PDA

View Full Version : A dumb question on differential brakes


sumeryamaner
1st Oct 2009, 20:27
Dear all...
I am really sorry to ask such a question but I think only you can help.
I wonder whether the big birds like 737, 777 or A3XX have differential brakes or not? Do the pedals control all brakes simultaneously or only the respective side like general aviation aircraft?
Thank you very much.

Sumer Yamaner

oceancrosser
1st Oct 2009, 20:43
The brake pedals only apply brakes on their respective side. And yes to some extent you can use differential braking on the big birds, such as when you making a 180° turn on narrow runways. Probably puts a bit of strain on the landing gear though.

sumeryamaner
1st Oct 2009, 21:01
Great... Thank you very much.

18-Wheeler
2nd Oct 2009, 14:19
Useless anecdote that's probably not reliable - If you're right-handed then you tend to push a little harder on the left brake pedal and vice-versa.
Had a couple of good Flight Engineers tell me (correctly) that I was right-handed after landing by looking at the brake temps. :)

banana head
2nd Oct 2009, 15:53
If you're right-handed then you tend to push a little harder on the left brake pedal and vice-versa.

Maybe in your case - but from what I've witnessed over a long long period the vast majority of pilots tend to press harder on the left pedal, regardless of if they are right or left handed.
The reason? simple really.
Which foot operates the accelerator and brake in your car?
Which foot operates the clutch?
Which of the two requires a sensitive touch and many different pressures to achieve a smooth drive - and which is operated almost like an on/off switch?
Thus most pilots (or at least those who drive manual cars!) tend to unintentionally brake harder on the left side.
Don't believe me?
Try this.
Get in your car.
Find a nice straight road with no traffic about.
Accelerate to approx 60 kph (in whatever gear is required/ comfortable).
Lift your right foot off the accelerator.
Place your LEFT foot over the brake pedal and brake normally.
Make sure you wear your seatbelt :E

Oh and don't believe everything the Flight Engineer tells you unless it's details of the cheapest place for breakfast downroute, the loudest bar or the raciest strip club :ok:

18-Wheeler
3rd Oct 2009, 00:51
Try this.
Get in your car.
Find a nice straight road with no traffic about.
Accelerate to approx 60 kph (in whatever gear is required/ comfortable).
Lift your right foot off the accelerator.
Place your LEFT foot over the brake pedal and brake normally.
Make sure you wear your seatbelt

That doesn't work with me - I'm a race & rally driver and so left-foot brake a lot, and when I drive a car with an automatic gearbox I always LFB anyway. ;)

But yes as I wrote above, it's not an entirely reliable anecdote.

Runaround Valve
3rd Oct 2009, 05:27
From what I can remember of my B747-200 course of many years ago....
The brake cables between the rudder pedals and the brake control valves are rigged at a different tensions.
One side is rigged at 120- 140 pounds cable tension and the other at 130-150 pounds cable tension. Forget which side is the highest, and using these tensions as a guide only. I am talking about this being the Captains side only, the First Officer would have his side rigged about the same.
This is to overcome the difference in pressure that people put on the brake pedals, being used to different forces when operating car brake and clutch pedals.

FCS Explorer
3rd Oct 2009, 08:49
since i leave the breaking to auto-brake and anti-skid i don't see why one side should be warmer than the other in relation to if i am L or R handed or my type of car.....:}

18-Wheeler
3rd Oct 2009, 09:34
since i leave the breaking to auto-brake

Good to see you leave the dirty work to the machinery. :)

Almendrudo
9th Oct 2009, 01:20
18-Wheeler,
I remember an engineer telling a crewof a corporate plane that they were landing only from the left seat because the engineer saw that the right hand side MLG was more worn out that the LH side.

I know, nothing to do with the original thread but I just wanted to share my experience.

Busserday
9th Oct 2009, 02:45
On the 330, with auto-brakes used routinely, I usually found the downwind (leeward?) brakes were almost always warmer than the windward brakes. But then again maybe I usually took the leg with the crosswind from the right (in reference to being right handed).http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/src:www.pprune.org/get/images/smilies/yeees.gif

I attributed this temperature differential to weather-cocking induced yaw being countered by the differential braking and the shielding of the wind to assist cooling on the leeward side, but it was just my own theory.http://images.ibsrv.net/ibsrv/res/src:www.pprune.org/get/images/smilies/nerd.gif
BD

411A
9th Oct 2009, 03:16
Delta worked around the hot brake 'problems':rolleyes: on the L1011....they removed the brake temperature gauges.:}

A wise decision.:ok:

stilton
10th Oct 2009, 05:54
Leave the 'breaking' to autobrake and anti skid !


I do miss Pilots..

Sir Richard
10th Oct 2009, 09:34
Busserday

Same on the 744, downwind side will tend to have less lift earlier in the landing run so those brakes will absorb more energy, especially when the landing pilot allows the windward wing to lift after touchdown. :8...must keep "flying" after touchdown in a strong crosswind.