PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Accidents and Close Calls (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls-139/)
-   -   Mid-air collision at Wilson Apt Nairobi Kenya (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/657979-mid-air-collision-wilson-apt-nairobi-kenya.html)

PC767 5th Mar 2024 10:08

Kenya mid air incident
 
https://news.sky.com/story/kenya-two...craft-13087682

SRMman 5th Mar 2024 10:12

Nairobi National Park Midair Collision
 
"At least two people were killed after two planes collided at the Nairobi National Park, police said.

About 44 others escaped unhurt in the Tuesday morning incident. The incident involved a Dash 8 registration number 5YSLK belonging to Safari Link which was headed for Diani with 44 passengers and five crew and a Cesna plane.

The Cesna registration number 5YNNJ had two people on board and was on a training session when the incident happened, police said."

Sounds very lucky for the Dash 8 . . .



ETOPS 5th Mar 2024 10:13

Mid-air collision at Wilson Apt Nairobi Kenya
 
Dash 8-300 departing Wilson HKNW collided with a Cessna 172 also operating from Wilson - 2 fatalities in the Cessna

https://avherald.com/h?article=515c1179&opt=0

ETOPS 5th Mar 2024 13:33

No photos yet of the damage to the Dash 8 or visual confirmation of the registration. Doesn't appear on any tracking website at that time....

double_barrel 5th Mar 2024 15:32

Sorry to say this, but the surprising thing is that this has not happened before.

i would bet the dash 8 was departing on 14 and the c172 was doing touch and goes on 07. ATC routinely allow the situation in which a training a/c doing circuits on 07, flies over the top of departing a/c. It’s always made me uncomfortable. All they have to do is hold the departing a/c for 30 seconds longer.

could have been much worse.

JanetFlight 5th Mar 2024 18:43

Apparently the midair took place this morning, the day is almost finishing, Kenya its not a Sudan or Yemen, and no further details, pics, videos, etc, has surfaced the aviation foruns, pages, etc....weird... :ooh:

SRMman 5th Mar 2024 20:43

I’ve found this, doesn’t look like enough damage to bring down the Cessna.

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....198b74692d.png

bluesideoops 5th Mar 2024 22:19

Enough to down a Cessna https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase/352214

DIBO 5th Mar 2024 22:19


Originally Posted by SRMman (Post 11609705)
doesn’t look like enough damage to bring down the Cessna.

I think it's difficult to judge. Long time ago I watched a Brasilia (EMB120) come in to land in a hurry with damage to the nose (mainly the "plastic" radome). A minute earlier it had taken down a twin-engine Piper in a mid-air on the upwind leg.

Pilot DAR 5th Mar 2024 22:34


I’ve found this, doesn’t look like enough damage to bring down the Cessna
Very certainly this much damage to a Dash 8 could be fatal to a 172. Presuming the possibility that the Dash 8 H stab hit a trailing edge of the Cessna ('cause the Dash 8 is faster), a crunched Cessna flight control could make the airplane entirely unflyable. I've had minor aileron trailing edge damage on a 182 and on a Aztec which made trimmed flight very difficult.

helialan 6th Mar 2024 02:32

Wilson has become dangerous beyond any acceptable limit. Overcrowded on the ground and in the circuit.. Poster No 5 has the most likely scenario. I have had 2 TCAS RA under exactly that scenario.

double_barrel 6th Mar 2024 04:22


Originally Posted by helialan (Post 11609821)
Wilson has become dangerous beyond any acceptable limit. Overcrowded on the ground and in the circuit.. Poster No 5 has the most likely scenario. I have had 2 TCAS RA under exactly that scenario.

Indeed, I no longer fly out of Wilson, it is just not an enjoyable experience. A while ago it was fun; a bit wild west, but busy and challenging. The last straw for me was actually the petty and stupid security. But on the ground and in the air it's pretty chaotic. Some operators have shockingly low standards, I recently flew as pax on a Fokker-50 operated by a certain company and their procedures were dangerous beyond belief. there's a lethal mix of training C150s and C172s packed into the circuit with a stream of commercial stuff coming in and out. The choke points off the end of 14 and around Monastery are total mayhem.

Peter H 6th Mar 2024 12:56

Newspaper report of the story and pictures of the crashed Cessna at:
https://eastleighvoice.co.ke/nationa...ide-in-nairobi


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:27.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.