Passengers stuck on plane wing during evacuation
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Way up North!
Posts: 76
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I’ve flown this very aircraft from both seats at flybe, it was SOP for the Captain to guard the thrust levers up to V1 so in the event of an RTO it’s the Captain who rejects and takes control (incap aside), as an FO I’d select F5 whilst we were stopping so by the time you stop it should already be set. If I remember correctly (God it’s only been 6 months) the flaps are not part of the Embraer QHR vital actions so although they should of been set it’s quite easy to forget hence the confirmation rather than select. The other reason I believe is if you evacuate after landing then more often than not you’ve already got F5 set so I believe it’s confirm rather than select to prevent the automatic mind set that you have to move the flaps before evacuating.
Last edited by Han 1st Solo; 19th Sep 2020 at 11:12.
DaveReid I quite agree with your definition of the word "confirms" but the AAIB doesn't fully agree (use of the word "suggests") and the manufacturer doesn't seem too bothered anyway as flap 1 is enough regardless.
Easy Street, VIKING9 - hehe would said computer have rejected the takeoff and initiated the evacuation at all?
Han 1st Solo thanks for your genuinely knowledgeable input!
I'll just conclude that if it is ambiguous enough to cause this discussion, I believe it should be cleared up in a revision to the QRH or FCTM, but that was not a finding of the report.
I'm going to bow out now, as it seems we are just going around in circles! But thanks for the discourse!
Easy Street, VIKING9 - hehe would said computer have rejected the takeoff and initiated the evacuation at all?
Han 1st Solo thanks for your genuinely knowledgeable input!
I'll just conclude that if it is ambiguous enough to cause this discussion, I believe it should be cleared up in a revision to the QRH or FCTM, but that was not a finding of the report.
I'm going to bow out now, as it seems we are just going around in circles! But thanks for the discourse!
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: at the edge of the alps
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It is not Embraer procedure to select flaps 5 during deceleration. It's part of the evacuation checklist only.
Hydraulics are not an issue, the flaps run on AC power. Not much of a difference, though. Once you shut down the engines, they won't move anymore.
If you look at the Embraer QRH procedure (which is in the report right below the Flybe vital items) it only requires to set the lever to 5 and does not ask to wait or check for actual deployment. (In general Embraer manufacturer's procedures cannot be lauded for consistency with normal and abnormal checklists using different naming philosophies and items used every flight referred to by ridiculously long wordings while at the same time not requiring to check a system state but rather if the lever is in the correct position.)
Regarding the position of the trailing edge flaps, there is no difference between flaps 3, 4 and 5 as only the slats move between 3 and 4/5.
It would of course make sense to mark overwing escape routes in day-glow or similar, but airlines seem to loathe painting stuff on planes that reminds passengers of emergencies (like marking exit outlines in light grey which is much less conspicuous to emergency responders than a red frame).
Hydraulics are not an issue, the flaps run on AC power. Not much of a difference, though. Once you shut down the engines, they won't move anymore.
If you look at the Embraer QRH procedure (which is in the report right below the Flybe vital items) it only requires to set the lever to 5 and does not ask to wait or check for actual deployment. (In general Embraer manufacturer's procedures cannot be lauded for consistency with normal and abnormal checklists using different naming philosophies and items used every flight referred to by ridiculously long wordings while at the same time not requiring to check a system state but rather if the lever is in the correct position.)
Regarding the position of the trailing edge flaps, there is no difference between flaps 3, 4 and 5 as only the slats move between 3 and 4/5.
It would of course make sense to mark overwing escape routes in day-glow or similar, but airlines seem to loathe painting stuff on planes that reminds passengers of emergencies (like marking exit outlines in light grey which is much less conspicuous to emergency responders than a red frame).
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: at the edge of the alps
Posts: 447
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Perth
Posts: 305
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
White Van Driver
The flaps are electrically powered on the E190/E170, not hydraulically, although shutting down the engines would also shutdown your source of AC power. (The APU is usually not running during take-offs and landings.)
The flaps are electrically powered on the E190/E170, not hydraulically, although shutting down the engines would also shutdown your source of AC power. (The APU is usually not running during take-offs and landings.)
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Auckland, NZ
Age: 79
Posts: 721
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
DavidReidUK
I know nothing about flying aeroplanes, but purely linguistically there is an ambiguity: does "Confirms Flap 5" mean "confirms that the controls are set for Flap 5" or "confirms that the flaps have actually reached the Flap 5 position"?
It is extraordinarily hard to be unambiguous.
I know nothing about flying aeroplanes, but purely linguistically there is an ambiguity: does "Confirms Flap 5" mean "confirms that the controls are set for Flap 5" or "confirms that the flaps have actually reached the Flap 5 position"?
It is extraordinarily hard to be unambiguous.
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: UK
Posts: 551
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Looking at other popular narrow bodies, the A318/319/320 has overwing exit slides. (A321 doesn't have overwing exits at all)
Last edited by TotalBeginner; 10th Oct 2020 at 13:07.
