On an even more basic level, why would you set up a private forum to 'elicit commentary', not expecting us to tell you exactly what we think and why? Are you really that naive? Even more tellingly, is how quickly you shut it down when you weren't getting the answers you expected. The fact that you obviously expected other than what you received is mind-boggling. What part of the lowest possible approval rating in EVERY area of your operation don't you get AT? The only positive respondents were other management sycophants. You are living close to the edge of disaster, and if you don't pull back soon, you will trigger the most epic collapse of an airline in the modern era. Nearly EVERY pilot is planning on leaving/retiring early. Future events will prove that point.