Overhead locker injury BA
Resident insomniac
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: N54 58 34 W02 01 21
Age: 79
Posts: 1,873
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Some years ago, there was an instance where many coin dealers were flying to a 'convention' (where they could also trade coins).
Apparently, the cabin baggage was significantly 'overweight' as each trader was carrying as much as they could lift in their hand luggage.
Apparently, the cabin baggage was significantly 'overweight' as each trader was carrying as much as they could lift in their hand luggage.
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Canada
Age: 37
Posts: 630
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Carry on bags in NZ are only 7kgs 
And they actually do check the weight of them prior to customs.
As soon as you walk through the doors, there is a person standing there with a set of scales. If your bags look like they are over 7kgs, they will stop you and ask to weigh the bags. If they are over, back down to check in you go.
Works quite well and no long queues. Quite a few heavy bags slip by but for the most part, the extreme ones are stopped.
And they actually do check the weight of them prior to customs.
As soon as you walk through the doors, there is a person standing there with a set of scales. If your bags look like they are over 7kgs, they will stop you and ask to weigh the bags. If they are over, back down to check in you go.
Works quite well and no long queues. Quite a few heavy bags slip by but for the most part, the extreme ones are stopped.
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: UK
Posts: 3
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A while back I've been asked at Southampton when checking in to put my hold baggage on Scales...
and then to put the hand baggage on as well to check it is within the weight limits specified.
and then to put the hand baggage on as well to check it is within the weight limits specified.
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: world
Posts: 3,424
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Weighing hand baggage at check-in is only effective to a point. If one is being seen off by friends or family it's easy to make sure your hand baggage weighs in below limits whilst someone else holds the offending extra kilos of stuff out of sight.
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Australia
Posts: 1,307
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was chastised at the check-in at Narita for having a heavy cabin bag. All I had in it was a small Macbook with power adaptors, an SLR and smaller camera, an electric toothbrush and a spare pair of shoes. Surely this isn't excessive?
Having said that, the single most weighty item was the (wheeled) cabin bag itself. I see how this alone could cause injury, especially if it fell on a seated passenger. Do we ban these?
Having said that, the single most weighty item was the (wheeled) cabin bag itself. I see how this alone could cause injury, especially if it fell on a seated passenger. Do we ban these?
Wheel-it-on baggage
Precisely! When carry-on becomes wheel-it-on this immediately implies HEAVY.
And why every six year-old needs one for a two hour flight beggars belief.
And why every six year-old needs one for a two hour flight beggars belief.
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Paris
Age: 74
Posts: 275
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Let me see. Every checked bag is xrayed for security and any stuff like laptops, cameras etc gets stolen by the handlers who have compulsory access. My camera stuff weighs 5 kgs, my laptop and ipad 4kg, how am I supposed to travel with a 7kg carry on?
BTW I would be ready to travel naked and even wait for luggage, thereby minimizing security searches, if the airline made a real effort to get my winter coat laptop and camera to wherever I am going.
Edmund
BTW I would be ready to travel naked and even wait for luggage, thereby minimizing security searches, if the airline made a real effort to get my winter coat laptop and camera to wherever I am going.
Edmund
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: San Jose
Posts: 727
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's all very well weighing bags early in the process, but what about those who load up in the duty-free shop? It is trivial to circumvent a check-in weight, and speaking personally, if I've got a mid-afternoon flight then I may well be carrying lunch with me at check-in. Although it's going to make the flight, it's not going to be in the carry-on bag when I board the aircraft.
What would be far more use is an early size check, on the basis that some of what I see in the boarding queue is really taking the piss when it comes to size. If there has to be a weight check, it needs to be in the run-up to boarding, by which time all stuff to be carried on should have been acquired. It might also make the flight safer, by giving the flight crew a more accurate weight for carry-on.
What would be far more use is an early size check, on the basis that some of what I see in the boarding queue is really taking the piss when it comes to size. If there has to be a weight check, it needs to be in the run-up to boarding, by which time all stuff to be carried on should have been acquired. It might also make the flight safer, by giving the flight crew a more accurate weight for carry-on.
Security seems to me a poor place to enforce baggage weight restrictions.
The weight limits for carry-on baggage are clearly shown on the tickets - 7Kg in OZ.
Ensure the baggage (size and weight) are within limits at the boarding gate.
If the SLF cannot stick within the limits for the baggage, leave the overweight/oversize baggage behind to travel as freight on the next service. Been there, done that.
Once it happens a few times, "social media" will spread the word quickly.
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: EDDM
Posts: 109
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Some A32S bin latches are only rated for 32KG (total) so many (European) airlines restrict handluggage to 8KG max/piece. BA is not one of them for some reason.
LX in ZRH and OS in VIE has G4S security staff standing before security and sending you to check-in your bag when overweight.
LX in ZRH and OS in VIE has G4S security staff standing before security and sending you to check-in your bag when overweight.
Join Date: May 2014
Location: CNX
Age: 80
Posts: 25
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What Really Happened ?
Despite all the discussion, we really do not know what happened, nor the nature of the problem.
Firstly, was the carry-on overweight? Did the injury occur while the SLF or member of the CC was placing it in the overhead ? Did they lose their grip and drop the carry-on bag ? Was the injury to the owner of the bag, or to some unfortunate soul who was already seated under the bin ? -- and finally, did this occur during boarding, while in flight ( bin collapse or cover failure) or during deplaning ? Each of these questions can lead to a very different discussion. Does anyone know ?
While asking if anyone knows, how do they handle an FAA approved oxygen concentrator in OZ ? The smallest I have seen is about 8 kg and is approved as cabin luggage, if required by the passenger, in most of the world.
Firstly, was the carry-on overweight? Did the injury occur while the SLF or member of the CC was placing it in the overhead ? Did they lose their grip and drop the carry-on bag ? Was the injury to the owner of the bag, or to some unfortunate soul who was already seated under the bin ? -- and finally, did this occur during boarding, while in flight ( bin collapse or cover failure) or during deplaning ? Each of these questions can lead to a very different discussion. Does anyone know ?
While asking if anyone knows, how do they handle an FAA approved oxygen concentrator in OZ ? The smallest I have seen is about 8 kg and is approved as cabin luggage, if required by the passenger, in most of the world.
Last edited by RF4; 18th Dec 2015 at 06:52. Reason: Typo
did this occur during boarding, while in flight ( bin collapse or cover failure) or during deplaning
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Oxford, UK
Posts: 1,546
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Away back in December 1970, my family moved from Berkeley California to Britain. My oldest son had learned to scuba dive in California, and insisted on bringing his diving kit, including the weight belt! it didn't go in the overhead, however, he just wore it under his jacket.....
Join Date: Nov 2015
Location: BRS/GVA
Posts: 342
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It strikes me that the bigger problem is the unknown total weight and balance of the aircraft. Since there is a significant amount of this unweighed baggage entering the AC. Its one thing to estimate it, but if you have a coin convention or a dive trip (see below) it could be significant.
I have used this trick myself as a diver on a low cost airline. Put the heavy stuff in my hand luggage (regulators, torches etc) and i end up with a 14kg hand luggage and a 20kg hold luggage. Thus avoiding the ridiculous sports equipment charges.
The problem is that people find a way to make systems work for them.
I would say its sensible to limit the size (to something like a small backpack, satchel) and weight to 5kg (no wheels), and increase the hold luggage back to 23/25kg as it used to be.
Its enough to allow the valuables to be carried, and mothers to look after kids.
I also think the carriage of alcohol in bins should be stopped. Hundreds of litres of flammable liquid in the cabin. I forget which accident it was, but it was highlighted as causing accelerated spread of fire and death in at least one case.
I have used this trick myself as a diver on a low cost airline. Put the heavy stuff in my hand luggage (regulators, torches etc) and i end up with a 14kg hand luggage and a 20kg hold luggage. Thus avoiding the ridiculous sports equipment charges.
The problem is that people find a way to make systems work for them.
I would say its sensible to limit the size (to something like a small backpack, satchel) and weight to 5kg (no wheels), and increase the hold luggage back to 23/25kg as it used to be.
Its enough to allow the valuables to be carried, and mothers to look after kids.
I also think the carriage of alcohol in bins should be stopped. Hundreds of litres of flammable liquid in the cabin. I forget which accident it was, but it was highlighted as causing accelerated spread of fire and death in at least one case.
Join Date: May 2003
Location: All over the place
Posts: 336
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Having worked for said airline, the hang luggage size/weight has been an on going issue. The company is scared of upsetting it's pax (particularly it's gold card holders) and as such seem is very lenient with what is let on board. The numbers of gate staff has gradually reduced, so they (not all, some are very proactive) struggle to police what is coming on board. Many a time, the crew are left with numerous wheelie bags in the galley during boarding on the A320 family due to a lack of space. The procedure is for the dispatcher (TRM) to close the door, remove the airbridge, then reattach the airbridge and open the door to off load bags, this making it a handing delay. However, many a time, the airbridge doesn't come back.
I flew with American Eagle a couple of years ago, only the agent boarding the flight, yet she managed to check every passengers' item of hand luggage and tagged that was too big, impressive.
Another issue is 'hand baggage only' fares. So, pax bring on their worldly possessions, some of them look like buckaroo.
Then you have those who have connected off from a 747/777/A380 and think that their crate will fit into the locker of a A319.
I hope that the passenger recovered and I hope that the airline will finally start looking into more strict guidelines.
I flew with American Eagle a couple of years ago, only the agent boarding the flight, yet she managed to check every passengers' item of hand luggage and tagged that was too big, impressive.
Another issue is 'hand baggage only' fares. So, pax bring on their worldly possessions, some of them look like buckaroo.
Then you have those who have connected off from a 747/777/A380 and think that their crate will fit into the locker of a A319.
I hope that the passenger recovered and I hope that the airline will finally start looking into more strict guidelines.
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: London
Posts: 391
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When bean-counters started charging for hold baggage,the encouragement is to stuff as much as you can into the cabin. When you start having to place cabin baggage under the seat in front because it won't fit or there is no room in the overhead, compromised safety is surely an issue ? Try fast evacuation with bags impeding your exit . Someone else alluded to the weight issue. Just how heavy is your aircraft these days ? Tons of stuff in the cabin, not correctly shown on the load-sheet. And all this, traced back to greedy companies charging for hold-baggage.
Just booked up for my Xmas break. Airline states check-in at reception compulsory, no prior "on-line" nonsense. Hold baggage goes free. Meal provided. ICAO limitation on hand-baggage. All this for not much more than the cheapo flights with all the add-ons. Sheer joy. I am going to use this company over and over and over again !
Just booked up for my Xmas break. Airline states check-in at reception compulsory, no prior "on-line" nonsense. Hold baggage goes free. Meal provided. ICAO limitation on hand-baggage. All this for not much more than the cheapo flights with all the add-ons. Sheer joy. I am going to use this company over and over and over again !