PDA

View Full Version : TCAS earns its way - again


Two's in
19th Jan 2007, 20:49
From the news today regarding an incident earlier this week over Iowa, where apparently vertical separation was lost between 2 aircraft and the pilots took the appropriate TCAS action. Probably the most noteworthy point of the article is how the FAA and NATCA have already taken up opposing views on who was to blame. There's nothing like getting your retaliation in first.



http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/10791874/detail.html

CHICAGO -- Federal authorities are investigating the near-collision of two passenger jets over Iowa this week that involved air traffic controllers serving O'Hare International Airport, the Federal Aviation Administration said Thursday.

One of the jets was headed for Denver International Airport.

The jets were less than two miles apart and headed toward each other at 500 mph when on-board collision alarms went off, leading both airplanes to take evasive action, the Chicago Tribune and WBBM-TV reported on their Web sites, citing the FAA and air traffic controllers.

A call placed to the FAA by The Associated Press late Thursday was not immediately returned.

A controller also helped prevent the planes -- flying at about 30,000 feet -- from crashing into each other, according to the controllers union.

The Tuesday incident involved a United Express commuter jet headed to O'Hare from Lincoln, Neb. and a Northwest Airlines Boeing 757-- about 900 feet higher -- en route to Denver from Detroit, the FAA said.

The FAA is investigating the incident as a violation of a requirement for a 1,000-foot minimum vertical separation between planes.

The federal agency attributed the near-collision to a mistake by a controller at the agency's Chicago Center radar facility in Aurora, Ill.; the center directs high-altitude traffic over sections of the Midwest.

The National Air Traffic Controllers Association, however, says the controller responsible for the planes and an assistant became distracted by a new technology being tested at the time.

"The planes were closing in on each other and the controller took action to keep the planes separated," Toby Hauck, union vice president at the Aurora center, said.

The FAA, however, said the controller wasn't working with the new technology.

"The controller lost track of where the planes were and they lost separation," FAA spokesman Tony Molinaro said.

The investigation of the incident is continuing, he said.

clicker
20th Jan 2007, 02:07
Comments suggest the NWA was only 100ft lower than he should have been so "evasive action" is perhaps a little OTT. But then it wont sell papers just saying he was only 100ft away from his assign level.

Did also like the comment "the controller took action to keep the planes separated". Thought that was in his job description. :ok:

I would suggest the union was, understandable, protecting their member from the flak as with "less than two mile range" and a TCAS activation the crew probally did the job themselves and then informed the controller.