PDA

View Full Version : job hazards: car racing vs. heli flying


rotorfan
27th Feb 2001, 10:17
Forwarded from a friend:

"This is worth a read...I think this may put things in perspective as to
where our priorities really are as a nation. Think about it.

Subject: FW: NASCAR and Perspective. - Lest we forget...

On 18 February 2001, while racing for fame and fortune, Dale Earnhardt died
in the last lap of the Daytona 500. It was surely a tragedy for his family,
friends and fans. He was 49 years old with grown children, one, which was
in the race. I am new to the NASCAR culture so much of what I know has come
from the newspaper and TV. He was a winner and earned everything he had.
This included more than "$41 million in winnings and ten times that from
endorsements and souvenir sales". He had a beautiful home and a private
jet. He drove the most sophisticated cars allowed and every part was
inspected and replaced as soon as there was any evidence of wear. This is
normally fully funded by the car and team sponsors. Today, there is no TV
station that does not constantly remind us of his tragic end and the radio
already has a song of tribute to this winning driver. Nothing should be
taken away from this man, he was a professional and the best in his
profession. He was in a very dangerous business but the rewards were great.

Two weeks ago seven U.S. Army soldiers died in a training accident when two
UH-60 Blackhawk helicopters collided during night maneuvers in Hawaii. The
soldiers were all in their twenties, pilots, crewchiefs and infantrymen.
Most of them lived in sub-standard housing. If you add their actual duty
hours (in the field, deployed) they probably earn something close to minimum
wage. The aircraft they were in were between
15 and 20 years old. Many times parts were not available to keep them in
good shape due to funding. They were involved in the extremely dangerous
business of flying in the Kuhuku mountains at night. It only gets worse
when the weather moves in as it did that night. Most times no one is there
with a yellow or red flag to slow things down when it gets critical. Their
children were mostly toddlers who will lose all memory of who "Daddy" was as
they grow up. They died training to defend our freedom.

I take nothing away from Dale Earnhardt but ask you to perform this simple
test. Ask any of your friends if they know who was the NASCAR driver killed
on 18 February 2001. Then ask them if they can name one of the seven
soldiers who died in Hawaii two weeks ago.

18 February 2001, Dale Earnhardt died driving for fame and glory at the
Daytona 500. The nation mourns. Seven soldiers died training to protect
our freedom. No one can remember their names and most don't even remember
the incident.

...as forwarded to me by a career helo pilot, who's flown in the dark in the
rain, with distances between your blades and Mother Earth being measured in
feet ... a bit sobering if I do say so. Alas, tomorrow we shall continue
the mission and launch to meet the sortie count and the training objectives.

For the record:

The six identified casualties were Maj.Robert L. Olson of Minnesota;Chief
Warrant Officer George P.Perry and Chief Warrant Officer Gregory
I.Montgomery, both of California; Sgt. Thomas E. Barber of Champlin,Minn.;
Specialist Bob D. MacDonald of Alta Loma, Calif.; and Specialist Rafael
Olvera-Rodriguez of El Paso.

Perhaps you could pass on to others..... "

Ed Winchester
27th Feb 2001, 11:08
Rotorfan,

It kind of puts things into perspective as I rise to go and fly my plastic pursuit ship in the freshly fallen snow. The famous/rich will be remembered - that is a fact of life. The rest of us just soldier on!

My condolences to all of the deceased mentioned.



[This message has been edited by Ed Winchester (edited 27 February 2001).]

hoverbover
27th Feb 2001, 13:35
Rotorfan

My condolences to all families of the deceased, a very sad time for all.

Being in both camps (heli flyer and racing driver)I feel for all mentioned and quite agree with your thoughts.

I think the real problem lies with the press, they look for what will sell, not what is true news.You only have to look at the number of deaths in car accidents which are not reported, but if a heli has an accident it makes national news (in the UK)and if that person is "famous" !!!!!

I feel any death is tragic however caused,and the press are really the ones to blame for the inequality in the reporting.

Regards
hoverbover

Randy_g
27th Feb 2001, 14:14
Well stated Hoverbover. If it's sensational, it's "good" news. Stuff that great ratings are made of. A couple of days ago, the cricket world lost an icon (not the insect). Now a mention in the news is justified, as he was one, if not the best player in the history of the game. Now I personally don't think that 2 days newscasts (amongst numerous other dedication shows) need to be devoted to this person, no matter who he is, or what he has done. I offer my condolences to his, and Dale Earnhardts families. These peoples jobs were to play a game, or drive a car really fast, but it is a sport, little more than a game.

The folks who lose their lives saving others, or protecting us deserve just as much of our attention. After all they actually add to our way of life, don't they. Sports are a diversion, something for us to do on time-off, or watch others play. It's entertainment. Sports stars earn millions per year. Yet those who mould our future, (teachers) get peanuts, the same goes for those who protect us. (be they military, police, nurses, ambo's) It just seems silly to me. I wonder how many people could go to university with what Alex Rodriguez will make in one year ?? Or how many hospital beds could be opened, or how much an OR waiting list could be shortened.

It's a tragedy when anyone dies, no matter who they are. My thoughts go out to anyone who loses a family member or friend.

Cheers

Randy_G

If you can't stand the heat ...

Then turn up the airconditioning !! :)

Pac Rotors
28th Feb 2001, 00:25
HoverBover,

Dont class all us media people in the same catergory. I have been in the helo industry for many years and have been writing about the industry for many years. Have never sensationalised the bad side of things and always cover the pro active and positive side of things.

I have seen a lot of my friends die in helos and also saw one racing driver so I have also seen and reported on both sides.

PR http://www.pprune.org/ubb/NonCGI/cool.gif

hoverbover
28th Feb 2001, 01:01
Pac Rotors

Sorry for the using the term Press generally, as you rightly say there are SOME very honourable reporters out there, but in my experiences they are few and far between.

My critiscisms are aimed more at the mainstream reporters of news, and not the more specialized news.



A classic example of this was when David Coulthard (Formula 1 Driver)was involved in the Lear Jet accident last year, the news was full of what a "hero" he was etc etc. No mention of the fact that Two Pilots were killed, and that they were the real hero's.

As I said earlier. I am sorry for using the Press term generally, but I am sure you will agree that there are lots of the Press which do not have your values nor morals!

Regards
hoverbover

Pac Rotors
28th Feb 2001, 03:11
No problems, I know exactly what you mean. Have had same sort of conversations with general media around the place when it comes to helicopter accidents etc.

PR http://www.pprune.org/ubb/NonCGI/cool.gif

DPW
28th Feb 2001, 07:47
I live in the hotbed of NASCAR fandom, and I can see the overreaction to Earnhardt's death first hand. More to the point, how many of us in the rotary wing industry have had friends die in the performance of their duties? Do they deserve any less recognition than a race car driver? Of course not. I, for one, didn't even know about the Blackhawk accident. I didn't know any of the men involved, but I do sympathize with their families. Perhaps the recognition by newsmedia isn't the reason they were out there risking their lives?????

rotorspeed
28th Feb 2001, 19:17
We need to be clear what the media are doing, and that is reporting according to public interest. The public are a lot more interested in reading/hearing about high profile celebrity deaths, which is why they generate more space in the media. Simple.

Don't forget, it works both ways though, when someone unknown gets caught speeeding in a car, for example, it generates no press. Your high profile celebrity/politician etc generates a big story.

Let's not confuse extent of media exposure with the level of respect and value of life, which of course is the same regardless of fame.

And let's be honest, we'll all read the story of the celeb road death ahead of the unknown. The media just give their customers what they want.

Pac Rotors
1st Mar 2001, 02:38
It would be great if the newspaper type media would cover the important EMS type rescues as well as other high profile events that helos do instead of just the accidents. But then again thats probably too much to ask.

PR http://www.pprune.org/ubb/NonCGI/cool.gif