PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Airlines, Airports & Routes (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes-85/)
-   -   Edinburgh-3 (https://www.pprune.org/airlines-airports-routes/600425-edinburgh-3-a.html)

CabinCrewe 11th May 2019 22:16


Originally Posted by cuthere (Post 10469223)
Just popping by. I thought I was viewing the Edinburgh thread. My mistake....!

LOL! Its the old grandeur above station again that leads to this..😴

cuthere 11th May 2019 23:01


LOL! Its the old grandeur above station again that leads to this..��
You been drinking? Maybe I’m naive after 15 years on here; however, can you explain to me the direct relevance of what carrier is using what aircraft FROM MANCHESTER TO AMERICA to this thread?

I like reading about Edinburgh and its routes etc on the Edinburgh thread. Were I to be interested in another airport, I would read the relevant thread. Apologies for my grandeur above station. I’m also a stickler for apostrophes. Maybe use one the next time you’re abbreviating “it” and “is” to “it’s”. Cheers!

Rutan16 12th May 2019 14:03

It’s relevant only that it’s correcting erroneous information posted on this particular thread by others .



CabinCrewe 12th May 2019 16:47


Originally Posted by cuthere (Post 10469304)


You been drinking? Maybe I’m naive after 15 years on here; however, can you explain to me the direct relevance of what carrier is using what aircraft FROM MANCHESTER TO AMERICA to this thread?

I like reading about Edinburgh and its routes etc on the Edinburgh thread. Were I to be interested in another airport, I would read the relevant thread. Apologies for my grandeur above station. I’m also a stickler for apostrophes. Maybe use one the next time you’re abbreviating “it” and “is” to “it’s”. Cheers!

The reference was to the usual EDI posters claiming EDI is entitled to widebodies on a par with MAN.
If I want a grammar lesson, it most certainly "wont" be from you.

VickersVicount 12th May 2019 16:50


Originally Posted by CabinCrewe (Post 10469690)
If I want a grammar lesson, it most certainly "wont" be from you.

LOL! Anyway, back to EDI... What about this HA debacle?

sinbad73 12th May 2019 18:17


Originally Posted by VickersVicount (Post 10469691)

LOL! Anyway, back to EDI... What about this HA debacle?

HU.

HA is Hawaiian.

ld0595 12th May 2019 19:15

Could be switching to summer seasonal, could be completely suspended. Seems like management don't even know.

A quote from this article: Scotland’s direct air link to China faces axe


Edinburgh Airport said it was waiting to hear from the airline whether flights would resume next summer.
A spokesman said: “We understand this is a suspension of the route over the winter. We’re bitterly disappointed and there will be no let-up in our efforts to maintain Scotland’s only direct link to China and the Far East – but having the most expensive aviation tax in the world doesn’t help.”

Asturias56 13th May 2019 08:11

Just looking at LHR-EDI mid August - almost all the flights "only have 3/4/6 tickets left"

Is this real and if so is it always like this???

And it's £ 170++ one way..............

inOban 13th May 2019 08:25

Edinburgh Festival?

ATNotts 13th May 2019 08:54


Originally Posted by ld0595 (Post 10469762)
Could be switching to summer seasonal, could be completely suspended. Seems like management don't even know.

A quote from this article: Scotland’s direct air link to China faces axe

The Chinese tour operator CAISA will be bank rolling the operation, if CAISA aren't happy with take up on PEK/EDI they will consolidate their bookings on to PEK/MAN. If they want to give EDI another crack they'll possibly resume for summer, perhaps just peak summer, 2020.

BHX managed 2 season with CAISA before Hainan / CAISA jumped into bed with MAN and there is now hardly even a slim chance that there'll be a direct PEK/BHX in the medium term. Sadly same may well happen with EDI. Whatever, the real high revenue business traffic will continue to reside in the UK where it always has done - London; home of the largest number of billionaires of any global city - according the the Sunday Times Rich List.

inOban 13th May 2019 10:13

Is the fact that the Dublin to Shenzhen route is continuing the key? For business traffic a route to South China would surely have been better.
I do notice that the HU route to Oslo continues. Perhaps EDI as an extension of that would be better.

willy wombat 13th May 2019 10:29

What I would really, really like to know (but never will) is whether various services that run for a while then stop are attracted by sweetheart deals, discounts, marketing support etc and when that runs out the route doesn't prove to be viable. And another thing, it is time that Scottish airport managements stopped going on about APD. It's not going to go away, it's not going to be reduced (manifesto or no manifesto) and businesses need to plan on that basis. I will, however, accept complaints about the Brexit omnishambles.

VickersVicount 13th May 2019 10:59


Originally Posted by inOban (Post 10470159)
Perhaps EDI as an extension of that would be better.

Why? I doubt the inbound Chinese tourist really cares (if they've committed to what might be a double drop) whether its OSL or DUB.
If it is prestige Chinese business EDI are after, this is the wrong airline/product, wrong frequency and needs (always) to be direct.
Cathay Pacific 4-5 times per week, A35G, direct to HKG would have a far better chance. Much nicer product, well known, redivert some LHR OW connections. Would be surprised to see this happen though in current climate. If there were indeed generous incentives for HA could there be for others?

Rob Royston 13th May 2019 11:41

When I saw that the flight was feeding two airports at this end I feared the worst. On a lot of routes from Europe to Africa that's what happened when the bigger modern jets arrived with passengers on the second drop having over an hour added to their journey times each way. Very few local passengers used the flight to/from the second airport, it was mostly business people and oil workers plus lots of oilfied cargo.
It also meant that the return overnight flights missed the early connections to places like Dublin, Edinburgh etc leading to more lost time.
The Chinese travellers probably get put off as well if the flight does not go directly to their chosen destination.

nighthawk117 13th May 2019 20:02


Originally Posted by Rob Royston (Post 10470212)
When I saw that the flight was feeding two airports at this end I feared the worst. On a lot of routes from Europe to Africa that's what happened when the bigger modern jets arrived with passengers on the second drop having over an hour added to their journey times each way. Very few local passengers used the flight to/from the second airport, it was mostly business people and oil workers plus lots of oilfied cargo.
It also meant that the return overnight flights missed the early connections to places like Dublin, Edinburgh etc leading to more lost time.
The Chinese travellers probably get put off as well if the flight does not go directly to their chosen destination.

Why does everyone keep fixating on the fact its a double drop? Just book on the days it operates directly to/from EDI! I'm pretty sure the vast majority of passengers managed to work that one out. Only those desperate to get to EDI on the days it operates PEK-DUB-EDI would book on that flight, and even then they probably got there quicker than connecting at a hub.

CabinCrewe 13th May 2019 20:42


Originally Posted by nighthawk117 (Post 10470544)
Why does everyone keep fixating on the fact its a double drop? Just book on the days it operates directly to/from EDI! I'm pretty sure the vast majority of passengers managed to work that one out. Only those desperate to get to EDI on the days it operates PEK-DUB-EDI would book on that flight, and even then they probably got there quicker than connecting at a hub.

Why bother at all with it then?

Skipness One Foxtrot 14th May 2019 10:53


Originally Posted by nighthawk117 (Post 10468152)
As for the United / Delta examples - i'm not convinced. Look at Manchester, with its much larger catchment, yet it's still narrowbody central to the US. With the exception of the United flight which upgraded this year, it's all 757s. These aircraft are perfect for operating flights to the UK, freeing up widebodies for flights further in to Europe.

Not quite, the Delta JV has seen Virgin having a B744 / A330 base which is now the same size as Gatwick. American fly the A332 on PHL leaving United with a seasonal B757 / B767 mix.
But yes, fair point about the inbound passenger profile.

CabinCrewe 14th May 2019 11:08


Originally Posted by Skipness One Foxtrot (Post 10470965)
leaving United with s seasonal B757 / B767 mix.

When is the 757 next planned for UA from MAN?

VickersVicount 14th May 2019 11:11


inOban 14th May 2019 15:44


Originally Posted by CabinCrewe (Post 10470573)

Why bother at all with it then?

I can only think that the Chinese tourists are on a two-centre holiday to both Scotland and Ireland. It makes no sense to the ordinary traveller.
Has anyone noticed how slack is the schedule? It's allowed 10 hours and 50 minutes eastbound, AIRC, but usually takes just 9, arriving in Beijing about 3am.


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:45.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.