RN Aircraft carrier Bulwark lost aircraft at sea near Nowra, Australia 1963-5.

[A37575]

Around the years of 1963-5 I was flying an RAAF Dakota at Canberra, when weather forced us to divert to the RAN Air Station at Nowra, NSW. In the evening a bunch of Royal Navy pilots landed at Nowra from the RN aircraft carrier "Bulwark" which had been conducting exercises off the coast near Jervis Bay.

From the conversation I overheard in the wardroom at Nowra I gathered that several aircraft from the carrier had crashed into the sea in bad weather and the remaining pilots had diverted to Nowra. I believe the carrier sailed on to Sydney. I don't recall the aircraft types but they may have been Sea Hawks. The drama was kept from the media and not one word got out to the public about the disaster (if indeed there was one of course).

Does anyone have information on the events of that day?

[Kieron Kirk]

HMS Bulwark was commissioned as a "Commando Carrier" on 23rd January 1960 at Portsmouth. So helicopters only.

Dates 1963-65 is a bit difficult.

Exercise Fotex65 involved Bulwark, HMAS Melbourne, HMS Victorious and HMS Eagle. So 1965, but where?

As to Seahawks, they were out of service by December 1960.

Shall continue to do some more "googling".

Ciarain.

[Kieron Kirk]

Exercise Fotex65 took place in the Straits of Malacca in March 1965.

820 Squadron on HMS Eagle lost 2 Wessex and HMAS Melbourne also lost a Wessex.

Ciarain.

[A37575]

Thanks so far. I checked my log book and there is no doubt that the date of the incidents/ accidents was 25th October 1965. If my memory is astray and it wasn't HMS Bulwark then was there another British aircraft carrier in the area of RANAS Nowra that night?

[Brian Abraham]

A37575, an interesting story. Joined the FAA mid '66 and not a story that I heard of in my 7 years in the Nowra wardroom. Will email a chap who was front line at Nowra on Gannets at the time and report back.

[A37575]

Meantime I will try and locate the second pilot on that Dakota trip to Nowra, Flying Officer Gary Beck (completed his RAAF career as an AVM) and see if he recalls the glum faces of the pilots in flying overalls that were in the ward room that evening.

[Brian Abraham]

A37575, sorry but I don't bring much joy. Here is a reply from a fellow aviator who held a senior position at Nowra at the time.

I certainly do not have any knowledge of any mishaps from any RN Carrier in October 1965. I was at ALBATROSS at that time and feel somehow I would have been involved had such accidents occurred. It is stupid to suggest that in peacetime fatal accidents were covered up. There were plenty of people at ALBATROSS who would have been on the phone to the Daily Telegraph in the hope of making a quick buck. Sorry but I think another myth has been shot down.

Does anyone know if there is a data base of FAA (UK) aircraft losses available? The FAA (UK) museum may be of help to you.

[A37575]

Sorry but I think another myth has been shot down.


Fine, I accept now that nothing untoward happened. A Seniors Moment no doubt:ok:

[J Miller]

Not so fast! The Royal Navy paid a visit to NAS Nowra around that time and had a Gannet taxi into a hanger door @ the completion of night flying. H hanger, western end. That would put a frown on the aircrews face, and about the same time a Sea Vixen (may have been a Buc) landed and blew a tyre and put a few extra holes in the aircraft.
I was a young NAMAE on 724 squadron @ the time...a long time ago now!

[Rainboe]

Pa Rainboe was on Victorious in the 50s and 60s. He used to regale me with stories of the fatal accidents that were always occurring, and the astonishing attrition rate of the pilots on the squadrons.

[Lee Howard]

Chaps

You ask if there is a record of all Fleet Air Arm losses. The answer is yes - contained within "Fleet Air Arm Fixed-Wing Aircraft since 1946" by Ray Sturtivant, Mick Burrow and yours truly and published by Air-Britain (Historians) Ltd. Both Mick and I are currently finalising the rotary-wing companion volume to this (nine years in the making!) with a hoped-for publication towards the end of this year. This will have detailed individual histories for all helicopters owned/operated by the Royal Navy since 1943.

I've checked our Wessex histories and there is nothing showing for any incident on 25 October 1965. With regard to the 820 Sqn loss in the Straits of Malacca, only one is recorded - XS122 ('295/E') which suffered an engine failure, ditched but remained afloat (a rarity!) allowing it to be recovered aboard Eagle and returned to the UK for repair. Sadly it was written off in a later crash in 1972.

I'm still on the lookout for the loan of photographs that anyone might have in order to illustrate the book, so if anyone can help, please drop me a PM. :ok:

HTH

Lee

[VicW]

Hi Lee,

Just read your note regarding your request for Photo's of Helicopter Crashes.

I was the crewman of Wessex 5 XT774 which crashed on board HMS Bulwark 17/0/1969. We were off Cyprus at the time rembarking our Commando Unit. Unfortunatley one of the Flight Deck stores party was killed and another seriously injured. The Pilot and I were only slightly injured although the aircraft was a right off

I have a couple of photo's if you are interested.

Best regards
Email: [email protected] ([email protected])
Mobile: +61 (0) 423 588 593

[Capot]

If confirmation were needed, I can confirm that at that time HMS Bulwark was a Commando Carrier.

I was an embarked troop (Cdo Artillery) in the boat when she carried out a work-up cruise in the Channel for several weeks. I don't know the precise date, but it was well before '62/'63.

So no fixed wing were flying from her in '62/'63.

[Lee Howard]

Vic

Thanks for the reply. E-mail duly sent.

For those interested, the date was 17 May 1969 and Able Seaman Hughes was the unfortunate victim (with Able Seaman Willis also being injured on deck).

Lee

[Captain Airclues]

When was 'Operation Swordhilt' which was held off the coast of Australia (1965?, 1966?). HMS Victorious with 801's Buccaneers and 893's Sea Vixens, took part in Operation Swordhilt, before visiting Sydney.

Dave

Edit; I think that 'Swordhilt' might have been October 1966, so a year out.

[Lower Hangar]

We execrcised down the Oz coast before we went into Garden island dockyard in October 1968 -I know 'cos I had my 25th birthday alongside. So that was HMS Hermes 801 (Bucc), 893 (Vixen) 849B (Gannet) and 824 (Ithink ) - during our ops off Jervis Bay an 849 Gannet taxied into a hangar at Nowra. - I think it got lightered back on before we left the area for Garden Island.

That was HMS Hermes deployment May 1968 to April 1969 .

[JAKCO]

While coming over for lunch on the Bulwark the aussie copter's blades hit the deck and ditched into the sea. Apparently it was overloaded, no causualties. Somewhere off Manila during exercises in 1960. Have a photo of copter in the sea just after the crash.

[JAKCO]

My mistake , my post should read: Indian Ocean, HMS Hermes, Exercise Jet 61 4th March 1961. Just checked on the back of the photograph. Age is getting a problem.

[Union Jack]

HMS Victorious with 801's Buccaneers and 893's Sea Vixens, took part in Operation Swordhilt, before visiting Sydney ....

.... in October 1966. A bit late I know, but just spotted Captain A's post thanks to JAKCO.

Jack

[sycamore]

I did an SAR search off Changi on 10 July `66 for `Sea Vixen crew`,that had ejected/crashed the previous evening. I think `bodies` were later found..

[1956]

Were you the co pilot with David Dixon on the Wessex??? Back in Cyprus all those years ago??? if so and I have got the right date, time and place then I have a photo of the crash on deck..my daughters are trying to find out more about David's time spent in the Navy, by the time we married he had left the navy some years previous!!:)

[CharlieOneSix]

Sycamore - the pilot of that Vixen was a friend, Nick Parrett, who joined the RN the same day as me. Super guy, as was his Observer, Tim Woodford.

It was thought Nick became disoriented on the final turn of a night GCA into Changi whilst dealing with a hydraulic failure. He had taken off from Eagle. Both crew were still aboard the aircraft when the wreckage was eventually found submerged.

[4Greens]

The previous Hermes was sunk by the Japanese in the last war near Colombo. The Hermes you referred to laid a wreath in remembrance over the spot where the sinking occurred.

[Jackw106]

Quote {crewman of Wessex 5 XT774 which crashed on board HMS Bulwark 17/0/1969}

I was on the same deployment. I came back on board in F they declared an emergency on our approach we had the same problem as the a/c that crashed

[david parry]

Always remember our Wessex exploding in mid air whilst doing RRRF all day operating between Hms Victorious and the RFA. In 1966 all 4 were lost ,i was on deck at the time!!! RIP

[FAR CU]

Rainboe - if you are there . . . or someone gives you a heads up. . . .. come back . . .. come back . . .. . (it was only a rash)

[Old-Duffer]

On 25 October 1965, two RN Hunters were lost near Buchan but there were no other RN aircraft recorded as being lost that date.

Is it possible that the RN crews you met had been notified of this accident to a pair of 764 Sqn aircraft in the UK that morning (UK time)?

Allowing for the time difference, it is possible that by evening in Australia, news of an accident in the UK morning could have filtered through over the comms net. There were no fatal casualties recorded for this collision BTW.

Old Duffer

[hval]

H.M.S. Bulwark was originally a fixed wing aircraft carrier (1954 - 1958). Bulwark was paid of in 1958 for conversion to a helicopter carrier.

H.M.S. Bulwark Movements during March 1965 included: - Bulwark was using helicopters to resupply Australian troops in Sarawak.

March 1965, took part in exercise FOTEX 65, along with HMAS Melbourne, HMS Victorious and HMS Eagle and combined to give a total of 40 vessels from four navies. The exercise lasted three weeks.

the only aircraft lost by Bulwark (that I know of) during 1965 was a Hiller HT2 (XS164) on 09/04/1965. Lost over Borneo:

Also Wessex 1, No. XP108 on 04/04/1965 in Borneo:

Also Two Wessex 1's collided over Borneo on 12/04/1965:


NOTE
Did you know that Bulwark was used for Kestrel trials in 1966?

http://www.bulwarkassoc.co.uk/eastleigh/gallery/bulwark/bulwark01.jpg