View Full Version : AI Rating

21st Sep 2008, 02:33
Accident posts generate pages of speculation on pPrune, some 'informed' others 'speculative'. How about acknowledging the first post to propose a cause most closely aligned to the interim / final official investigation report with an AI rating of 1? These could be published as a League Table.
It would not assume the official conclusion accurate, only the most likely, based on available evidence. Neither would it diminsh reasoned debate.

21st Sep 2008, 02:38
That's not likely to be productive. The amateur and even professional whodunnit respondents with causation theories are viewed as a mixed blessing, at best.

Scoring the "winners" would be a bit like setting up a "Free Cheese" shop for mice.

Those who know what's up can make their own judgments. In the end, the only opinion that matters anyway is the official one in the Report.