PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Accidents and Close Calls (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls-139/)
-   -   Bembridge Accident (https://www.pprune.org/accidents-close-calls/574830-bembridge-accident.html)

Whiskey Bravo 16th Feb 2016 17:03

Bembridge Accident
 
Appears that all of the occupants thankfully escaped unscathed, but there could be some useful learnings from this accident:

Light aircraft crashes at Bembridge Airport - BBC News

The aircraft appears to be locally based and the weather this morning was benign along the south coast. In windy conditions the approach on 30 can be 'interesting' but that can't have been a factor today. Very odd.

Sallyann1234 16th Feb 2016 17:21

A little more information here:
Isle of Wight: Plane crash at Bembridge Airport,

Maoraigh1 16th Feb 2016 20:25

Could the runway be soft enough for the nose wheel to dig-in?

Sallyann1234 16th Feb 2016 21:10

It should be a pretty firm runway. This was the former Britten-Norman base so used for much heavier aircraft.

3wheels 16th Feb 2016 23:36

And it's made of concrete!:rolleyes:

The Ancient Geek 17th Feb 2016 00:41

It takes a lot to invert a 172 with 4 people on board.
Possibly left the runway and dug into soft grass ?

ShyTorque 17th Feb 2016 00:47

Two observations: From the photos, the nose wheel looks to be heavily discoloured by mud.

Secondly, according to the report, the pilot was on board :D

3wheels 17th Feb 2016 06:19

Oh shy torque.....pleaseeee let them carry on, they are doing soooooo well!

AndoniP 17th Feb 2016 08:14

Can you still land on the grass strip alongside the main concrete runway?

Corsairoz 17th Feb 2016 09:50

I've used Bembridge a good few times in AA5's and PA-28's in my flying past. The runway is pretty narrow, and if the wind is in the right direction some strong variations from the trees can pull you around.
I almost left the runway on more than one occasion myself to be honest :)

C

tmmorris 17th Feb 2016 11:22


Originally Posted by ShyTorque (Post 9272291)
Two observations: From the photos, the nose wheel looks to be heavily discoloured by mud.

Secondly, according to the report, the pilot was on board :D

To be fair I think they meant the pilot was a local...

Flying_Anorak 17th Feb 2016 23:45

Irrespective of wind direction I've never made a landing at Bembridge I'm completely happy with! There's a hump in the hard IIRC and the grass (between the hard and the excellent Propller Inn) used to be used by the gliding club.

GlenQuagmire 18th Feb 2016 07:06

I have only been there in a citation but I don't remember it being any more difficult that any other small airfield. If islanders and citations can get in, a 172 shouldn't struggle, especially on a half decent day

flybymike 18th Feb 2016 15:53

Last I heard the propeller inn had closed, possibly permanently.

GA facilities seem to be collapsing around us.

the_flying_cop 18th Feb 2016 15:59

Our defender got in there on many occasions without issue. Getting out was more of a challenge!

9 lives 18th Feb 2016 16:15

Isn't a Defender a kind of Land Rover?

the_flying_cop 20th Feb 2016 00:35

Step Turn, in case you were not having a good wheeze, the defender was the 'posh' stretched turbine version of the islander.

Made the same racket as a Land Rover mind ;)

9 lives 20th Feb 2016 12:28

Ah yes, found it! Very cool! I once saw a Turbine Islander at Farnborough, but they did not seem to have a presence in North America. Shame, probably a great plane, I sure enjoyed flying the piston version.

I suppose Land Rover's marketing has been more effective than Britten Norman's!

sablatnic 21st Feb 2016 08:12

Land Rover?!?

In the good old days it came out as Trabant when we wrote Land Rover. What is happening to this forum?

Test: Land Rover LandRover land rover l a n d r o v e r

Anyway - that "funny" seems to have gone away. But laser still comes out "funny".

chevvron 21st Feb 2016 08:25

I went to Bembridge with Peter Cadbury once in his Islander, dropping off a couple of BN people who'd delivered the aircraft (GBESO) to Preston Candover after maintenance. We took off for the return journey on the BN tarmac strip north of the present paved runway which is now a taxiway, the paved runway having not yet been built!

flybymike 21st Feb 2016 12:04

That looks incredibly short. Maybe 300 metres?

chevvron 21st Feb 2016 13:59

Probably; piece of p1ss for an Islander. The 'old' Lerwick (Shetlands) strip was a similar length and had a stone barn at the end; Loganair had a special 'mod' approved which gave them (I think) 15 deg extra flap for PT flights.
We lined up on 19, the holding point being conspicuous as it was a huge patch of stinging nettles. Peter (the pilot) lowered full flap, then tripped the circuit breaker which gave him the extra flap, then it was full throttle against the brakes, yoke hard back, release brakes and it rotated after about 50yd, then check forward and climb away retracting the flaps slowly. Mind you we only had 2 passengers on board going to Unst so it was hardly overloaded.

flybymike 21st Feb 2016 16:09


We lined up on 19, the holding point being conspicuous as it was a huge patch of stinging nettles. Peter (the pilot) lowered full flap, then tripped the circuit breaker which gave him the extra flap, then it was full throttle against the brakes, yoke hard back, release brakes and it rotated after about 50yd, then check forward and climb away retracting the flaps slowly.
Surely the extra flap was for landing not take off?

the_flying_cop 21st Feb 2016 16:15

the approach over the cliffs certainly focussed the mind too!

DeRated 24th Feb 2016 20:52

Surely the extra flap was for landing not take off?
 
The electric flap settings are 0, take-off (10), Full (30). Selecting flaps down from the take-off setting would run them to 30 but if you pull the CB they will stop and remain at that position. Resetting the CB doesn't re-start the flap motor until the flap selector switch is activated (in either direction).

I've used 20 degrees to haul out of PNG mud, then using the CB eased them up to Take-off setting. Need to know by feel where the CB is....! (2nd row, 6th from the right if a 1981 memory is correct)


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:59.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.