PDA

View Full Version : Flt Lt C. D. Jenkins, RAF Aldegrove, Antrim


Oh I See
8th Feb 2002, 03:31
I sit here, writing this, as a serving airman (aircrew) who chooses, like the rest of you, to hide behind the anonymity of this board. I can not think of a truer cause than that of clearing the names of Flt Lt John Tapper, Flt Lt Rick Cook and The Royal Air Force. Therefore I am humbled by the loyalty and courage displayed in this letter.

<a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/Content/displayPopup.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2002/02/07/dt0705.xml&site=15" target="_blank">http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/Content/displayPopup.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2002/02/07/dt0705.xml&site=15</a>

I know this man will reap the whirlwind but he is right, I, however, am a coward.

Always_broken_in_wilts
8th Feb 2002, 03:48
WELL DONE THAT MAN!!

There are not many "royals" that I would take my hat off to but the officer Jenkins certainly gets my vote. This is an act more worthy of praise than anything ever written on the annual reports of the scoundrels responsible for this long fight.

As a crewman on the "16 seater" at the time of crash I knew the individuals, not closely, but well enough to know that the slurs against them were unjust and I was very dismayed to think the service could treat those who could not defend themselves in such a callous manner.

Lets hope that the eventual and inevitable plight of the fine upstanding Mr Jenkins is made public so the country can see what happens to those who dare to critcise our lords and masters.And if a financial penalty is imposed I for one will be putting my hand in my pocket to help out.

Keep us informed please.

<img src="wink.gif" border="0">

Always_broken_in_wilts
8th Feb 2002, 03:50
All spelling mistakes in the above were alcohol induced.

Apologies....hic <img src="rolleyes.gif" border="0">

uncle peter
8th Feb 2002, 03:58
i too doff my cap to a bloody courageous bloke. i will gladly buy that man a pint.

his written word amplifies the thoughts of the majority.

Big Green Arrow
8th Feb 2002, 11:54
Nice one my son...just hope this 'putting your head above the collective parapet' doesn't leave you as a target...nevertheless well done..just says what we're all thinking

Jeep
8th Feb 2002, 12:00
Big balls Jenks, big balls. Now I understand why you didn't have to submit to the essay competition like all us pongos.

FJJP
8th Feb 2002, 12:59
A very, very brave man. Those of you who hope he won't become a target I'm afraid are a little niaive. He'll already have had the first of a number of interviews which will end up in front of Day. I fear he has severely famaged his future prospects.

Gainesy
8th Feb 2002, 13:18
Flt Lt Jenkins is a man who understands and applies the concepts of integrity, honour and loyalty. If he ends up in front of Day, then hopefully, some of it will rub off on the latter officer.

Well said mate.

The Mistress
8th Feb 2002, 13:20
Jenkins - I really wish there were more like you - a man of honour.

You may very well become a target of some vile and malicious actions in fairly short order. I know all about that.

e-mail me if you need legal help.

WibbleOne
8th Feb 2002, 13:41
Well said that man. As an ancient aviator I too agree that professional aircrew do not fly deliberately into cloud below SA. Unfortunately, I don't believe we will get a similar, from the heart, reply from Day, you don't get to be where he is today without losing your compassion, honesty and integrity.

John Nichol
8th Feb 2002, 14:10
I admire your bravery Flt Lt Jenkins - though I fear the sh!t will have well and truly hit the fan by now.

Your letter came at a very welcome time. I was at an "off the record brief" by the faceless ones in the MOD on Tuesday who were quite happy to state, off the record and hence anonymously (YOU PATHETIC COWARDS KNOW WHO YOU ARE)that:

1. "I was at Odiham recently - and everybody agreed with us that (the 2 pilots) were grossly negligent"

I presume that some of the serving people might disagree with that?

2. "All this stuff about Special Forces crews is rubish - you don't have to been anything special to qualify. If you look at their (Tapper and Cook) 5000s you will see that they were nothing special at all".

I will not break the code and mention the name of the person who peddled this filth (yet) but you know who you are - indeed you read these pages - and you should be truly ashamed of yourself.

I'm so pleased that Flt Lt Jenkins has shown what a liar you are.

Emerson Cahooners
8th Feb 2002, 14:58
For me, Jenks epitomises everything that a senior Officer should be, loyal, courageous, a man of honour. Sadly it’s those that repeal these values that reach the top these days, what a pity.

Jenks, you are a scholar and a gentleman, I doff my cap to your audacious letter.

InFinRetirement
8th Feb 2002, 15:28
Bloody hell! Talk about laying yourself on the track to be run over.

Sir! You are a gentleman. I salute you.

Paul Wesson
8th Feb 2002, 17:36
Loyalty to the Royal Air Force and his friends, courage, honour, integrity - Jenks is doomed.

In different circumstances and for different reasons I have put my head above the parapet a couple of times. Experience shows that it can test friendships and relationships to the full. Flt Lt Jenkins will have the tacit support of a lot of people, but it will be interesting to see if any of the execs at Aldergrove will want to defend his actions to higher authority. My personal experience is that people will be washing their hands so vigorously that Co Antrim could well be out of soap before the week is out!

I don't know Jenks' current circumstances, but my experiences have left a sour taste in the mouth. The following are just a few of the things that happened to me:

a. Wg Cdr's wife 'phoned to say that her son could no longer play with our daughter, then aged 5 (you try explaining that to a tearful little girl).

b. Stn Cdr's wife tried to stop my wife running a stall at Wives' Club Xmas Fair (I kid you not).

c. Padre 'phoned to say that my family were no longer welcome at his church because he was worried about his next posting (cf Bible, 2 masters, God and Mammon).

d. 'Friends' forgot to invite us to parties, but always managed to drink our beer!

e. Shunned at school gate by wives of Sqn Ldrs and above (Claire S*****e, Moira M****y - you know who you are).

f. Personal paperwork mislaid, disappeared, delayed etc.

g. Person I bubbled for misuse of public funds promoted to CAS (I have been disclosed proof by MOD and all could well be revealed in Swindon County Court between 27th and 30th May).

The list goes on and on and on. I salute Jenks and admire his courage (and if it is the man I knew, and I think it is, I have always respected his professionalism). I just hope that his life doesn't become as difficult as mine became - if he suffers only 10% of what I've had to put up with he should count himself lucky. There are some very unforgiving people out there!

PS Owing to a recent change in the Road Traffic Act, 'Loyalty' is no longer a 2 way street. With immediate effect 'Loyalty' is a one way street with substantial traffic calming measures.

PPS There has been a technical hitch and the traffic light at the end of 'Loyalty' is stuck at red until further notice. Anybody wishing to use 'Loyalty' as a means of access to the district of 'Career Furtherance' should turn right down 'Stab in the Back Alley', make a left turn into 'Brown Nose Road' and grovel their way up to the top of 'The Heap'. Relieving the policeman on secondary duty could help smooth the journey.

uncle peter
8th Feb 2002, 17:36
prepare for rant.

Flt Lt Jenkins in my opinion is a man of honour, integrity and of undoubtable courage. He chose an appropriate forum to air not only his own views but those of a substantial number of colleagues. He chose not to hide behind the shield of anonymity in order to provide credibility to his / our opinion.

with reference to your post JN i would request that you do not allow those responsible for the cowardice of hearsay to remain unaccountable.

although i perhaps do not agree with the naming of the individual, making sufficient reference so that they could be identified would not, in my opinion, be out of order.

Flt Lt Jenkins chose to waive his anonymity, perhaps knowing the disproportionate response that may attract. It is appalling that some could hide behind an "informal briefing" and "off the record" remarks to further emphasise the MoD's now untenable position.

note to those people: you are bringing shame on the service i was once proud to serve, but now cannot wait to leave.

food for thought: blair has made known his disapproval for re-opening the inquiry into the tragedy, however the slimy oik mandelson has convinced him to re-open the enquiry into the circumstances of his resignation so that he may clear his name. I despair.

rant ends.

lightbob
8th Feb 2002, 17:44
AM Day said that the decision he made required 'moral courage' - Jenks has probably used much more in writing his letter. Perhaps it is time to issue a few AMs with mirrors so that they can contemplate their souls.

fobotcso
8th Feb 2002, 21:05
I suspect that "moral courage" is often used an excuse for blind and illogical thinking.

Corporate and institutional bullying has always been present in the Armed Forces and this case will always be remembered as the very essence of it. Ultimately it was the reason for my (slightly) early departure. It exists at all levels; I have known Group Captains bully Wing Commanders and Air Vice Marshals who bullied Squadron Leaders. There will always be a few who can't help it when they find themselves in a position to abuse their power. When it is done so publicly and from such a high level, bullying of two dead men is incomprehensible.

In the pub the other day I found some sensible people who felt that Wratten/Day might be right. It took only a few moments to remind them of the circumstances and to convince them that the Lords were right.

I did BoI on a (still) unexplained double fatal many years ago. The elapsed time from their final cheerful R/T call to radar "Clear on top at 60" to impact at over 600 kts under a 1200ft ceiling with good visibility was less than 15 seconds! Twenty seconds is an eternity in which things can go wrong with an aircraft.

But let's remember, that's not the issue. Whatever Tapper and Cook may have done or not done there is no evidence that they were negligent and it is an abuse of power to fly in the face of logical deduction from the facts and say they were.

Jenks is clearly an outstanding team player; I suspect that he will find support from directions that will suprise us all. And I hope that's not just my natural optimism coming through.

Sven Sixtoo
8th Feb 2002, 22:43
That may be the bravest document I have ever read. The only decision that comes close in my experience is the day OC 22 Sqn refused to go operational with the Sea King 3A in the face of a ministerial statement that it would happen.

Loyalty 6. .Integrity 6. .Strength of Character 6. .Power of written expression 6. .Sven

Hydraulic Palm Tree
8th Feb 2002, 22:44
I know Jenks, not well, but as a decent down to Earth chap who works on one of the Sqns over here at Aldergrove. I too am not afraid of keeping my anonimity and many of you out there will know who I am and what I have done and what I now do.

What Jenks has said is brave indeed and JHC had called in for his scalp as soon as they saw the letter.

We all know that what he has said is true and respect him for taking that bold step. Until he penned that letter he has remained silent despite the unquestionable anger that has been lurking inside him. His decision to go public' is no more unloyal than the conclusion that has been reached by our Lords. If he is punished in an unnaceptable manner I, along with many fellow aviators WILLmake a stand with him, in support of his actions. CAS cannot and I suspect will not be able to uphold the punishment of one of his officers who supports a decision made by the highest law making body in the Country. AM Day, do not hide behind your rank, as a man, you are a coward; the lowest of the low. If Jenks' humiliation continues I hope I get the chance to tell you this in the near future. Rest assured, I will!

HPT

[ 08 February 2002: Message edited by: Hydraulic Palm Tree ]

[ 08 February 2002: Message edited by: Hydraulic Palm Tree ]</p>

Gen. Bombdabastards
8th Feb 2002, 22:47
Well done Jenk's, a gentleman and a scholar. You have bigger B***s than a lot of those senior to yourself.. . At least if they do take any action against you, you have a date documented that it occured after and you may be able to take them on for victimisation.. .what have you got to lose?

Best Wishes. .GB

The Pilgrim
8th Feb 2002, 23:55
Well done Jenk's, good people are telling you the reasons for your letter, its not courage, its nots balls its right and its time that people knew it was right. Buy ya a beer Friday.

Barn Doors
9th Feb 2002, 00:07
Flt Lt Jenkins, I have rarely seen, let alone read such an honest and touching letter as yours. The loyalty contained is an example to us all, serving or not, Air Officer or not. If I'm ever fortunate enough to meet you in person, your's is a pint!

GOOD SHOW,

Regards, BD! <img src="wink.gif" border="0">

Charlie Luncher
9th Feb 2002, 00:29
To Jenks

Sir,. .I have the honour to be your obedient servant.

Refreshing to see an Officer with the qualities I respect and admire. There are too few these days or am I just old fashioned?

My words are not said lightly.

Tread carefully Warrior.

maniac55
9th Feb 2002, 00:45
Again, I do not know Jenks but as someone I know likes to say "To those of you who have done well, well done, you know who you are!"

jayteeto
9th Feb 2002, 01:07
Big Balls Colin, order that man a new namebadge. Jenks I hope you survive this one, I'll fly with you anyday! Mind you, you'll need a Wokka to lift those gonads............................ . .I walked out from the line office with John Tapper that day, never ever met such a meticulous PROFESSIONAL pilot, in my opinion he could not do the things they claim, well done to all those who fought on.

Stan Bydike
9th Feb 2002, 01:09
For what it is worth you have my utmost respect

Tiger_mate
9th Feb 2002, 01:16
Flt Lt C. D. Jenkins, RAF Aldegrove, Antrim

Besides the obvious spullin mistake, didnt Jenks get a medal of some distinction once??

Or was that one of those, he who signed the 700 gets the metal moments!

With balls as big as this I`ll bet he will struggle to walk into the AOCs office. I think "Jenks" can go up in neon lights on the crewman role of honour, after all, he used to be one <img src="smile.gif" border="0"> <img src="smile.gif" border="0">

Hands up who thinks he said anything wrong? No I didnt think so, and the Euro Court will agree as well, freedom of speech, power to the people. Why are we led by knobs these days. Last one out....

Kiting for Boys
9th Feb 2002, 01:43
In Ardua Veritas

misterploppy
9th Feb 2002, 02:07
Cahones grandes Mr Jenkins.

Respect.

I only hope that the excuse for an air officer remaining in the Service will not be around long enough to adversely affect your career.

whiskydrinker
9th Feb 2002, 06:23
To Jenks

I once fought and lost against the system. My chest swells with pride to know there are officers like yourself still serving.

fobotcso has it right - it is downright bullying. Most senior officers need to get what's coming to them.

My heartfelt support.. .ws

Robert Cooper
9th Feb 2002, 09:36
Although retired just on 20 years ago, it is heartwarming to see that the RAF can still attract officers of Flt Lt Jenkins' calibre.

He is going to get sh*t upon greatly, but I think he will find he has friends in places he never dreamed of.

Bob C

Huh, What did he say?

amyoungz
9th Feb 2002, 10:39
Jenks

Never met you, but would be proud to buy you a beer someday.

I'm keeping well clear of the technical arguments in the case, because I'm simply not clued-up enough to comment. However, it seems to me that 'absolutely no doubt whatsoever' is quite sufficiently unequivocal and that the original Board and the House of Lords are occupying the high ground here.

Here's a Spin Doctor's recipe for getting out of this mess, Tony. Stick forward, full opposite rudder.

Qwin T Senshall
9th Feb 2002, 19:56
Flt Lt Jenkins

I'll go to war on your wing.

Qwin

ChristopherRobin
9th Feb 2002, 20:17
I agree - well done. Today's telegraph letters page adds to the chorus:

<a href="http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/Content/displayPopup.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2002/02/09/dt0904.xml&sit" target="_blank">http://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/Content/displayPopup.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2002/02/09/dt0904.xml&sit</a> e=15

[quote]An officer and a gentlemen. .(Filed: 09/02/2002)

SIR - Flt Lt Jenkins's moving example of moral courage and loyalty to his friends who piloted the crashed Chinook (letter, Feb. 7) is an example to us all. It is reassuring to know that the spirit of Douglas Bader still lives in this age of overpaid nonentities and mendacious politicians.

One can only hope that the desk pilots at the Air Ministry are magnanimous rather than vengeful with regard to this young man, and that Flt Lt Jenkins is allowed to continue with a job to which he is obviously committed. We should be grateful that such people exist.

<hr></blockquote>

cyclic
9th Feb 2002, 23:46
Pleased to see there is still some honour in the Service. Many of our "betters" please take note.

ShyTorque
10th Feb 2002, 00:08
Jenks,

You have said what many have thought but feared to say in public. Good on you mate, best of luck.

Not seen you since I retired in '94 but if you are at Odious on the 26th you won't be short of a beer or two.

Big Green Arrow
10th Feb 2002, 00:33
Take a lawyer with you into all future interviews mate....I believe you are entitled to one, at The Queen's expense too. You get my vote any day.

cryogenic
10th Feb 2002, 01:00
I don't believe the officer Jenkins has stuck his head above the parapet at all...he's climbed right out of the trench and made himself a target for any venal half-wit from planet MOD who cares to take a pot. Writing that letter was an extremely courageous thing to do. I pulled the plug in 99 and I know b..... all about wokkas as a kipper fleet man, however, I know enough about BOIs and the disgracefully contrived and illegal result of this one to know that, for sure, I would go out of my way to stick up for Jenks. "Right is right and wrong is no man's right"

1.3VStall
11th Feb 2002, 23:40
I can't believe contributions to this thread have suddenly dried up. Has the RAF put out some sort of threat to would be contributors?

Jenks, you are a star! Would someone still serving please take it upon themselves to keep us all updated on what is happening to Jenks. He could well need external support as the vindictive might of the establishment is focused on him. Jenks, mate, you can count on my 100% support for what it's worth.

Jackonicko
11th Feb 2002, 23:50
Awesome letter. Difficult to know what possible help a journo could be, but if Jenks reads this, he should know that he now has many admirers in the press, and many of us would go out of our way to help him out.

Dai Chopper
12th Feb 2002, 00:07
Colin

Well said. Much of what you have so bravely said has been reiterated at many a crew-room and Happy Hour chat. I know that most above the rank of Wg Cdr will dismiss your comments but your basic argument should be a fundamental of leadership and morality within the RAF - NOT GUILTY until proved otherwise. I hope John Day reflects on the whole episode and is ashamed of his own bombastic and arrogant attitude, having read your letter.

You're still ugly though!

Dave Jones (thankfully retired)

Green Bottle
12th Feb 2002, 01:29
Respect Jenks. You are a mouthpiece for those of us without your moral courage. Thank you.

Fortyodd
13th Feb 2002, 00:59
As I left the Military a couple of years ago I no longer have to salute anyone. Jenks, you are the exception. Having once been where you are now, I have some idea of what you are going through. As has already been said, you will find you have friends in places you never knew existed.

STAN DEASY
13th Feb 2002, 01:25
Awesome letter, exquisitly written.

. .Respect from the Dark blue.

Night NVG Goggles
14th Feb 2002, 18:11
Jenks, you said many wise words to me at Nav school, I have never forgotton them. Your recent words were truly courageous. It is an honour to know you. You are a true Officer and a Gentleman. The next time I am home, the beers are on me.

bakseetblatherer
14th Feb 2002, 19:37
Jenks,. .Not much I can add to what has gone before but you're an example to us all.

Hengist Pod
15th Feb 2002, 00:32
Well I'm C-in-C Strike and I think you're a right w@nker!

Hydraulic Palm Tree
15th Feb 2002, 02:14
Hengist

You are well off the mark this time. Apologise and never bother to darken PPRUNE again you repulsive creature.

From your previous posts it is not difficult to know that you are based at Odiham, are rear crew on the Chinook on 18 or 27 Sqn, probably ex 230 Sqn Pumas and can be easily identified by the huge chips on both shoulders.

I think I'll ask Rude Crewman who you are when I speak to him next. I'm sure a few of the boys would like to shake your hand.

HPT

[ 14 February 2002: Message edited by: Hydraulic Palm Tree ]</p>

Ed Winchester
15th Feb 2002, 02:30
HPT,

I think Hengist was attempting a bit of satire, not expressing his personal opinion of Jenks. Hope life is treating you well.

P.S. Jenks, please accept a hearty slap on the back.

[ 14 February 2002: Message edited by: Ed Winchester ]</p>

PlasticCabDriver
15th Feb 2002, 02:45
Couldn't let the thread pass without adding my two penn'orth of support.

I think you'll find it hard to buy your own beer for quite a while.

BEagle
15th Feb 2002, 21:50
Well, Victor killer of Hamilton infamy, are you effing surprised that anyone at a military base in November India wouldn't tell a civilian inquirer where Jenks could be found.........

BEagle
15th Feb 2002, 22:42
.......and you have the effontery to quote Flight Safety?? Guess who's well publicised totally avoidable accident still features at the FLAC and FSup Course!!

Go away!!!

goldcup
15th Feb 2002, 22:57
No, no BEags. Get off the fence and tell us what you REALLY think!

covec
16th Feb 2002, 00:13
I am adding this to push this page back to the top of the thread.

Sorry, I had not read this topic prior to posting my reply to Ambler re SNCO Aircrew - shafted...

Pub User
16th Feb 2002, 01:29
Gentlemen, let's be realistic. Those of us who know Jenks also know that he regularly writes letters to the Telegraph in the hope of one being published. Obviously he chooses politically topical subjects, as they have the best chance of publication. Now, he's finally succeeded, and it's caused a lot of commotion, despite some innaccuracies. He's Spec Aircrew, what are they going to do to him? Send him to NI?

[ 15 February 2002: Message edited by: Pub User ]</p>

Dunhovrin
16th Feb 2002, 14:09
To Tiger-mate,

No tales out of school but Jenks once saved 15 lives, including mine. I got the gong and all he got was a bollocking for a different incident which was in no way his fault. I think our Jenks's shoulders are broad enough to carry any ***** the heiarachy try and dump on him. What are they going to do - send him to Ireland?

If you read this Col say Hi to the missus for me...

Art Field
16th Feb 2002, 16:10
M.J.

Still reckon you are the only one marching in step I see.

[ 16 February 2002: Message edited by: Art Field ]</p>

XM147
16th Feb 2002, 16:35
Jenks. I only wish that my command of the English language was as great as yours. You used all the right words and put them all in the right order! I take my hat off to you!!

Oh I See
16th Feb 2002, 21:36
Pub User

What were the inaccuracies?

Pub User
16th Feb 2002, 22:09
The bit about how the crew was so vastly experienced that no unit today would be able to field a similar one.

Oh I See
17th Feb 2002, 00:08
Pub User

Not knowing the exact experience of the crew (of four), particularly as this would only be known to a select few due to the nature of SF Ops and Ex, I can only await proof of YOUR statement.

Picky I know but you did say inaccuracies. I await the rest.. . <img src="confused.gif" border="0">

Pub User
17th Feb 2002, 01:35
OK then inaccuracy, it was post happy-hour when I wrote it!

Oswald
17th Feb 2002, 19:31
Beagle . . I think your comments are unwarranted and juvenile.

Jenks. . Haven't seen you since BFTS....good letter though, well done.

OOPS 78
19th Feb 2002, 22:26
What has actually happened to C Jenkins?

FJJP
22nd Feb 2002, 12:09
It all seems to have gone quiet - anybody in the know care to update us as to what has befallen this gutsy officer Jenks?

<img src="confused.gif" border="0"> <img src="confused.gif" border="0">

ShyTorque
22nd Feb 2002, 12:44
Perhaps he has been forced to work in the same office as Admin Guru.

Or has he become John Day's teaboy? (no, not toyboy!) <img src="eek.gif" border="0">

Big Green Arrow
23rd Feb 2002, 01:12
Just putting this back to the top

Oh I See
23rd Feb 2002, 01:40
Pub User

From your last posts I can only assume that you work with Flt Lt Jenkins. If this is the case could you at least let the rest of us know what is happening? If he is a man merely seeking to see his name in the Telegraph then what can be the harm of letting the rest of us know what has, or hasn’t happened?

jiffni
23rd Feb 2002, 08:11
down route at the mo, but it would appear that:

our man has had an interview with flt comd, sqn comd and mr nivea himself. it would appear that he has been told that writing accusations about a serving bigwig is out of order; against queens regs etc.

although his topic this time is a popular slanderous theme, the general proposition that you may as a serving officer write to the national press, is wrong.

what do the lawyers say?

we all have plenty to ......

friend or no friend, you cannot publicly slag off a serving senior officer. quite right too.

Mr Jiffni RN

Oh I See
23rd Feb 2002, 12:32
jiffni

Thank you for the news of Flt Lt Jenkins. I agree with you re slandering/embarrassing in the light of the law and would also appreciate any informed view as to whether this has occurred in this case.

Pub User
23rd Feb 2002, 15:15
Oh I See

sorry for the lack of reply, but I parted company from Jenks recently thanks to an Innsworth escape chit.

Intersting news from jiffni, I hope nothing serious comes Jenk's way. Calling a senior officer's comments 'fatuous', when the House of Lords has already judged them to be innaccurate can hardly be described as publicly slagging him off. Or can it? Any legal gurus here?

uncle peter
23rd Feb 2002, 15:57
A defamatory comment is one which reflects on a person’s reputation so as to lower the plaintiff in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally. The ordinary and natural meaning of the words may include any implication or inference which a reasonable reader guided by general knowledge would draw from the words.

Publication consists of communicating defamatory material to a third party. If this is in written form then the tort is Libel, if spoken it is slander The tort of libel is actionable per se (unlike slander where special damage must be proved).

That is the legal requirement to establish the offence. However, the defences to the above include Truth (known as justification). As the house of lords select committee report criticised day, merely repeating these criticisms would not amount to libel.

That is the position in the law of tort. However, the sticking point could be QR 999, where (paraphrasing) it is quite simply not on to criticise a senior officer where those criticisms would lead to others being dissatisfied with the actions of that officer or with their terms of service generally. As the HoL has already criticised day i dont personally think they could proceed with disciplinary action under that QR, as they could not prove that the letter from jenks caused any dissatisfaction that had not already been caused (and criticised) by that officer himself.

2 words to say about this. $h1te.

ShyTorque
23rd Feb 2002, 16:16
I suppose it had to be done, discipline and good order and all that but their airships are attempting to hide behind QRs now, are they?

Sadder and sadder, more pathetic every day this farce is allowed to continue..

I know of one very senior officer who is likely to end up with a severely finger poked chest should he attend the SH reunion. Civvies are allowed to do that, of course.

<img src="wink.gif" border="0">

Oh I See
23rd Feb 2002, 17:00
Pub User

No problem. Good job you got a chit because tunnelling was never an option from that place!!

. .uncle peter

Thank you for an enlightening post. If nothing else it serves to show how careful we must be when speaking of our seniors. Such respectful silence has always been the way of my time in the RAF. However that respect has also been reflected by the actions of these seniors when their juniors ‘fell off the cart’. It now seems that the Mirror Reflective Mk1 has been replaced by the very modern Mirror One Way Mk1.

slj
23rd Feb 2002, 18:17
Uncle peter

Perhaps they should consider Day for court martial.

Any volunteers for the court?

Big Green Arrow
24th Feb 2002, 00:43
Surely as the HoL has already decided that their Airships were guilty of a 'gaff', then merely reiterating the comments of the highest decision making body in UK (discounting Brussels of course!) cannot be construed as breaking the aforementioned QR, can it?

Stands by for FLARRAC

XM147
28th Feb 2002, 00:23
Back to the top...

MrBernoulli
28th Feb 2002, 12:02
Ah, sod it! If the senior officers have publicly dug a bloody great hole for themselves then QRs cannot be hidden behind. Everything is already out in the public domain and no way can Jenks's remarks be considered as lowering anyones opinion of the senior officers. Those 2 did it all on their own!

No right-thinking military man could possibly hope to charge Jenks under QRs and hope to succeed. Come to think of it, no idiot could hope to proceed with such an action either.

Terry Rumble
28th Feb 2002, 13:21
Dear Flt Lt Jenkins,. .I have the honour to be.................

Having only just RTBd from the land of camels and shower bags last week, I have just read the said letter.. .May I say how very proud I feel to find that after 30 years in a rapidly declining service, we still have some officers left (junior officers at that I might add) that have shown true courage and bravery?. .You epitomise all that should be expected from an Officer Sir, and I and my fellow AA salute you!. .I fear however, that you will be rewarded by those in power, not with a medal or even a congratulations, but by something closely approaching that feeling of cold steel in the back.. .Have no doubt tho' Sir, you have placed yourself most definately high up with the eagles. Far higher than those in power can even dream of, and your actions will most certainly not be forgoten. . .From a (very) old Master, I salute you.

FJJP
7th Mar 2002, 18:57
Back to the top. Anybody know what has happened to Jenks? How much of it has come off the fan? Or are their Airships so sh*t scared of more bad publicity that they daren't clobber him?

Yozzer
7th Mar 2002, 19:53
As this is back at the top anyway, I will say this. Jenks would rather it quietly slipped away, he doesnt do computers nor the internet so has not seen these contents, although as you would imagine, he has been told.. .. .He made his comments that he sincerely felt and has had the one sided chat with the self opinionated members of our society. He remains in post, and is mildly embarassed at the attention that he has been getting, for despite the earler comment regarding a desire to see his own name in print, that was far from the reasoning behind his actions.. .. .I know that he will support this request: Please let it go, for it is history.

The Mistress
7th Mar 2002, 20:14
Pity you don't follow your own advice Yozzer. Git.