PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Accidents and Close Calls (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls-139/)
-   -   Four injured on United after lithium battery catches fire (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/651237-four-injured-united-after-lithium-battery-catches-fire.html)

voyageur9 7th Feb 2023 20:35

Four injured on United after lithium battery catches fire
 
Four people were taken to the hospital after an external battery caught fire on a United Airlines flight early Tuesday, officials said.

Shortly after takeoff, the device was found on fire inside a seat back pocket of first class, United told ABC News.

https://abcnews.go.com/US/4-injured-...ry?id=96953705

DroneDog 8th Feb 2023 10:05

Best wishes to the crew, this needs to be policed before a really major incident occurs, on check-in, maybe a requirement to demonstrate the laptop has only 20% or less battery reserve thru security before boarding, less stored energy should things go wrong.

ehwatezedoing 8th Feb 2023 11:07


Originally Posted by DroneDog (Post 11382163)
Best wishes to the crew, this needs to be policed before a really major incident occurs, on check-in, maybe a requirement to demonstrate the laptop has only 20% or less battery reserve thru security before boarding, less stored energy should things go wrong.

Less cheapo made in China's one would probably do the trick.

ZFT 8th Feb 2023 11:29


Originally Posted by DroneDog (Post 11382163)
Best wishes to the crew, this needs to be policed before a really major incident occurs, on check-in, maybe a requirement to demonstrate the laptop has only 20% or less battery reserve thru security before boarding, less stored energy should things go wrong.

Seems a bit pointless with charging points in most seats now.

pilotmike 8th Feb 2023 19:55


Originally Posted by DroneDog (Post 11382163)
Best wishes to the crew, this needs to be policed before a really major incident occurs, on check-in, maybe a requirement to demonstrate the laptop has only 20% or less battery reserve thru security before boarding, less stored energy should things go wrong.

Perhaps counter-intuitively, some lithium chemistry (lithium Ion, I believe) batteries can be at significant risk of catching fire when deeply discharged. Keeping most lithium chemistry batteries near to 50% is a safe level for them. It seems the danger does not tally closely with the remaining charge in the battery.

So it is not as simple as checking batteries are under 20% charged.

BFSGrad 8th Feb 2023 22:16

Listening to the ATC audio, emergency compounded by loss of transmit audio from United when pilots masked up. ATC handled it like a boss!

Bksmithca 8th Feb 2023 22:52


Originally Posted by ZFT (Post 11382201)
Seems a bit pointless with charging points in most seats now.

That nice but what does an individual do when there out in the middle of a field. Go chance the external battery wasn't ment for use on the plane but possibly elsewhere

ZFT 8th Feb 2023 23:49


Originally Posted by Bksmithca (Post 11382545)
That nice but what does an individual do when there out in the middle of a field. Go chance the external battery wasn't ment for use on the plane but possibly elsewhere

I have no idea what you mean?

Bksmithca 9th Feb 2023 00:12


Originally Posted by ZFT (Post 11382558)
I have no idea what you mean?

The external battery allows users to recharge the internal battery on cell phones, handheld GPS units. All of these things can be used off the airplane where there is no plug-ins available

India Four Two 9th Feb 2023 00:38

Here’s the audio:

https://forums.liveatc.net/index.php...0;attach=11582

Bill Harris 22nd Feb 2023 01:22


Originally Posted by Bksmithca (Post 11382563)
The external battery allows users to recharge the internal battery on cell phones, handheld GPS units. All of these things can be used off the airplane where there is no plug-ins available

Exactly. I have a small 5000mAh external Lithium battery that I use to recharge or supplement my Smartphone's battery when I'm traveling. Apparently someone left a bad or defective battery inside a seatpocket.

Capn Bloggs 22nd Feb 2023 02:21


The external battery

​​​​​​​small 5000mAh external Lithium battery
A powerbank.

Andrewgr2 22nd Feb 2023 05:42


Originally Posted by ehwatezedoing (Post 11382194)
Less cheapo made in China's one would probably do the trick.

Aren’t they all made in China?

fdr 26th Feb 2023 02:51


Originally Posted by Bksmithca (Post 11382563)
The external battery allows users to recharge the internal battery on cell phones, handheld GPS units. All of these things can be used off the airplane where there is no plug-ins available

and are usually available at any electrical retailer, most inbound duty free shops, and many gas stations.

Denti 26th Feb 2023 09:26

And of course in nearly every terminal past check in and security in the commonplace electronic shops, and rechargeable via in-seat power outlets.

old-timer 5th Mar 2023 20:47

Fully agree, was saying this 10 years ago when I worked in part 21J cabin design, disaster waiting to happen,

henra 6th Mar 2023 18:50


Originally Posted by pilotmike (Post 11382446)
Perhaps counter-intuitively, some lithium chemistry (lithium Ion, I believe) batteries can be at significant risk of catching fire when deeply discharged.

That is not exactly correct. As long as they are deeply discharged nothing can happen. The problem with deep- discharging is that it damages the separator inside the cell. There are chemical processes which happen when a LiPo/LiIon cell drops beneath 3,0V per cell. These processes decrease the internal resistance between the active layers. When after such a deep- discharge the battery is charged again, the risk of a fire are extremely increased due to this internal short- circuit. The cell heats up, the polymer separator foil melts and a full- blown short circuit will happen at some stage. That is what happens in a so called Thermal Runaway. That is why deep- discharging is considered a fire hazard with LiPos/LiIons. As long as the cells are completely empty you can drive a screw driver through a cell and nothing will happe. Do that with a cell >~60% charge state and have a nice fireworks.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:00.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.