Pilots Association on Tuesday refused to back down from its threat to go on strike over its demand for equal pay for local and foreign pilots.

“We love Garuda, we love Indonesians,” said Isays U. Sampesule, from the association known as the APG. “We are in a strategic industry and the strike will threaten the country’s economy, but we will do that if the company doesn’t respond to our calls.”

Its demands center on alleged discriminatory salaries at the state carrier, where foreign pilots are reportedly paid about double their local counterparts.

“A foreign first officer receives as much as $7,200 [a month], which includes accommodation benefits; a captain receives $10,200 including benefits. Compare this to the salary of a [local] first officer, which is Rp 43 million [$5,030],” Isays said.

He said that at Garuda, pilots needed to work 15 to 20 years as first officers before being promoted to the rank of captain.

“It often happens that our captains have to fly with foreign first officers on a higher salary. The captain bears all the risks and responsibilities, he is the one who makes the final call, but yet he is paid less,” Isays said. “This is not logical.”

He said Garuda employed 40 foreign pilots out of a total of 850 to 900 pilots. “The airline has to hire expatriates because the industry is booming and local aviation schools cannot supply enough skilled pilots to meet demand,” he said.

Jeffrey Ticoalu, from the APG’s industrial division, told the Jakarta Globe that the association had unsuccessfully sought a meeting with Garuda management since April.

“First, they said they were too busy to meet us. We sent another letter in May and the executive director finally agreed to see us on June 28,” Jeffrey said.

However, the pilots were disappointed as it was the operational director, rather than his superior, who attended the meeting.

“He also told us that even though he represented the executive director, the decision was not in his hands,” Jeffrey said.

Said Damanik, a lawyer for the APG, said the association had given the company two weeks to respond to its demands: a more equal policy on the rights and duties of local and expatriate pilots and for the executive director of Garuda and its commissioners to meet with pilots.

“If they fail, then we will take further steps according to the industrial law,” he said.

Garuda’s president, Emirsyah Satar, defended the pay policy, denying it was discriminatory.

“Foreign pilots are contract employees, while local pilots are permanent staff. If we calculate it as a whole [including insurance, pension and other entitlements], their salaries are more or less the same,” he said.

Garuda spokesman Pujobroto said pilot recruitment was necessary to keep up with Garuda’s growth goals.

“All airline companies are expanding at the moment, and Garuda has a plan to make a quantum leap in 2015,” Pujobroto said. “So, in line with the target, we will increase the volume of flights and recruit more pilots from flight academies.”

However, he said, new pilots would still require additional training in order to get commercial licenses and ratings needed to fly Garuda’s planes.

“The training process would take between three and six months, and in the meantime, we need additional pilots. That’s why we hire contract pilots,” he said. “Their contract period is usually only for a year.”

Metro man
13th Jul 2011, 07:28
Garuda terms and conditions, along with other Indonesian airlines are well below world standard. However you need to factor in the relatively low cost of living for a local. A narrowbody captain may be on considerably less than a European Airline would pay but would be able to live in a mansion with a couple of servants. An EasyJet skipper living on London on two or three times the pay could manage a semi detatched house and a cleaning woman once a week.

If the foreigners are simply contract pilots employed for a fixed term then Garuda have to pay the going rate to compete with Vietnam/Korea/China etc

It would be reasonable to offer any local pilot who wants it, the same terms and conditions as the contract pilots. Fixed term with no guarantee of extension, first out the door in the event of a down turn, back of the queue for upgrade behind those on normal terms. In return they get the same pay.

scandicstar
23rd Jul 2011, 03:22
So where does the MAS pilots , especially the captains of the narrowbody level playing field? So the B738 Captains doing the widebody operation with the narrowbody allowances?. Likewise the foreign copilots on 3 years contract getting more than the captains who need to be thaught virtually almost everything? The good things here is that the quality life and foods are abundant down here if you do not compare the gross income.:sad: > Fiery Air Asia is putting up a lot of pressure to MAS operations with the share market tipping on the opposite side for both carriers. Times are bad though future look promising. Every airlines have their ups and downs. Am I :sad: or :( ? Ride the storms and I shall not:{

WYOMINGPILOT
23rd Jul 2011, 05:35
“It often happens that our captains have to fly with foreign first officers on a higher salary. The captain bears all the risks and responsibilities, he is the one who makes the final call, but yet he is paid less,” Isays said. “This is not logical.”
This just demonstrates the ignorance of their argument. These pilots are a short term solution only and should be paid a higher premium. They may last 1 year or they may last 5 years but there is not the job security, protections and stability of a local pilot so Ex-Pats are always paid at a higher rate.

aseanaero
23rd Jul 2011, 06:14
You see this argument a lot in Indonesia also with engineers.

One of our clients hired an experienced foreign engineer on a 1 year contract for skills transfer and training local engineers on a new aircraft type and he was totally white anted and isolated by the locals due to his salary. He left when his contract was up , he couldn't wait to get out.

The locals couldn't do the job and somebody was brought in from Europe on a premium to teach them , very few of the local engineers got the point he was there to lift their skill level on the aircraft , they just looked at his salary , disappointing ...